4 ms·
Correct me if I'm not understanding this DAO "revolution" correctly: - A group of people pool some money together. - The money is used to buy assets/fund proj
by paxys 5y ago
Correct me if I'm not understanding this DAO "revolution" correctly:
- A group of people pool some money together.
- The money is used to buy assets/fund projects.
- Members vote on spending, governance etc., with their vote being proportional to their investment.
- They can raise money by issuing more "tokens" for new investors.
- Existing members can sell their tokens to someone else.
Like, congrats crypto community, you just invented a...public company?
- patrickaljord 5y agoFirst, the difference is that it's trust-less because people votes are backed by crypto. Second, you're aware the "congrats, you've just invented" argument is a ridiculous fallacy that can be used against any kind of innovation. It's also has a very bad record as it's been used against the internet, smartphones, social media etc.
- bendergarcia 5y agoRight but it’s like a meta company. Like, a company of anything, not just traditional businesses. Plus the whole process is totally streamlined and, outside of rug pulls, super transparent. Ownership and transfer of ownership is in front of everyone’s eyes. It’s like what Amazon did. People could buy stuff before, but now they could buy stuff with much more ease (search, order, return etc).
- agucova 5y agoLike just an organization? A non-profit or other type of cooperative depending on your local regulations might fit exactly. I don't see how it improves any part of the process.
- dudeman6969 5y agoYou can create and fund one on Twitter over a weekend…
- jimkleiber 5y agoI just assume that could be possible with a gofundme or kickstarter platform if they were allowed to sell ownership shares to the public. I think why it doesn't happen on those platforms has more to do with the securities laws than tech challenges.
- arcticbull 5y agoAs usual, crypto is not a technical solution but rather a regulatory arbitrage solution. The technology is old and boring. Scoffing at the law, though, well that's fun and new.
- gammarator 5y ago> outside of rug pulls Other than that, how was the play, Mrs. Lincoln?
- pylon 5y agoI assume none of the existing regulations or laws that involve public companies apply to DAOs? Like can you pool the money and then do nothing or go against what was agreed upon?
- colechristensen 5y agoYou assume wrong. The things regulators have authority over are rather broadly defined, and the regulators will and have rather eagerly pursue novel attempts to avoid regulation. The best that one running such things could hope for is a period of indecision. This though seems pretty cut and dry “is a security” and all sorts of compliance will apply early.
- SturgeonsLaw 5y agoIt's more like a co-op. The difference is that every participant has a voice. With the traditional public company - with few exceptions - decisions are made only by the board and the execs.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> more like a co-op The owners aren’t providing labour. Votes are tied to shares—one person can have more than one vote. And the shares are acquired with capital. Closer to corporation than coöp. If the DAO committed to turning the team over to its players or fans, and then fixed one vote one member, that would resemble a coöperative.
- jonnydubowsky 5y agoThere are worker-owned co-ops and customer-owned co-ops. DAOs also are a fairly generic concept, made more specific by whatever terms and conditions are memorialized in their originating contracts.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> worker-owned co-ops and customer-owned co-ops. DAOs also are a fairly generic concept Totally agree. There is no reason a coöp couldn’t run on a blockchain. This DAO is not that.
- markburns 5y agoAs far as I can recall, I had never encountered this kind of usage of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diaeresis_(diacritic) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diaeresis_(diacritic) in the word cooperative. I was going to ask you about it but Wikipedia gave a sufficient explanation, so commenting for the benefit of other readers.
- agolliver 5y agoThe New Yorker is one of the few places you'll see this regularly https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-curse-of-the-diaeresis https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-curse-of-...
- rvz 5y agoBasically, A pseudo public company funded using unregulated digital assets = DAO. But this time when a DAO executes a rug-pull, or the token crashes to 0, the regulators are not going to save you.
- thebean11 5y agoI’m not sure this should be your example about what a DAO actually is, if you were to choose between the ones that currently exist.
- jimkleiber 5y agoExactly, a public company that skirts KYC/AML laws and securities laws. I'm not saying I necessarily agree with those laws, I just see much of the "DAO revolution" as designed to "free the people" into investing anonymously and without accredited investor requirements, without directly trying to change the laws. One thing I think it does that most don't talk about: allows people to register a global company/org. Right now, I think the highest level to register an org is the nation-state level, not much, if anything, exists at a global level.
- lloydgrossman 5y agothose bits on the net will sure come in handy when it goes to trial in "global court".
- jimkleiber 5y agoA fair point—there also isn't much of a global judicial system to regulate property ownership. WIPO perhaps but doesn't seem too relevant/powerful to most and probably doesn't cover most things. So then we have global things often being regulated by national laws, which, seems to be a conundrum I see happening more and more.
- giansegato 5y agoThat’s actually the point. You theoretically shouldn’t need a court. Everything is regulated by code, and if something goes wrong you have to own it. The code is public. You can vet it as much as you want. Proposals are voted proportional to code ownership. It looks controversial but not utterly nonsense to me.
- scatters 5y agoFor on chain stuff, sure. Where it interfaces with the real world, how do you make the agents carry out the decisions of the code without using the courts?
- giansegato 5y ago
- reginold 5y agoI'm pro-cryptocurrencies, but I also don't really get what's so amazing about DAOs. Are there any references or explanations from people who love them? Here's a piece by Vitalik I found compelling: https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/08/16/voting3.html https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/08/16/voting3.html
- cblconfederate 5y agothat runs by itself
- jurassic 5y agoThe revolutionary bit is you can raise money through a DAO without paying millions to a corrupt investment bank to handle your IPO. No letting the investment bank set the opening price too low so their stable of institutional investors get a reliable "pop", etc. You don't need to spend millions on special consultants to help you prepare regulatory filings. So far, anyway. I'm a major crypto skeptic, but I definitely see the appeal of disposing of these gatekeepers and putting the public back in public markets.
- erikpukinskis 5y agoYes, crypto is not about inventing some kind of new financial instrument that never existed before. It’s about having software that runs the regulation schemes surrounding those financial instruments without needing human regulators.