3 ms·
Interesting to see them mention tulpas here. It's always been a bit of a meme online, but I knew a pretty tenured hypnotist who was utterly terrified of the thi
by smoldesu 5y ago
Interesting to see them mention tulpas here. It's always been a bit of a meme online, but I knew a pretty tenured hypnotist who was utterly terrified of the things. He'd seen tulpas cause irreversible psychological damage to the people who adopted them, where many people would become completely attached to a character or particular fiction in their head. This could cause them to act out involuntarily, induce constant paranoia or even completely alter their perception of reality. He figures the human brain is simply not meant for multiple inhabitants, and I'm inclined to agree. Hearing the occasional story of a person who's gotten in too far with tulpas just makes me sad, particularly because there's no real easy "fix" for it. Oftentimes, people wall themselves in to an altered reality and refuse to leave, be it by their own volition, or even another's.
- bencollier49 5y agoFrom reading around the subject there seems to be a weird intersection between the My Little Pony fandom, Tulpas, and some of the more unusual sexual proclivities. I actually know an exorcist from a mainline church; I should ask him what he makes of it.
- spats1990 5y agoWhat's interesting about this stuff is that it seems to support interpretation through multiple cognitive frameworks. There could be a mystical/esoteric explanation for why those people became so attached to the characters or fictions. Or it could be that they were already vulnerable to schizophrenic or depersonalization/derealization-type disorders. It's like how you'll sometimes hear/read people say that tantra/mediation stuff like Kundalini can be dangerous because it results in an energy imbalance that could potentially be irreparable and/or lead to lasting damage.
- bencollier49 5y agoYeah, the various explanations are a bit like geometry vs. algebra in maths. They're different tools for explaining the same things.
- thisiswater 5y agoThis is interesting, because my (more literary than scientific) understanding of ego development includes becoming aware of an 'inner tribe' or 'multiple voices' inside one's mind which simultaneously are and aren't the self, to differing degrees. Integrating these voices, allowing them to discuss with each other, et cetera has been a method which allows great insight into problems where reaching a solution was blocked by a limited perspective. Accessing these voices is invaluable for writing fiction, perhaps the difference with a tulpa is the level of reality and influence ascribed to a single 'not-me' voice? I also see the ability to have an internal Socratic dialogue as requiring a kind of ego-splitting, in a way that could be conceptualized as a tulpa asking (often surprising) questions. Very abstract and hard to talk about stuff, I hope that makes sense.
- rendx 5y agoSee for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_Family_Systems_Model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_Family_Systems_Model (of which I am a big fan, and it helped me a lot to work through past trauma and deal with my emotions), https://www.theemotionmachine.com/the-mindbus-technique/ https://www.theemotionmachine.com/the-mindbus-technique/ , https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/brainsnacks/201606/whos-riding-your-me-bus https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/brainsnacks/201606/w... etc
- Eelongate 5y agoI lost one of my friends to the tulpa crap a few years ago. It's self-induced schizophrenia and it ruined his life. He lost his job, all of his friends, and last I heard was living on the street.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoSchizophrenia is more common than people think. Happened to a family member but medication calmed the voices and they are steady now. I wonder what it takes for people to accept they are not well though…
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]