14 ms·
Saintcon: Lock Picking Lawyer Keynote
- lgsilver 5y agoFunny that right after he explained how he keeps his family safe by keeping his face and name off the internet, he spent the rest of the video focusing on the ineffectiveness and "downright stupidity" of security by obscurity.
- GuB-42 5y agoI think there is a misunderstanding about security by obscurity. What is bad is hiding defects instead of addressing the problem. It does not mean you should reveal everything! I find it well explained in the video. For example, if you don't tell people what kind of lock you are using to secure your stuff, this is a form of security by obscurity, but it is not a bad thing. Even if your lock is one of the best, if an attacker knows what it is, he will be better prepared. I think no one who cares about security will tell you things that you don't need to know, it is called OPSEC, I believe. What is bad is when you realize that your lock is weak, instead of trying to fix it, you try to hide the weakness. And that's the idea that LPL criticizes in his talk. Hiding his identity is most likely not his only defense against the craziness of the internet. From his videos, we know that he has guns, and who knows what he secures his house with. He is most likely prepared to deal with the consequences of an identity leak, but that doesn't mean he wants it to happen. That's defense in depth, an other important part of security.
- lgsilver 5y agoYep. That's totally fair and you're right. Would be interesting for him to compare / analogize that with the lock companies' approach.
- elcomet 5y ago> From his videos, we know that he has guns This is interesting because we know that's not a good security. In fact, it has been shown that having a gun in the house is associated with more firearm-related deaths and not less. So I suggest anyone that is thinking of buying guns to read this. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15522849/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15522849/
- HWR_14 5y agoThat study doesn't mean that guns are bad security. They obviously lead to more gun related suicides, and can turn domestic fights more violent. However, if you are at high risk of being attacked (if you are a criminal defense attorney or a minor YouTube celebrity), the risk of being assaulted is different from the general population's.
- elcomet 5y agoYes you're right about the different risk profile. I just hope most people that do not have such a risk profile are aware of this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aphroz 5y agoI've watched way too many lockpicking videos since I discovered LPL. A little click on one, two is binding..
- carreau 5y agoRead some of these and tell me if you hear his voice. https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/irszx0/wp_hello_this_is_lockpicking_lawyer_i_was_put/ https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/irszx0/wp_h... "Anyways, that’s all for me today, if you liked this video please subscribe to see more videos like this, and as always, have a nice day."
- JaakkoP 5y agoI too find his explanation on each click soothing. Except when he got challenged to open a “difficult” bike lock in under 2 minutes by another locksmith he was dead silent the entire time and opened it in like 20 seconds.
- masklinn 5y agoThe first video using lishis was absolutely stellar as well as it showed much more clearly what was happening under the hood.
- unixhero 5y ago"Got a click out of him/hem"
- shapefrog 5y ago"And back to one"
- timonoko 5y agoHappiness is when you finally discover and experience "counter rotation" all by yourself.
- codezero 5y agoAnd madness is when there are only serrated pins. At least for me :)
- cranium 5y agoLPL videos are an example in educational videos. Clear explanations, no fluff, no finger pointing (except for Master Lock and unbacked marketing claims) and real expertise.
- Stevvo 5y agoThey stand out in all of the fluff on YouTube because it's just about the locks. No vane selfie cams.
- bjoli 5y agoI have done a little bit of lock picking as a hobby, and LPL is somewhat of a lock-picking Mozart. Locks I struggle with, he picks in less than 30 seconds. He has inspired me to become better at lock picking, which helped me at least once when I locked myself out of my locker at work. My Assa-Abloy lock which would have taken me 20 minutes before was open in under 2 minutes.
- codezero 5y agoI am convinced he’s a savant. A combination of maybe naturally higher senses in the fingers and a methodical approach to solving puzzles. I got pretty good pretty fast at picking, and that convinced me he is otherworldly in his talent and abilities. On another note, I’m really going to miss Bosnian Bill, he excelled as a teacher and worked hard to remove anything mystical or subjective from approaching lock picking. LPL is great, but still doesn’t quite go into deep detail about how to improve at tensioning, dealing with various types of pins, in a way that resonates with “regular” people, where Bill was just a huge help in those areas.
- delusional 5y agoThe wonderful thing about video is that even as Bosnian Bill retires his lessons will remain available, all 1909 of them.
- junon 5y agoWatched this the other day. Great talk by a legend lockpicker.
- mongol 5y agoHas there ever been a lock which he could not pick?
- dskloet 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29367405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29367405
- szundi 5y agoThat would be interesting to know
- mongol 5y agoYes. After having watched the keynote, I have mixed feelings. He keeps repeating how awful common locks are, and that it is in the interest of lock users that that is revealed. But never does he mention how a lock buyer can evaluate if a lock is good. What should we look out for?
- timonoko 5y agoFrom a row of cheap locks, you can easily find the best. The key has deep cut (ie long pin) first. It is really difficult to pick behind that first pin.
- timonoko 5y agoAlso the long pin might be long enuff to prevent comping, as demonstrated by the Lock Picking Lawyer.
- codezero 5y agoLook out for (keep away from) US residential lock brands, like Schlage or anything you can buy at Home Depot. Newer Kwikset locks are OK but still susceptible to some more moderate attacks with a shim. In general, try to get any “rated” European lock. They have standards for pick resistance and brute force resistance unlike retail US locks. Look for something with dimple pins, an active element, or multiple pin stacks with security pins, trap pins (anti tamper). With all that said I don’t think the low security locks we have are such a problem. You can break a window open or just find an unlocked door if you are looking to do some bad shit. I like how Schuyler Towne put it: locks are just a social contract. I’m saying, hey, don't go opening that door, and as a civil society we agree not to. A higher security lock on your home isn’t going to make your flimsy door harder to kick down, or your window harder to break, so yeah it’s nice to be educated on the security trade offs you make physically, but I’m not sure it’s important to beef up residential security in the US.
- russellbeattie 5y agoI have an idea for a LPL-proof lock: Take a decent padlock, one that gets high marks from LPL, and then weld a curved steel tube to it ending at the keyhole. Then take the key and cut it in half at the head, welding a long stiff spring to attach the two halves, like a plumber's snake. To unlock, you simply stick the key bit down the tube around the bend and (with some fiddling I'm sure) into the keyway, then you can turn the key to open. Without direct access to the tumbler, I'm not sure how you'd be able to pick it.
- dmitriid 5y ago> I have an idea for a LPL-proof lock There's a lock on his channel that he can't open. Bowley lock: https://youtu.be/qV8QKZNFxLw https://youtu.be/qV8QKZNFxLw and there's a different prototype, too: https://youtu.be/D6vioIPVzM4 https://youtu.be/D6vioIPVzM4
- ryzvonusef 5y agothere was some kerkuffle aboyut whether he actually tried to pick it, since it could be picked: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KS0FSzamUzc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KS0FSzamUzc Or maybe the picker aligned his stars when picking... not sure
- dmitriid 5y agoThis is amazing. Thank you! There's discussion in the comments with Bowley Lock Company Inc saying that the stars did align, but we might never know
- raverbashing 5y agoYes, if you push hard enough everything is "pickable" I guess But an easy code, power tools and having the lock in an ideal work position doesn't make it easily pickable. Sounds like the same useless discussions on computer security where people will discuss key sizes but not rubberhose cryptography.
- svennek 5y ago
- userbinator 5y agoIf you watch LPL enough, you get the notion that most locks are for keeping honest people honest rather than stopping a determined attacker. All the comments from people who have managed to lock themselves out further reinforce that.
- thurn 5y agoIt's really interesting stuff, although realistically, the situations in which it matters how hard to pick a lock is are pretty rare -- the majority of situations where an evil actor is trying to bypass a lock are ones where they'd be willing to employ destructive techniques instead.
- LanceH 5y agoI bought lockpicks for the kids when covid hit for something to do. Within an hour, everyone could open the practice lock which is in a clear casing. Within a week, we could all open your typical masterlock and my daughter could open any of the locks you might purchase from home depot.
- iso1210 5y agoYou have to realise that LPL has a very specific set of skills. Skills he has acquired over a very long career. Skills that make hom a nightmare for people like masterlock. I had a locksmith out a couple of years ago, and was very disappointed when he simply got out a drill rather than starting with 'click out of one'. LPL makes things look easy, I'm sure they aren't.
- OkayPhysicist 5y agoI encourage you to try out locksport as a hobby. Pretty much anyone can learn to pop open a masterlock padlock in 30 seconds or so with maybe a couple hours practice. Don't get me wrong, he makes even really, really hard to pick locks look easy, but that doesn't negate the fact that a lot of locks are just actually easy.
- delusional 5y agoYou have to excuse that I didn't watch the video, so i might be missing some context. LPL's career isn't lockpicking is it? I was under the impression that it was just a hobby that turned into a youtube channel. I seem to recall him saying that he just picks locks all the time, and that's why he's good. I think he said that when he watches movies he takes a 30 locks and then he just sits there and picks them while watching.
- speedgoose 5y agoIf youtube suggests way too many lock picking videos after you watched this one, you can go to your YouTube history and remove the video from the list.
- asimpletune 5y agoMuch has been made about LPL s and his astonishing skill, but I’d like to briefly mention my appreciation for LPL the showman. I really think the style and format of his show makes it so incredibly watchable. I love his voice, the delivery, and the way he so articulately breaks down how he thinks and approaches problem solving. He really makes you feel like you could do it too. It’s very subtle but as a showman he’s one of the alltime best on YouTube.
- dwighttk 5y agoAnd the fact that he doesn’t surround his videos with tons of cruft to make them longer. Probably the only YouTuber that tries to sell me stuff and I totally think that is a good and natural idea.
- thefunnyman 5y agoHe’s also the only YouTuber I’ve ever bought something from. He does a great job of using the things he sells in videos to demonstrate their value and he’s not overly pushy about it like many other creators. He’ll simply mention that the tool he uses is one that is available for purchase from him, no different than mentioning the names of other tools he uses. It’s an ingenious and very effective sales pitch.
- j16sdiz 5y agoIn the linked video at 33:10, he said he deliberately make his videos short.
- mschuster91 5y ago> And the fact that he doesn’t surround his videos with tons of cruft to make them longer. Unlike most full-time Youtubers, LPL does not need to pad out videos or pander to sponsors to make a living, and he doesn't need to engage in clickbaiting and SEO/algorithm manipulation to lure new viewers. This independency from anyone else is what allows him the complete artistic control to do videos the way he prefers.
- 5y ago
- xaduha 5y agoI keep bringing up smartcards in every thread, but I just can't help it. Car keys seems to be moving towards contactless, at least Tesla got a right idea, there's even open-source implementation as an applet for it https://github.com/darconeous/gauss-key-card https://github.com/darconeous/gauss-key-card. Cryptography is math and you can't beat math, cost and scale will always limit complicated physical keys. And most existing electronic keys/tags/fobs/cards use cheaper not-quite-smartcards that are vulnerable to replay attacks and cloning, LPL even had some videos about them.
- judge2020 5y agoTesla got it wrong in the sense BT is vulnerable to repeater attacks and such could likely be used to steal your car, assuming you were targeted by someone trying. Edit for reference: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25187170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25187170
- tux1968 5y agoI don't know how Tesla implemented their key, but there's nothing in BT that makes it inherently vulnerable to repeater attacks. Garage doors addressed that problem a long time ago by changing the code after every successful opening.
- marcan_42 5y agoThat's not a repeater attack; that's a replay attack. A repeater attack means tunneling the communications over the internet/long distance radio/whatever, where someone's in your car and someone else is following you. That's the repeater bit, they have a pair of devices that act like a long distance radio repeater.
- tux1968 5y agoThat's diabolically clever. I'm curious how any technology can overcome that, and why BT is apparently more susceptible?
- oxplot 5y agoI want LPL to tell me once what to buy, not keep telling me what not to buy 1400 times. It's educational, I understand, but man, can you put up one video where you tell us what you use on your own front door?
- half-kh-hacker 5y agoThere is a video for modified Kwikset that he showed that's what is on his door, AFAICT.
- ImJasonH 5y agohttps://youtu.be/7JlgKCUqzA0 https://youtu.be/7JlgKCUqzA0
- dotancohen 5y ago> I want LPL to tell me once what to buy, That would entail far more responsibility - and possibly liability - than telling you what not to buy. Remember, this guy is a lawyer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kamranjon 5y agoThis goes into some padlocks he considers to be quality: https://youtu.be/L6iMmCSayBQ https://youtu.be/L6iMmCSayBQ
- geertj 5y agoBesides the modified Kwikset, he was also unable to pick the Bowley lock.
- dotancohen 5y agoThis is what an LPL recommendation video looks like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXoS_HB1I3o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXoS_HB1I3o
- TwinProduction 5y agoI love LPL. I knew he liked his craft, but even his intentions are pure -- I had no idea he purposely shortened his videos to icnrease his reach.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoThe intro explaining the weirdness he was exposed to as a result of the channel was eye-opening and shocking to me. Some weirdness is to be expected, but the level of stalking resulting from even such a non-controversial channel is not something I would have thought of. Edit: Didn't think of the "locksmiths hate it" aspect that probably explains at least some of the crazy (e.g. trackers).
- therealdrag0 5y agoI hear about these crazy stalker-ish things from different public people like once a year, and I'm always amazed.