5 ms·
> And that's tax on all your income. I (strongly) suspect that will not stand up to judicial review. Income that has no nexus in the state, let alone the munic
by sokoloff 5y ago
> And that's tax on all your income.
I (strongly) suspect that will not stand up to judicial review. Income that has no nexus in the state, let alone the municipality, is not going to be taxable for part-time visitors to the state.
Here’s a research position paper prepared for one state that touches pretty squarely on the issues and the Constitutional barriers to enacting what is proposed above: https://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/hrd/pubs/ss/clssnonr.pdf https://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/hrd/pubs/ss/clssnonr.pdf
- lotsofpulp 5y agoSupreme Court denied hearing New Hampshire v Massachusetts on Jun 28, 2021, and basically told individual taxpayers to fight being taxes by states they have not set foot in. I know quite a few people who have not stepped foot in NY state for nearly 2 years now and have been paying NY state income taxes the whole time. https://www.sullivanlaw.com/news-The-Supreme-Court-Denies-Complaint-in-New-Hampshire-v-Massachusetts-Heightening-the-Importance-of-Individual-Refund-Claims.html https://www.sullivanlaw.com/news-The-Supreme-Court-Denies-Co...
- sokoloff 5y agoIn both of those cases, that income has substantial nexus in the state, though, with the employer generally being located in the taxing state.
- ghaff 5y agoI suspect we haven't heard the last of these cases though. As I understand the NH and MA case, this is about continuing to collect state income tax from NH residents who are no longer commuting. Presumably, it does not apply to remote NH residents who never commuted to a MA location. (The situation of course gets even more complicated when a NH resident is remote to a company that has offices in many states. Why would MA have any particular right to state income tax just because an MA office is closer?) States are getting very grabby in this regard though. Quite a few are going after business travelers who may have spent as little as a day in the state.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> (The situation of course gets even more complicated when a NH resident is remote to a company that has offices in many states. Why would MA have any particular right to state income tax just because an MA office is closer?) I do not see it as complicated. Either a state is restricted to being able to tax income from work performed within its geographic boundaries, or it is not. If it is not, then I do not see why every state cannot tax every single employee of any business that has any presence in the state. Very surprised this Supreme Court declined to hear it with only 2 Justices disagreeing.
- ghaff 5y agoIt's complicated in that states have a bunch of different rules, are apparently inconsistent in applying them, and there is also apparently not clear precedent. I agree that this seems a case tailor made for SCOTUS to have taken. Here's just one "it's complicated" example. Say I lived in NH (I don't) and worked remote. (And let's simplify and imagine I never went to an office.) My closest office would be, in fact, be in Massachusetts but HQ is in North Carolina. Why would I pay MA given that I don't live or work there? Maybe I should pay NC? But now you've created a situation where heavily remote companies should establish HQs in no income tax states. As I also noted, there are a bunch of theoretical rules related to business travel that haven't been historically enforced in most cases but seem to be increasingly so. Which may mean that a lot of employees may increasingly have to file multiple state returns depending upon various thresholds.
- sokoloff 5y agoPro athletes already have to file in the many states in which they perform: https://www.forbes.com/sites/kurtbadenhausen/2017/04/18/income-taxes-for-pro-athletes-are-reminder-of-how-complicated-u-s-tax-code/amp/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kurtbadenhausen/2017/04/18/inco... (It’s a small enough group of people and the per-game incomes high enough to go after as compared to my income for the days I attend a conference somewhere.)
- 5y ago