3 ms·
Copyright isn't just one right. It's a bundle of rights. In the US those are the copying, distribution, derivative work, public performance, and public display
by tzs 5y ago
Copyright isn't just one right. It's a bundle of rights. In the US those are the copying, distribution, derivative work, public performance, and public display rights.
I'd like to see some consideration of setting different terms for these different rights. I don't see any reason for example that the optimal term for copying and the optimal term for derivative works must be the same.
I'd also like some consideration for having the term depend on the nature of the work. I could see a case for example for the derivative work right to have a shorter term for nonfiction than for fiction.
For nonfiction, what the author brings to the table is the work in researching and organizing the underlying facts. Give them long enough exclusive rights to make that monetarily worthwhile so that it gets done and we're good.
For fiction, there is cultural value in having a character developed consistently over the course of several works so I'd support longer rights there for the author.
- laumars 5y agoI think there is a risk of over complicating the rules in doing all that you suggest. Baring in mind copyright law affects everyone, having something that is easy to reason with is definitely a feature rather than a problem. That all said, I do think the concept of different terms for different rights is an interesting idea that deserves more discussion.
- cwkoss 5y ago> For fiction, there is cultural value in having a character developed consistently over the course of several works so I'd support longer rights there for the author. Authors could still use trademark to denote what is 'canon'. I don't think society is worse off if some books had "Official Star Wars Canon" logos on them, and more books that lacked this logo. Right now we only get the former, which doesn't benefit anyone but the IP owner.