24 ms·
offtopic a bit - Why does COMCAST insist on handling residential DNS, despite alternates available in the USA ? from what I see at one site in California, the
by mistrial9 5y ago
offtopic a bit - Why does COMCAST insist on handling residential DNS, despite alternates available in the USA ? from what I see at one site in California, the DNS has to come from the local router via IP address, which is directly run by COMCAST.
- detaro 5y agowhat do you mean by "insist"? Do they use their DNS as a default in their routers? Do they block access to other DNS servers? ...
- toast0 5y agoOffering a recursive DNS server is one of the basic jobs of an ISP intended for regular users. It's not strictly required, but it makes everyone a lot happier, since most consumer oriented operating systems don't include a recursive resolver (or they're not enabled out of the box). I can't find a changelog for the root hints, but I don't think they change that often. I can see L changed IPs in 2007 (and IPv6 in 2015), D in 2012, H in 2015; B in 2017 (and also 2004); I'm not sure if there were changes before then too, but I'm pretty sure even if you had a really old list from 1991, at least a few of the roots are still there, and you could bootstrap from there. There's value in a shared, somewhat local cache though. And also value in your ISP doing the recursion without the delay imposed by the last mile physical protocol.