4 ms·
You can see any quantum event, such that is only described by a probability, as a fork. It produces two universes, in one if which the event has occurred, in an
by nine_k 5y ago
You can see any quantum event, such that is only described by a probability, as a fork. It produces two universes, in one if which the event has occurred, in another has not, otherwise identical.
Using this model, it is easy to imagine "parallel realities" which are very close to ours and thus amenable to fantasizing, but different enough to contain whatever makes the fantasies attractive.
- bee_rider 5y agoRight, and it is interesting because 'quantum events' happen very often, which would seem to indicate an infinite number of universes, which means that any particular fantasy you'd like to think about is occurring in some of them. The bit I get fuzzy at: something I believe, but without proof, is that any scheme that involved any communication between universes would fundamentally violate a ton of basic physics principles. I mean, it would seem to violate the definition of universe as the totality of existence, but that's just a definition. But I'm sure (again, without actually doing any math or physics) that it must violate some conservation of energy rules as well. Edit: I bet there's a really slick line of argument like: if you want to duplicate a universe, there's all that matter in the second copy to make, which you've got to pay E=mc^2 for. This is OK in the many worlds interpretation because <reasons relating to the universes being totally disconnected from each other, or something like that>. But if they were connected to each other <the previous reasons would somehow be invalid>. But filling in those two blanks -- that sort of stuff is why I retreated to thermodynamics, with the rest of the engineers.
- drdeca 5y agoCheck out the concept of a "Everett-Wheeler telephone". If quantum mechanics had a non-linearity and... some other conditions, then you could use it to send, uh, some information between two sides of a branch point, uh, once, I think. At least, you could send a single bit from one side of the branch to the other. I think the idea is, if there are non-linearities in time evolution, then either [the thing described above] is possible, or sending messages back in time is possible? So, that's, I suppose, a reason one might expect time evolution to be completely linear? (beyond just, it being not completely linear being like, super ugly.) But, also, I don't think the "duplicating the universe requires duplicating all the matter" really follows from QM stuff. These "splittings", they aren't... It is all just linear combinations of things. Ok, so, idk how to handle this in like, a relativistic context, but in a non-relativistic context, if you are just talking about unitary time evolution, with no born rule discrete jump stuff imposed on top (which, if you are using MWI , which I assume is what you mean because you are talking about the splittings, is the thing), then it's not like you have some single time at which you go from one universe to two universes? It's all just continuous time evolution of the wavefunction. The worlds are just projections of this wavefunction into parts that can be considered independently because of like, decoherence and such? Something like that. Maybe you could think of it as less "the world if the measurement outcome is x" and more "the world insofar as the measurement outcome is x" ?
- desertrider12 5y agoThere was a really great short story by Ted Chiang about this concept (finite communication between forks): https://onezero.medium.com/anxiety-is-the-dizziness-of-freedom-b5ab45cae2a5 https://onezero.medium.com/anxiety-is-the-dizziness-of-freed... . I found it from an HN post a couple months ago.
- rapjr9 5y ago>if you want to duplicate a universe, there's all that matter in the second copy to make, which you've got to pay E=mc^2 for. This bothers me also, it's like every tiny quantum event creates a Big Bang in a new dimension. There is information duplication as well. Without a way to communicate between dimensions there would seem to be absolutely no way to test this theory. Maybe every quantum event is a communication? And why a new universe for every event? Why not just two universes? And how does time fit in? Maybe the second universe would be the first universe running backwards in time? The energy and information duplication seems too extreme. Could new dimensions eventually fill all possible dimensions and start to collide or overlap? Maybe our universe is a superposition of all dimensions?
- bee_rider 5y agoI think that last bit is part of it -- the idea is that really there ought to be a wavefunction for the whole universe, so it is fine for the universe to be in a superposition (deemed the multiverse).
- pyinstallwoes 5y agoAnd while we're at it, take any imaginative 'thing' that fits like a fabled Panacea of Axiom and conclude any conclusion as "matter of fact" in another reality, which will never be dealt with in the physical whatsoever. My, what a fork of paths have we diverged from the seeking to understand the physical. Anyone? Smells like a bad test suite that's been patched by hiding the failing tests through a layer of indirection.