5 ms·
How do you explain it without any common experience? Well, that introduces a further problem - if you have no common experience... how do you communicate with
by vacri 15y ago
How do you explain it without any common experience?
Well, that introduces a further problem - if you have no common experience... how do you communicate with them at all?
- gmaslov 15y agoAgreed. The setup of this question struck me as a bit of an arbitrary "moving goalposts" problem.
- jerf 15y agoWe all live in the same universe with the same physics and have a great deal of common experiences and mathematics with which to potentially have this sort of conversation with them. (Yeah, ye olde "they might be totally incomprehensible" is still there, but in this case we're talking about the flip side... it isn't impossible that we could in fact understand them.) Nevertheless, there are some fundamental symmetries that are so symmetric that we could understand vast swathes of their communication and still not know whether perhaps we inverted their entire communication, lock stock and barrel, because the difference between left and right is actually very, very subtle, subtle nearly to the point of nonexistence. (For a long time we thought they were nonexistent, but we've since found some down at the base of physics.) The "Contact" model of an enormous transmission that can be progressively decoded can not be ruled out, though we have experimental evidence that it's harder than it seems at first blush. (Still, those experiments tend to focus on having our 'top minds' decode pictures that amount to a few hundred bits; arguably it would actually be easier to decode an entire mathematical codex as we would have a lot more to work with, much like cyphertexts actually get somewhat easier to crack as they get larger.)
- vacri 15y agoBut if you have to work verbally only, and can never point to something to say "this is -foo-", how do you communicate? It doesn't really matter that we live in the same universe - how the hell do we say "Hey, you know DNA?" when we can't even make an arbitrary point. The article is saying that we can't communicate things about constellations or other simple-yet-arbitrary points, but that we can happily communicate about things we can't even sense ourselves (who knows about the aliens senses?). Sure, we can verbally define what a Volt is, but the words we use to make that definition require common experience at some point to make sense. Remember that the rosetta stone was so useful because it provided a reference point to help decode a previously incomprehensible language. In order to communicate with someone, you must have a common experience somewhere.
- jerf 15y agoWe don't have to work verbally only. As I said, the "Contact" scenario is perfectly plausible and you can send diagrams just fine. Also recall as I said we're not talking worst-case scenarios where the intelligence is utterly incomprehensible, which frankly I'm pretty down on anyhow (I don't think "utterly incomprehensible" and "able to survive in our universe" work together, personally), we're talking about some reasonable alien that we actually can communicate with. And the idea that they might not have a concept of diagrams isn't the point, the point is that they might today. The whole "But they might be incomprehensible and we might have zero common reference frames" is not really applicable here, just a fashionable knee-jerk reaction to "the alien question". As a possible outcome, sure, as the only outcome, no way.
- vacri 15y agoI'm working from the original article's demands, which deny diagrams or being able to point at something: And imagine, moreover, that you had to do so in a purely verbal manner, that is, without drawing pictures or pointing at things or otherwise making gestures. With diagrams or pointing, showing what left and right mean becomes trivial. On the knee-jerk reaction thing, it's more pointing out that it's a matter of moving the goalposts as mentioned below. It's making an arbitrary line of what can be communicated I agree with you that the incomprehensible alien form is pointless, but as soon as we have a common frame of reference, we can drill down to defining right and left. All you need is four points: Point A is 'up', Point B is 'down', put your viewing position so that Point C is between you and the line AB. With A being 'up', Point D is on the left side of the line AB. Whether you use stars, a mountainside, a tree, galaxies, or jellyfish, that's all you need - but you still need a common point to refer to. I think a better way of phrasing the problem would be: You have a communications conduit to a parallel universe and we only have the ability to speak through it. The alien understands us but has no prior concept of right and left. We can't point or refer to bodies in our universe as they can't see them, but apart from that, all physical rules are the same and they have the same level of science knowledge as us. How do we tell them right from left in this instance? We can get the concept across with left- and right-handed molecules (though DNA may be out as they may not have it), but how to indicate which is left and right in verbiage only, I'm not sure. Phrased this way, you don't have to do silly logical twists to have the alien living in our universe yet still somehow preventing them from seeing the same things we do.