5 ms·
More Cash Invested in Stock in 2021 Than Two Decades Combined
- johng 5y agoPretty scary. A lot of this money has to be from new investors that have never seen a market correction. Hell, if you've invested in the past year, you've pretty much only seen the market go up up up!
- unstatusthequo 5y agoEr, past ~10 years I think?
- OJFord 5y agoMarch 2020 was brief for many sectors in hindsight, but quite brutal at the time. Of course if you expand your horizon and look only at the end vs. beginning it's fine, but you can do that well back past 2008 too. GP means 'never seen any significant drop at any point', not just that then came back up.
- bo1024 5y agoDunno, seems like the lesson anyone would have learned in 2020 is “the fed will save you and all losses are extremely temporary”, which is not like a real downturn.
- OJFord 5y agoMaybe, but it seems directionally correct. If you panicked and sold only to later repurchase (or not need the cash until later) that was bad - and even if you learnt not to do that for the wrong (or not generalisable) reason, you sort of learnt the right thing?
- thedougd 5y agoWinners win. What reason do new investors have to believe it will crash now? Pandemic? A global supply chain interruption? Democrat controlled U.S. government? Widespread protests and unrest? None of these things slowed the stock gains. Those who bought the usual tech stocks last year and held made 20% plus.
- MaxDPS 5y agoThe Pandemic did slow down the stock market…there were huge drops when we still didn’t know much about COVID-19. Once we realized that it wasn’t nearly as bad as and we’d be able to create a vaccine, it corrected again (as should be expected).
- peter303 5y agoTrillions of stimulus money funneled through Robinhood app.
- trashcan 5y agoAs of a couple months ago, Robinhood only had 80 billion USD in AUM. That said, I agree with the sentiment that there has been a ton more retail investment than usual, but I don't know how to quantify it.
- GDC7 5y agoStock market has become something that countries use to advertise and show power, much like GDP. Gone are the days when the S&P and the GDP represented a condensed data point to enable people to evaluate the general health of the economy and companies. This happens everywhere, as soon as a KPI start monopolizing the conversation, the optimizer/cheater in all of us decides to start finding ways to prop up the KPI instead of improving operations and let the KPI fall where it may. But truth cannot be hidden, lies won't conceal it. Even with stock market at all time highs, people are miserable, that's the only KPI you cannot fake.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fnord77 5y ago> people are miserable, that's the only KPI you cannot fake. too bad this can't really be quantified. Or can it?
- epicureanideal 5y agohttps://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2021/06/worlds-happiest-countries-denmark-finland-norway/619299/ https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2021/06/worlds-ha... > "If you imagine a ladder whose rungs are numbered zero to 10, and zero represents your worst possible life and 10 represents your best, which rung would you be on?" https://worldhappiness.report/ https://worldhappiness.report/ Alternative measurement method based on PERMA: https://www.peggykern.org/questionnaires.html https://www.peggykern.org/questionnaires.html
- throwawaysea 5y agoCan self reported data be relied upon? People only know the life they know and don’t necessarily know it could be better. I often find the Scandinavian ratings on these questions to be suspicious. Personally I found life in those countries to be boring and soulless. Everything was fine but it lacked spirit or something - I’m not sure what the right words are. Since then I’ve viewed their high responses with skepticism as I think the majority of Americans would not find life there to be some amazing utopia.
- tmerr 5y agoProbably cherry-picked stats. The article says "Investors have poured almost $900 billion into equity exchange-traded and long-only funds in 2021". So does that sum together to all "Stock"? What about mutual funds? And what even are long-only funds, are those popular? https://web.archive.org/web/20211125175105/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-25/stock-funds-took-in-more-cash-in-2021-than-two-decades-combined https://web.archive.org/web/20211125175105/https://www.bloom...
- voisin 5y agoLong only just means they don’t have short positions that would gain from a market downturn. I.e. they aren’t hedging.
- dsizzle 5y agoWhich is to say, yes, they're popular -- they're the vast majority of stock funds.
- tmerr 5y agoThanks. It might include more than I expected, but still "exchange-traded and long-only funds" would be missing anything that's not considered a fund, like individual stocks, that are still nonetheless in my mind part of "Stocks" in aggregate. Maybe they account for this, maybe not, it's really hard to understand without real sources in the article. All it really says it is some BofA report without any link to it.
- nkohari 5y agoETFs represent an aggregation of many individual stocks, though, so money flowing into ETFs (indirectly) means money flowing into individual stocks.
- tmerr 5y agoSure. But without every piece of the pie accounted for we can't tell whether the increase in money to funds is representative of the whole, or caused by shifting preferences
- bko 5y ago> Investors have poured almost $900 billion into equity exchange-traded and long-only funds in 2021 -- exceeding the combined total from the past 19 years -- according to analysts at Bank of America Corp. and EPFR Global. No discussion in the article about where this money came from. My guess is that it came from the direct covid payments and extended unemployment which amounted to ~$1.4 trillion. Of course personal expenditures went down as well due to covid, but if you look at Personal Consumption Expenditures you'll see it went from $14 bn in Feb 2020 (monthly) to $13.7bn to $12bn in March and April, but it quickly recovered. Today its 16,291, or 10% higher than the 2020-01-01 level. date PCE MoM diff 2020-01-01 14,770 2020-02-01 14,785 0% 2020-03-01 13,762 -7% 2020-04-01 12,022 -13% 2020-05-01 13,058 9% 2020-06-01 13,889 6% 2020-07-01 14,129 2% 2020-08-01 14,271 1% 2020-09-01 14,482 1% https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PCE https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PCE
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> No discussion in the article about where this money came from. My guess is that it came from the direct covid payments and extended unemployment which amounted to ~$1.4 trillion. Interest rates are so low that money that would normally go into bonds and money market funds was diverted into the stock market. Unemployment benefits did not prop the stock market up. People have to be unemployed to receive those benefits and the benefits are (excluding some periods of fuzzy COVID unemployment policy) less than normal wages, so unemployed people were suddenly receiving an influx of extra cash.
- bko 5y ago> Unemployment benefits did not prop the stock market up. People have to be unemployed to receive those benefits and the benefits are (excluding some periods of fuzzy COVID unemployment policy) less than normal wages, so unemployed people were suddenly receiving an influx of extra cash. That's not necessarily true. A study found that 68% of unemployment workers who can receive benefits got payments greater than their lost earnings. The median replacement rate was 134% so the median unemployed person getting benefits got a 34% raise. >> As a result, though, many people may now be eligible for substantially more money while unemployed than they made while they were working. A new analysis by Peter Ganong, Pascal Noel and Joseph Vavra, economists at the University of Chicago,1 uses government data from 2019 to estimate that 68 percent of unemployed workers who can receive benefits are eligible for payments that are greater than their lost earnings. They also found that the estimated median replacement rate — the share of a worker’s original weekly salary that is being replaced by unemployment benefits — is 134 percent, or more than one-third above their original wage. A substantial minority of those workers, particularly in low-wage professions like food service and janitorial work, may end up receiving more than 150 percent of their previous weekly salary.2 [0] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/many-americans-are-getting-more-money-from-unemployment-than-they-were-from-their-jobs/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/many-americans-are-gett...
- senko 5y agoThis needs to be compared to how much was (or was not) invested in bond and money markets compared to previous years. With everyone expecting rates to rise and seeing the inflationary pressure, it makes sense people choose stocks over bonds or cash equivalents.
- anm89 5y agoThis is the right answer. Bond markets are WAY bigger than equities markets and these figures represent a small preference shift out of bonds and into equities. If anything it tells me that these valuations could go a lot higher. And ironically its self perpetuating because if it crashes, rates will just be further suppressed reinforcing the move.
- beervirus 5y ago> Investors have poured almost $900 billion into equity exchange-traded and long-only funds in 2021 For context, the total market cap of the companies in the S&P 500 is around $39 trillion. So this is a decent sized inflow, but not as crazy as the headline makes it sound.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoWorth noting that net ETF inflow goes negative as investors withdraw from the stock market, so the past 19 years cited in this article includes both periods of net inflows and periods of net outflows. The article notes that the most recent week saw a net outflow from the stock market: > One possible sign of skittishness: investors have pulled money from stock funds only twice this year, and the second time was in the past week. Equity funds had $2.7 billion outflows in the week through Nov. 23, according to BofA. Also important to note that this is largely a product of low interest rates, not just stimulus money as many are suggesting. The stock market becomes the investment location of choice as low interest rates make bonds and money market unattractive. Article mentions this at the very bottom: > The amount of money moving into the stock market dwarfed anything else this year. Bond funds attracted just $496 billion and money market funds received about $260 billion.
- hanniabu 5y agoWhere did all this additional money come from?
- neffy 5y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/27/stock-buybacks-surge-to-likely-record-highs-but-a-tax-from-congress-poses-a-threat.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/27/stock-buybacks-surge-to-like... Stock Buybacks (i.e. from corporate "investment") amongst other things.
- missedthecue 5y agoThis article is talking about ETF and ETN inflows. Buybacks will have no impact on this number.
- throwaway13337 5y agoSo what happens when people get scared again and we have another large downturn? The idea people seem to have is that the Fed will step in. Maybe buying stocks like it buys bonds? It's following the Bank of Japan playbook so that's next, I suppose. At that point, doesn't inflation become a major concern, though? The reason people aren't holding bonds and cash anymore is not that they are fearless or that there is no return on the money like there used to be. They're actively fearful that holding cashing or bonds is just being a chump for when the indirect money print ramps up. There are only two ways I see this going. Rapid inflation followed by a new currency made with a real promise of backing (probably not crypto). Or a stagnation of the economy for a long time. Maybe there is a third way. I'd love a different perspective because both of these sound pretty painful.
- bsder 5y ago> The idea people seem to have is that the Fed will step in. See. People can learn. Cash reserves are only useful if things are allowed to fail. Then, the people with cash can buy the remnants and put the failed stuff to good use. If, however, everyone who overextended themselves are always going to get bailed out, holding cash is for suckers--better to run up the credit just like everybody else.
- shioyama 5y agoSo true and so sad.
- dogweather 5y agoSounds like click-bait fake news. Are these dollar amounts adjusted for inflation? As a percentage of disposable income? Etc.
- TomGullen 5y agoDoesn't this also (largely) mean more stock was sold for cash in 2021 than the same two decades combined?
- altspace 5y agoI’ve been wondering about same /similar thing. I keep hearing that increase in m2 supply is ok as long it goes into assets… not sure how it’s ok since cash still stays in circulation
- dsizzle 5y agoThe title here is missing a key word compared to the source: it's stock funds that have had more cash invested, not simply stock. So it's true that every stock purchase has a corresponding seller, but the same is not true for stock funds.
- swader999 5y agoMaybe a million dollars just isn't what it used to be.
- xwdv 5y agoIt definitely isn’t. There’s so many more millionaires out there now. It’s not a big deal anymore, I expect most people will become millionaires at some point in their life, probably 30s. I hit a million 3 years ago and have already doubled that. 8 figures is the new goal.
- endisneigh 5y ago> I expect most people will become millionaires at some point in their life, probably 30s. The people on here are so out of touch with reality, lol.
- naveen99 5y agoAverage age to reach a millionaire in the usa is 55. https://www.lexingtonlaw.com/blog/finance/average-net-worth-by-age.html https://www.lexingtonlaw.com/blog/finance/average-net-worth-...
- sumeno 5y agoThe averages are blown way out by the top. The median never tops $300k, so no, most people are not millionaires by their 30s
- naveen99 5y agoIf we valued people’s net worth like we value companies listed on the nasdaq, with P/E ratios of 40, median us worker with earnings of 60k, is at $2.4 million before 30. Note, the median salary of nasdaq listed company employees is probably not much higher than 60k without whom the companies wouldn’t sustain their own valuations.
- carom 5y agoA lot of this is from institutional investors fleeing the bond market.
- skybrian 5y agoWhere did the money go? Who was on the other side of the transactions?