5 ms·
The spatial Finder treated files and folders like physical objects. There was only one window on the screen for a given folder because a physical folder can onl
by bitwize 5y ago
The spatial Finder treated files and folders like physical objects. There was only one window on the screen for a given folder because a physical folder can only be at one place at a time. The location of each file and folder on the desktop or in a window was saved, as is the size and location of each open window, because objects remain where you left them unless moved.
It's not something that surfaces in conscious memory, but subconsciously this takes advantage of millions of years of evolution of the human brain to cope with and manipulate objecrs in the physical world, something other file managers don't do. Apple invested millions of dollars and thousands of user-hours of experimentation into making the OS take advantage of innate human psychology like this, something NO other computer manufacturer (including Xerox) had done at the time. It's a big part of why the original Mac OS was, objectively, the easiest operating system to use in the world (and far easier than many operating systems that postdate it including modern macOS).
- Someone 5y agoYes, it was great, but that feature doesn’t work with multi-user systems or network storage. Say user 1 has a large screen, and sizes the window of a folder accordingly, keeping spacing of icons in it large. Next, user 2 opens the folder on their desktop. Firstly, should it disappear from user 1’s screen, as it would if it were a physical object? That probably is undesirable. Also, if the window doesn’t fit on user 2’s screen, what should the UI do? Resize the window? On user 2’s screen or on both screens? If user 2 changes the looks of the window, and user 1 opens it again, should user 1 see it the way user 2 left it behind? Access rights introduce other problems with this metaphor. What should happen if user 2 doesn’t have write rights to a networked folder? Should they be allowed to move icons within a folder? Change window sizes? If so, where should the information about icon layout be stored? Those physical folders also don’t work well with disks with millions of files.
- setpatchaddress 5y agoThere's no reason a spatial layout shouldn't be remembered (by default) per-user on a multiuser system.
- Someone 5y agoNo, but then, you loose the ‘physical’ layout. My “that word icon with a blue label in the top row” would be your “last document in the list”. That’s not how real world objects behave.
- chongli 5y agoI wonder how many users of MacBooks and even iMacs and Mac Pros actually set up multiple user accounts on their machines? I would conjecture that the number is pretty low, perhaps below 10%. Furthermore, I think the majority of home users (the bulk of Apple users) have no network storage at all. Why go to the trouble of setting up and maintaining a file server at home when your files get backed up to iCloud and you can AirDrop anything you want to your friends? Traditional file sharing is more of a power user feature. But besides that, there is a solution to the problem you described: make the spatial information local. Each user gets a different view of the world. As for dealing with millions of files, the classic Mac Finder had list view with disclosure triangles on the folders. If you added a modern indexing search to that it would be better than anything we have today.
- mietek 5y agoList view remains available in the modern macOS Finder.
- chongli 5y agoYes it does, but spatial orientation does not. The modern Finder uses browser windows that allow me to look at the same folder in multiple windows at the same time. It also constantly forgets what a folder looked like the last time I opened it. This means I can no longer rely on my spatial memory to navigate my computer. I am reduced to navigating entirely by abstract hierarchy plus search. If you’ve ever tried cooking in someone else’s kitchen you’ve experienced first hand the huge decline in productivity that comes from not knowing where everything is. Compared to cooking in your own kitchen, the experience can be quite jarring and uncomfortable. The modern macOS Finder forces everyone to cook in someone else’s kitchen.
- Someone 5y ago“Each user gets a different view” is breaking the resemblance with reality. I can’t have a file folder (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File_folder#Tabbed_file_folders https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File_folder#Tabbed_file_fold...) that has items sorted by name that, to you, sorts them by age, for example. I also think disclosure triangles were (¿one of?) the first thing(s) that broke the spatial finder. At least, I don’t remember ever such a triangle being disabled because a window on the folder already was open, or having one or more windows for a folder close automatically when opening up a disclosure triangle. They were extremely nice, but IMO also indicators that the spatial Finder doesn’t work well with the deep hierarchies you get when you have millions of files (but to be honest, the current system doesn’t work well, either)
- anton96 5y agoThose things are still possible in the current Mac OS. Is there some important characteristics that were lost in Mac OS X ?
- wmf 5y agoIn the classic spatial Finder, every folder always opened in a new window. I'm not sure if it's possible to force that behavior under the current Finder.
- TazeTSchnitzel 5y agoThe current Finder does that thing sometimes, and other times it doesn't. I'm not sure what the rule is, it might be related to whether it's a folder you double-click directly from the desktop.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoIt does it on read only filesystems. So you’ll see it if you plug in an ntfs drive, for example (unless you’ve installed third party ntfs drivers).
- blkhp19 5y agowhich has never made any sense to me - what's different about a read-only FS that would make me want every single navigation action to open a new window?
- marcellus23 5y agoI think the closest you can get is holding down CMD when you open a folder. There doesn't seem to be a way to get that to be the default.
- nielsbot 5y agoSeems there is an option? https://www.igeeksblog.com/open-folders-in-new-windows-instead-of-tabs-in-mac-os-x-finder#method-2-making-new-windows-your-default-option https://www.igeeksblog.com/open-folders-in-new-windows-inste...
- Wowfunhappy 5y ago> There was only one window on the screen for a given folder because a physical folder can only be at one place at a time. The location of each file and folder on the desktop or in a window was saved, as is the size and location of each open window, because objects remain where you left them unless moved. You could just live update icon positions in both windows, particularly on modern machines. Just like how if you rename a file in one window, it appears renamed in the other window.
- AlanYx 5y agoThe problem with updating icon positions in both windows (to preserve the spatial metaphor) is that doing so also breaks the spatial metaphor. You switch to the second window and suddenly something that you thought was in one place suddenly isn't, and you're not sure why for a second or two. Eastgate Tinderbox is an example of software that actually implements this behavior, and it ends up being more frustrating than it seems, to the point where most users seem to only keep one spatial view open at any one time. Which seems to be where the original Mac UI settled too. I'm not sure why Tinderbox never moved to a model where a complete set of spatial positions are maintained per spatial view, so users could have two windows open with the same object in different positions, but presumably that would also have the potential for user confusion.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoI would argue iOS is the easiest operating system. Toddlers are often very good at it.
- layer8 5y agoThat only means that iOS is easy for toddler use-cases. ;) (iOS user here)
- mananaysiempre 5y agoI’m conflicted about this spatial interface thing (alternatively known as the “object-oriented user interface”). On one hand, for file managers it sounds like it should make sense, even if the overwhelming majority of file managers I’ve used (from Norton Commander to Windows 98+ Explorer to Far Manager to mc to Nautilus) don’t follow it. Even in general I’d very much like it to work, if nothing else because it pleasantly constrains the design space for GUIs. On the other, for text editors and similar apps not following it (i.e. being capable of displaying multiple views of a single buffer) is a killer feature; people rave about split editing every time it is first implemented in a given app category (text editors, word processors, spreadsheets, online spreadsheets, you name it). I’d also probably be less than enthused about a web browser that could only open a single view of a given URL. Now that I’m thinking about it, “Open a Copy” is perhaps my favourite feature in Evince and the main think I miss in other PDF viewers. The problem is, to some extent you want the view to be a separate “thing”, for example so that it can serve as a conceptual host for navigation history. Maybe the responsibility of maintaining said history could be hoisted onto the window manager, but I can’t say I’ve heard anyone mention this option, even if only to say it’s dumb and won’t work for such-and-such simple reason. I’d very much this to work, it’s just that all the gravestones (CUA, Cairo, etc.) make me wary and half the questions (that now seem obvious) don’t appear to even have been asked (many years ago, when people actually tried making this).
- fzzzy 5y agoNah. I definitely don't rave about split views. Don't like them at all.
- simondotau 5y agoIt’s really quite simple. Spatial memory is a viable system when you have tens of folders and hundreds of files. Once you have thousands of folders and millions of files, the metaphor rapidly becomes a hinderance. By analogy, think of the contents of your pantry versus the contents of your local supermarket. You can comprehend the former spatially, whereas the latter is mostly navigated hierarchically. Sure, you can usually remember where the bread aisle is — and then someone updates the operating system and bread gets moved to the other side of the store.