4 ms·
I don't like these copyrights persisting forever just so that the extended family of the original creator can collect money for doing nothing. I think an inter
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
I don't like these copyrights persisting forever just so that the extended family of the original creator can collect money for doing nothing.
I think an interesting side effect of copyright reform could be that original creators get a boost of street cred when they create new works even if the original is now public domain. They might even like some of the remixed ideas that new artists would be free to tinker with.
I'm a big believer in the mostly free market so I tend to side with whatever allows more competition. Copyright, as it stands right now, stifles innovation and competition and only benefits entities like Disney.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> street cred Like “exposure”, this is something people talk about being a reward to justify arrangements that are materially exploitive. There are good arguments to be made for limiting copyright, but invoking artists getting street cred undermines rather than reinforces them.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoWrong. That's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about new works from the original artist getting a boost for being by the original artist and not some random person.
- GuB-42 5y ago> I don't like these copyrights persisting forever just so that the extended family of the original creator can collect money for doing nothing. That's inheritance. If your father builds a house before he dies, you will inherit the house even though you did nothing, it won't become public property. If your father writes a book before he dies, you will inherit the copyrights even though you did nothing, it won't become public domain. You may not like the idea of inheritance, or long copyright terms, but extending copyright way past the original creator life is a logical conclusion when you combine the two.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoUnder your analogy patents and copyrights would last forever?
- nybble41 5y agoProperty rights don't expire. Copyright does. These are very different systems based on fundamentally different principles. Reasoning about copyrights using analogies based on physical property such as houses is not particularly productive. If you want copyright to be something that can be inherited or otherwise gifted to someone else, a (short) fixed term like the original 28 year limit makes much more sense than anything based on the author's lifespan. There is no need to extent it "way past the original creator life". Most things that can potentially be inherited don't have longer lifetimes than their original owners. Even houses don't last forever. If they're still around they can be part of the estate; otherwise the heirs can inherit whatever is left of the invested earnings.
- mbarbar 5y ago>but extending copyright way past the original creator life is a logical conclusion when you combine the two. Not necessarily, unless you mean that copyright should always be able to be passed down should the holder wish. In your example, the father can double dip: write a (good enough) book, make money through sales (more guaranteed through state-enforced monopoly), buy a house with, maybe part of, that money, then have both the house and copyright inherited by the inheritors.
- chrismcb 5y agoCopyright stifles some innovation. But it also spurs others. Today's copyright benefits the little guy as much as the big guy. But if you moved to a primarily free market only system, the only one that benefits is the big guy.