4 ms·
Direct democracy killed Socraties. The current system, flawed as it is, does a reasonable job of prevention the most stupid ideas from getting Mainstream attent
by tomjen3 15y ago
Direct democracy killed Socraties. The current system, flawed as it is, does a reasonable job of prevention the most stupid ideas from getting Mainstream attention.
The people deciding political issues wouldn't be the reasonable and smart people who hang around here. It will be the people who stand around picking funerals, people who never graduated high school, functional illiterates and the drug dealers in the inner cities.
Is it really that kind of people, the ones who can be convinced with a few late night tv commercials, you want to run your country?
- david927 15y agoDirect democracy killed Socraties. No, no it did not. Direct democracy means the legislative branch doesn't use a proxy. There are still two other branches. How is this so hard to understand? Elected representatives are supposed to fully represent their constituents. There is not supposed to be a difference between the rep. and who they represent. What direct democracy says is that the proxy of a representative has been corrupted and is no longer necessary. That is all. P.S. The whole notion that representatives are "smarter" than their constituents is both false (Michelle Bachman?) and elitist. Who the fuck are you to decide that people are too dumb to have a democracy? It's the same line throughout history and people have consistently proved it wrong.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThat there would be separate legislative and executive branches doesn't stop a direct democracy from passing laws that would punish Socrates again.
- david927 15y agoSure it does: laws are held to be constitutional by the judicial branch. Such laws as killed Socrates are not constitutional.
- jacques_chester 15y agoYou're still missing the point. Unpopular people would be made subject to laws meant to get them. This already happens in representative democracies, it would get much worse. Socrates might not be executed (depending on the constitution in question), but he might still find himself prisoner for life because the law had mandatory sentencing provisions.
- david927 15y agoAnd I think you're missing the point: representational government has been gamed. It's not about them being smarter and understanding the laws better (they often don't even read them, but use assistants for that); it's a bottleneck, ripe for corruption. Billions are at stake and only 535 people stand in the way; with lobbying(bribing) being perfectly legal. It's broken. You may not like it, but it's not really up to you (or me) to decide. The people can choose to eliminate that ineffective, rotten layer.
- jacques_chester 15y ago> And I think you're missing the point: representational government has been gamed. It's not about them being smarter and understanding the laws better (they often don't even read them, but use assistants for that); it's a bottleneck, ripe for corruption. Right. If you look elsewhere, you'll see my notes on the particulars of the US system. We have rent-seeking here in Australia, but nothing like the scale of the US. The difference is that US Members of Congress are basically independent agents. No party discipline, and no executive constraints, prevent them from that kind of deal-making. It's down to the peculiarities of the US system, not representative democracy in general. Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater. (Plus there's the standard libertarian argument that reducing the power of Congress reduces incentives to fiddle; but that doesn't do away with merely petty corruption).
- david927 15y agoAnd I think it's all bathwater. No more political parties. No more Coke/Pepsi choices of elected officials. No more outright corruption. Open government, e-democracy. The time has come.
- henrikgs 15y agoWhy is it false or elitist to assume that someone working full time on a subject is "smarter" than everyone else on that particular subject? I am pretty sure 99% of the lawyers in US would do a better job than me defending anyone in a trial. Every car mechanic in the world would do a better job than me fixing some mechanical problem in my car. Does this mean that I am dumb? No, it just means I devote my time to other areas of expertise. I really cannot see why this shouldn't apply for politicians as well.
- david927 15y agoWe can have people working full-time analyzing the subject and read what their opinions are. That's what representatives do, actually -- they have people who read the bills and give advice on what they think. I'm saying, like with so many areas, by using the internet we can skip the middle-man.
- danssig 15y ago>does a reasonable job of prevention the most stupid ideas from getting Mainstream attention. Citation needed? Some pretty stupid ideas get through and lots of corruption (e.g. "bridge to nowhere"). >The people deciding political issues wouldn't be the reasonable and smart people who hang around here. What kind of people do think are in the Senate/Congress? They're not the reasonable and smart people who hang around here either. And in any case, those people you so happily deride are choosing said representatives anyway. Any problems you see with giving everyone a say exist with giving a subset of those people a say. In fact I would say the problem is exaggerated with the smaller group because the kind of people who would be good for government are the kind who would never be willing to do that job. I bet they would be willing to voice their opinions though.