5 ms·

Which is better: optimism or pessimism? [audio]

open-source-ux 5y ago
A summary of some of the discussion points in the programme: - 80% of the population have a optimism bias, 10% doesn't have a systematic optimism bias one way or the another, and 10% have a pessimistic outlook. (For example, the pessimist sees the future as worse than the present and past, or overestimates negative outcomes.) - The optimism outlook is a u-curve shape: high in young ages, drops in mid-life (the bottom of the U shape), then climbs again in older populations. How do we explain this? We don't know, but there are some theories e.g. mid-life can be a stressful time for many people. - An optimism bias is good for people's mental health and physical health; optimists live longer. - Espen Fadnes, a Freefall professional, considers himself an optimist. He has done about 8000 jumps and never worries about the danger when doing during a freefall down a mountain. It's about being in the moment, like forced meditation. It doesn't mean he make mistakes - he's made lots of them, but learns from them. - Pessimism can make some people work through lots of scenarios as a way of anticipating events and preparing for them i.e. stop those events from happening, manage the associated anxiety and take effective action. Also referred as 'defensive pessimism'. - The Pessimist is less likely to be surprised or disappointed when things go wrong (because they anticipated different scenarios). - There are nuances in different outlooks and it's too simplistic to say optimists do better. - Are there cultural differences between countries? Can cultural norms particular to a country change our outlook? More research is needed. - Germany vs USA: a German who has lived in the USA reflects on the cultural differences between the countries. In conclusion, we are probably all a mixture of the optimist and pessimist to varying proportions, and dependent on the situation and the cultural norms where we live. There is much more in the programme - it's a very stimulating listen.
- GDC7 5y ago
  Also a pessimist might anticipate that even if they are successful in say the next 5 big events on life paths, their lives would still be mundane and not special enough.
fargle 5y ago
For an optimist, optimism. For a pessimist, neither.
simonblack 5y ago
Pessimism. All surprises then are pleasant ones, not unpleasant surprises.

A summary of some of the discussion points in the programme: - 80% of the population have a optimism bias, 10% doesn't have a systematic optimism bias one way or the another, and 10% have a pessimistic outlook. (For example, the pessimist sees the future as worse than the present and past, or overestimates negative outcomes.) - The optimism outlook is a u-curve shape: high in young ages, drops in mid-life (the bottom of the U shape), then climbs again in older populations. How do we explain this? We don't know, but there are some theories e.g. mid-life can be a stressful time for many people. - An optimism bias is good for people's mental health and physical health; optimists live longer. - Espen Fadnes, a Freefall professional, considers himself an optimist. He has done about 8000 jumps and never worries about the danger when doing during a freefall down a mountain. It's about being in the moment, like forced meditation. It doesn't mean he make mistakes - he's made lots of them, but learns from them. - Pessimism can make some people work through lots of scenarios as a way of anticipating events and preparing for them i.e. stop those events from happening, manage the associated anxiety and take effective action. Also referred as 'defensive pessimism'. - The Pessimist is less likely to be surprised or disappointed when things go wrong (because they anticipated different scenarios). - There are nuances in different outlooks and it's too simplistic to say optimists do better. - Are there cultural differences between countries? Can cultural norms particular to a country change our outlook? More research is needed. - Germany vs USA: a German who has lived in the USA reflects on the cultural differences between the countries. In conclusion, we are probably all a mixture of the optimist and pessimist to varying proportions, and dependent on the situation and the cultural norms where we live. There is much more in the programme - it's a very stimulating listen.

GDC7 5y ago
Also a pessimist might anticipate that even if they are successful in say the next 5 big events on life paths, their lives would still be mundane and not special enough.

fargle 5y ago

For an optimist, optimism. For a pessimist, neither.

simonblack 5y ago

Pessimism. All surprises then are pleasant ones, not unpleasant surprises.