3 ms·
I agree that people could have a more effective BS filter, but I think there’s also some obligation to not publish BS in the first place at the risk of your tru
by sokoloff 5y ago
I agree that people could have a more effective BS filter, but I think there’s also some obligation to not publish BS in the first place at the risk of your trustworthiness reputation.
People intentionally or repeatedly inadvertently publishing BS should be called out and their opinions down-weighted heavily.
People having a good BS filter is one step in the chain towards this down-weighting, but isn’t the whole chain. If anything, people slinging BS today are likely to gain additional reach and opinion-weight, rather than to lose it.
- indigochill 5y ago> should be called out and their opinions down-weighted heavily But thinking about this from a loosely signal-process-y angle, once you have a BS signal in one channel that routes to a a particular set of minds, how does one route the corrective signal to that same set of minds (as opposed to, say, just your local friends who already agree with you anyway)? And even supposing you do, those minds are already programmed to process these signals in particular ways that probably means they're predisposed to accepting one or the other before either signal even arrives. The answer to this has always been to address the root of the problem, the preprogramming, through (relatively) uniform mass education, because that's the one and only place where you can (relatively) uniformly cram ideas into everyone's brain before they scatter to the winds and begin fancying themselves "free thinkers".
- sokoloff 5y agoIf you integrate over time, an erroneous signal (a stray bit of noise) can still result in a few minds here and there having the wrong information. That’s not ideal, but it’s unavoidable and not catastrophic so long as the source of the bad information systemically has reduced amplitude next time. Right now, sources of bad information get systemically louder, not quieter, over time. That’s way worse.
- geofft 5y agoThe post does exactly this, calling out Alex Berenson by name - but despite its best efforts, it will have very little impact on the people paying him to receive BS directly from his Substack. I don't think your opinion is unpopular because it's wrong. It's unpopular because it's empirically impractical. People don't suffer a reputational hit for publishing BS, and saying "But they should" doesn't get us anywhere (as you yourself point out). How do you propose that we actually cause reputational hits for such people? One way is to teach additional statistical literacy to the general public. There are probably other proposals worth trying and I'd be interested in hearing your takes on what they are. (One that might be effective - though certainly controversial - is for the government to say that Alex Berenson is actively putting lives in danger with lies and that, if the untruth of his statements can be proven in court, he should be subject to criminal penalties, just like Elizabeth Holmes is on trial for lying about her blood tests. But that seems a lot less good for society as a whole than teaching statistical literacy.)
- sokoloff 5y agoI don’t have a workable suggestion, but I agree that it’s not government regulation of speech. It’s going to be difficult to fix when enragement engagement is profitable for the platforms and the BS slingers. Elizabeth Holmes is on trial for lying about things where she had a specific legal obligation to tell the truth. I’d never heard of Alex Berenson before today, but I doubt his situation is one in which he’s obligated to tell the truth. That’s okay. Sunday school preachers aren’t either and we’re cool with that. We’re good with the Santa and Easter Bunny myths.
- native_samples 5y agoThe moment you go down that road, every academic epidemiologist and COVID expert will immediately be prosecuted because they have repeatedly made claims that were totally false and which have led directly to many deaths. For example, the claim that lockdowns work (they don't and this was known before COVID times), has led directly to people dying due to delayed medical treatment. Poverty also kills of course and their demands/misinformation has led to that too. The same is also true of more or less the entire field of nutrition, none of which has yielded anything useful, and has resulted in governments themselves spreading misinformation: https://sebastianrushworth.com/2021/11/27/is-saturated-fat-unhealthy/ https://sebastianrushworth.com/2021/11/27/is-saturated-fat-u... Incidentally, Berenson has written a long rebuttal to this kind of thing which you can find here: https://alexberenson.substack.com/p/the-english-data-on-vaccines-and/comments https://alexberenson.substack.com/p/the-english-data-on-vacc...
- geofft 5y ago> the claim that lockdowns work (they don't and this was known before COVID times) This is a bold claim and I'd be curious to see you back this up. By "lockdowns" - do you mean actual, genuine lockdowns / quarantines (mandatory stay-at-home orders, government-distributed emergency food packs and other essentials), or do you mean capacity restrictions etc. that get called "lockdowns" in the popular media? Note that my straw-man proposal (which I'm not seriously endorsing) is not that it should be prosecutable to have been wrong. Plenty of startups try to build something, and it doesn't work; they don't get prosecuted like Holmes. Holmes is facing prosecution for fraud, for knowingly telling falsehoods. If your implication is that academic epidemiologists, COVID experts, and the entire field of nutrition are all fraudulent as opposed to merely just going through the usual course of science - which, to be clear, I see as mostly but not entirely impossible - then yes, I think we have a rather serious problem on our hands, which we need to figure out for the survival of humanity, and I'll repeat my comment above: I'm very interested in knowing what proposals you have for solving it.
- toss1 5y agoYup, it is called establishing a reputation, positive or negative, trustworthy or untrustworthy This works well naturally in small communities, but once the society becomes too large, BSers, liars, and scammers can just move on to a new gullible crowd. So we got social media with review & reputation management systems, and these are now, of course, promptly gamed to the max. Moreover, this gaming is being done by the very people who should be most de-amplified, in order to amplify their BS, inlcuding everyone from just trolls to professional RUS dezinformatsiya shops (that'll gather a lot of downvotes). So yes, a huge part of the solution is to de-amplify the crowd that spews Bs or deliberate lies. Sure, freedom of speech is a right, but no one has to be required to amplify you on their platform - that takes away the freedom of speech of the platform owner (e.g., if HN were required to amplify everyone, then moderation would become effectively illegal). Why does this view gain downvotes so frequently? IDK, but it seems to be mostly readers with no nuance who think that freedom of speech requires zero restrictions, so any shadow of moderation or restriction rankles them, and they are not articulate enough to state a reason, but can still hit the down-arrow.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]