3 ms·
I suspect that writers for the Atlantic encounter a lot more of these than most people. I recall seeing only one, buried in the credits of an indie film. Perha
by jfengel 5y ago
I suspect that writers for the Atlantic encounter a lot more of these than most people.
I recall seeing only one, buried in the credits of an indie film. Perhaps people who attend more public events than me encounter them more.
"Consciousness raising" is very much the kind of thing that people do when they don't want to put forth any effort, but feel like they did. It's especially lame once everybody has already heard about the thing.
But I don't think most people are aware of the pre-colonial history of the land on which they're standing. At best they know vaguely that most of the US once belonged to somebody else, but practically never know who, or what happened.
Consciousness raising doesn't take very long, so people quickly tire of it. But it's also frustrating to say, "Yes, you've raised my consciousness and I've already agreed to do nothing about it, so can we just skip it?" Yes, everybody involved is now aggravated with now progress -- but it doesn't mean progress is impossible, or that we should simply go back to ignoring things.
So while "land acknowledgements" can just be moral exhibitionism, so is concern trolling about how exhibitionist somebody else is being. They may well be doing the very least, but at least they're not doing less than the least and actively undercutting it.
The author appears to be trying to shortcut the usual process: somebody develops an incomplete response to injustice, some people pick it up badly, others dismiss it reflexively, go on to cite the people doing it badly as proof that there's no injustice at all, commence the usual culture war along standard lines, while the intelligentsia try to get meta about it.
He's skipped to the last step. Unless other people are seeing more of these land acknolwedgments than I am, there's a lot more shouting to do first.