3 ms·
Copyright was a reasonable bargain when printing a book involved a large up-front investment of typesetting it and then printing all the copies that would ever
by kragen 5y ago
Copyright was a reasonable bargain when printing a book involved a large up-front investment of typesetting it and then printing all the copies that would ever be printed from that setup. It didn't affect most people, just printers. And it enabled authors to make a living from writing.
It became fairly dubious in the age of photocopiers, but fortunately was little enforced, except in the USSR. A photocopier was useless without typeset or handwritten text to copy, and the copies degraded every generation, so publishing houses were still needed.
Now every computer is a book-copying machine more powerful than the entire publishing industry a few decades ago: it can transmit a gigabit per second, and for a one-megabyte book, that's 125 copies a second, 10 million copies a day, 3 billion copies a year, so copyright is a constant danger to everyone. Fanfic sites are full of people sharing stories they wrote with no expectation of making money. The age of the rich celebrity authors like Isaac Asimov or Ernest Hemingway ended decades ago, not due to xeroxes but due to TV. The best software is free software, as copyright makes proprietary software untrustworthy, creating incentives to stuff it with malware. And, even if Elsevier were paying researchers instead of vice versa, the idea that copyright on research papers could fund research is as ludicrous as the idea that people would stop singing songs and telling stories without monopoly profits.
Apps, videos, and websites constantly disappear due to (often groundless) accusations of copyright violations. Police evade accountability by playing copyrighted music, rendering any recordings of their abuses copyright violations. A friend of mine committed suicide after being prosecuted for copyright violations that might have been fair use; we'll never know.
So, I would set the copyright term at zero years. Legal monopolies on preserving and sharing knowledge are not only useless in today's world, they are harmful, a monstrous menace to the integrity of the historical record and to private communication.
- Zak 5y ago> The age of the rich celebrity authors like Isaac Asimov or Ernest Hemingway ended decades ago J. K. Rowling and George R. R. Martin are two well-known counterexamples. You'll likely counter that much of their wealth came from movies and TV, and while that's partly true, they only got those deals due to the success of their books. I agree that aspects of traditional copyright law don't mesh well with modern technology, and that academic/scientific publishers are parasites, but I'm not convinced the concept has outlived its usefulness.
- kragen 5y agoI don't think that even the few rich authors kicking around nowadays enjoy the same kind of celebrity status that Hemingway did. His memorial monument has a bronze statue of his head on top of a column next to a reflecting pool, and the NYT devoted a 22-paragraph article to the news of his death: https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/99/07/04/specials/hemingway-services.html https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/99/07/04/s... https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/the-hemingway-memorial https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/the-hemingway-memorial Today, 60 years later, people write articles about going to visit it. I don't think anyone is going to build a monument to George R. R. Martin five years after his death.
- beej71 5y agoThe days of authors and artists making money from their copyrighted works are far from over. Believe me, there's nothing quite like seeing someone take the book you just spent a year writing, slapping their name on it, and giving it away. Even when I'm giving it away already. The biggest up-front investment these days is creation. And that is substantial. I agree the current term is insane, but doing away with it entirely will cause so much pain.
- kragen 5y agoI agree that plagiarism is contemptible and infuriating, but it's not the same problem copyright solves. It would be only barely more forgivable if I were to pass off a forgotten book of Mark Twain's as my own. And, I agree that creation requires a lot of up-front effort, and that copyright still provides some creators with monopoly profits. It's just that evidently those monopoly profits are no longer needed to stimulate that effort — if they ever were. The pain from eliminating copyright doesn't hold a candle to the pain of parents cut off from the research about their child's rare disease, or to the pain of losing the recordings of your grandmother's voice to DRM.
- beej71 5y ago> It would be only barely more forgivable if I were to pass off a forgotten book of Mark Twain's as my own. I'd argue that this is vastly more forgivable than doing the same to a just-published work. They're both equally plagiaristic, but you're not denying Twain a buck. > It's just that evidently those monopoly profits are no longer needed to stimulate that effort — if they ever were. I think it's required to stimulate the effort. Why record a song, write a book, make a film, if Amazon is just going to slap their name on it and take 100% of the proceeds leaving you no way to recoup your investment? Some people will do it for love, but you'll have zero chance of making a living off it. It's rare that an extreme response leads to a reasonable result. I'm fine with the original 12+12 years. And I agree that DRM is BS, but that's separate.
- kragen 5y agoI've learned a lot from a book that you chose to share freely; that's how I learned network programming, more than from Stevens. IIRC, this was before the end of the NSFNet and its AUP, so I think you probably did this without expecting to "recoup the investment", though you presumably know more about your motivations than I do. It's true that less creative work would be produced without the expectation of a financial return on that investment. There's some margin of writers, filmmakers, and musicians who would instead choose to dedicate much of their time to more profitable activities, such as machining, driving an Uber, performing surgery, or flipping burgers, because they aren't independently wealthy and aren't willing to make the sacrifice of eating brown rice and lentils for every meal in order to dedicate more time to their art. And the ideas that would never be born are a loss to society, and not a trivial one: we'd still have Wikipedia, surely, and Collateral Murder and Beej's Socket Guide, but not Welcome to Chechnya, Game of Thrones, or Westworld. But we need to weigh that loss against the vast devastation inflicted by copyright today. Our cultural heritage is being burned because it's illegal to preserve it. Innovators who create preservation tools get prosecuted for inducing circumvention of access control measures. People with rare diseases are cut off from access to the research literature that could save their lives. Our private communications through Facebook are being automatically scanned for forbidden information, a censorship infrastructure beyond anything Mao or the Nazis could ever have dreamed of. Books we "own" evaporate from within our homes when Amazon decides 1984 is still in copyright in our country. Every new internet startup needs to have an adequate censorship strategy to enforce copyright with, or Viacom will sue them for a billion dollars, as they did with YouTube; this strategy is incessantly used to silence criticism with wholly groundless copyright claims, including by the infamous Dr. Stacy Makhnevich: https://www.wired.com/2014/01/internet-companies-care-fair-use/ https://www.wired.com/2014/01/internet-companies-care-fair-u.... YouTubers are constantly extorted by false copyright claims; using Creative Commons licensed recordings of public-domain classical music on your video is a near-guaranteed way to get multiple copyright strikes. Printer makers lock out competitive ink cartridge vendors, extorting ridiculous ink prices from their users. Farmers are forbidden from repairing their John Deere tractors. NFL telecasts used to purport to forbid you from writing descriptions or accounts of football games. Only the biggest companies like Google can safely use free software like Apache Harmony --- and even Google almost lost in the Supreme Court. Internet streaming music radio was a promising new medium before being strangled in its cradle by copyright. And, of course, Aaron Swartz committed suicide after a baseless copyright prosecution. Reducing the term of copyright and punishing the most egregious abusers (like Makhnevich, John Deere, and the NFL) might reduce the magnitude of the problem, but it doesn't change the essential conflict: copyright attempts to reserve the right to preserve and disseminate our intellectual heritage to copyright holders, while the great public benefit of computers and the internet is that they make it trivial to preserve, disseminate, and extend that same intellectual heritage. Fundamentally these are not compatible. None of this has anything to do with plagiarism, which is a question of giving credit to creators, except in the accidental sense of being lumped into a single body of law.