3 ms·
It's almost impossible to compare the level of aphantasia people may or may not have, since all they can share is their opinions of their experiences. It's diff
by jiggawatts 5y ago
It's almost impossible to compare the level of aphantasia people may or may not have, since all they can share is their opinions of their experiences. It's difficult to do an objective comparison.
That aside, I do believe I have some form of aphantasia. I was talking to an artist colleague about his process, and he said that essentially he just visualises something on the paper and more or less just traces the outline of the mental image that he projects.
At the time, I couldn't even begin to imagine what that was like. Then one day while I was half asleep, I suddenly was able to picture simple geometric shapes and even human faces on the white wall next to my bed. Like black and white holograms, they were seemingly "right there", floating just above the surface of the wall. I reached out and I could trace the outlines with my finger.
I haven't been able to reproduce that, and it only happened a few times during the period of a few weeks.
Ah well, I guess I'll never be an artist...
- pram 5y agoDrawing is a technical skill you develop with directed practice like anything else. It has nothing to do with tracing magical images from your head.
- jiggawatts 5y agoI've heard this, and I did take a class in drawing once. I improved, and could see a path towards becoming good, but it was not "the same". The artist I was referring to didn't draw "iteratively", like most people. He didn't start with a pencil sketch outline that he refined progressively until it looked like the subject. Instead, he'd pick up a pen, put it on the paper, and then he just traced a single continuous outline, moving the pen inwards to fill in details. All in one movement, without picking up the pen. I saw him draw a "dwarf with a hammer" character like this, complete with clothes down to the buttons. A detailed beard and expressive face. Boots with the tops turned down. Wrinkles in the pants. A belt with a buckle. Detail upon detail. But he just... traced it. From the outside in. You couldn't even tell what he was going to draw until a couple of minutes. PS: I've also met a guy who could do the same kind of thing with programming. Most people build up code iteratively, "sketching" the structure using interfaces or function definitions, building them up and refining them one piece at a time. Not this guy. He'd just stare off into space, and then start typing. Left-to-right, top-to-bottom, non-stop. I saw him open seven consecutive brackets and the close the last one a page and a half later. He did this for a couple of hours at a fast typing rate, then hit compile. There were 3 typos due to a sticky shift key. He fixed those, and then the code compiled, ran, and successfully completed the (very complex!) problem. These were some of the freakiest thing I've ever witnessed in my life. Some people's brains just work differently to mine, and I won't ever be able to "think like them".
- scruple 5y agoDon't lose hope! I linked this article in another comment in this thread. You may be surprised to learn that the co-founder of Pixar and many of the animators they surveyed internally also have aphantasia. [0] I have been learning how to draw over the last 2.5 years, since discovering both that I also have aphantasia and that some of the best animators in the world do, too. I always thought it was unapproachable for the same reasons. I started with the book "Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain." [0]: https://www.bbc.com/news/health-47830256 https://www.bbc.com/news/health-47830256