4 ms·
Because heaven forbid the masses have Internet access that their government doesn't have the means to censor or surveil.
by josephcsible 5y ago
Because heaven forbid the masses have Internet access that their government doesn't have the means to censor or surveil.
- shellfishgene 5y agoI don't think Starlink would currently work without base stations in India.
- josephcsible 5y agoCouldn't they make it work for most of the population of India by putting stations near the border in neighboring countries?
- bklyn11201 5y agoCould they bypass the laws of a nation state by using inter-satellite lasers? Yes! But what leads people to believe that Starlink is going to ignore the laws of powerful countries?!
- toast0 5y agoIndia is pretty sizable, and Starlink currently does not do any orbital routing, so you've got to be within a certain distance from a ground station so that the satellite has you and that ground station in view. I don't know what that distance is though --- maybe someone else can provide that. If Sri Lanka also doesn't allow ground stations, that would make it pretty hard to cover southern India. Even when there's orbital routing, there's likely capacity limits. If Pakistan doesn't block ground stations, it may be a good solution for people in Jammu and Kashmir to get around the frequent government telecommunications shutdowns; assuming lax enforcement.
- th3iedkid 5y agoPakistani sat phones , VoIP channels etc were always used for attacks in India[1] . So this too probably adds to that. [1] https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/tmc-claims-hollow-civic-poll-results-proved-people-of-tripura-have-faith-in-bjp-dilip-ghosh/articleshow/87960324.cms https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/tmc-cla...
- amoshi 5y agoIt's a reasonable concern for a government if the surveiling capability is shifted from themselves to a foreign government (USA with PRISM and all the other programmes)
- jiggawatts 5y agoThe surveillance by foreign governments will happen either way. What they Indian government is upset about is that they don't also get a chance to implement surveillance over their own people. That, and bribes. They want their fair share.
- outside1234 5y agoIn this case, they are probably also unhappy that they haven't received bribes.
- new_stranger 5y agoTrue, the vary foundations of proper commerce are threatened!
- rich_sasha 5y agoStarling receiver receives as well as emits radio waves, isn’t that tightly controlled everywhere?
- jazzyjackson 5y agowhy would starlink have different rules than any other ISP licensed to operate in India?
- Nextgrid 5y agoBecause Starlink has no physical infrastructure there and no plans to set it up. You can access a website without that website being somehow licensed to “operate” in your country. You should be able to talk to Starlink equipment (which is in space and outside of India’s jurisdiction) without them being licensed in India.
- bklyn11201 5y agoYou’re going to be shocked that A) Starlink will have lots of Indian ground infrastructure once approved B) Starlink will be highly compliant with nation state laws C) Starlink will comply with filtering requests made by nation states when the revenue is lucrative enough
- jazzyjackson 5y agoI think Starlink will have a hell of a time convincing any amount of prospective customers to smuggle in illegal transmitters - the triangulation of which is a solved problem but this is a moot argument, Elon is interested in funding Mars missions, he will comply with Indian censorship/regulations because there’s no profit without their blessing.
- bklyn11201 5y agoStarlink provides access to geographically diverse customers but doesn’t work well for dense population clusters. And what promises have been made around censorship? Do we have any reason to believe that Starlink will avoid large swathes of the world in the name of censorship-free services?
- Jansen312 5y agoConsider Indian consumer isn't with high purchasing power in comparison to EU, NA and APAC, Starlink can temporary avoid that and support Indian regional countries like Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. It is hard to believe Indian government able to tolerate that.
- dilawar 5y agoMay be Ambani's Jio is upset.
- bklyn11201 5y agoStarlink requires massive annual cap ex, is bandwidth limited per cell, and needs very expensive ground receivers. Jio is the most cost effective large-scale bandwidth provider ever created! They are on two different planets playing two different games.
- jhgb 5y agoActually, Starlink is not on a planet. (But that Indians don't like competition is understandable.)
- bklyn11201 5y agoIt’s just a misunderstanding on competition. Many Reddit forums show Americans looking for Starlink to compete with their fixed bandwidth provider like Comcast. American cable providers have very bad support reputations but generally provide about 300mbps for about $70 a month these days. Starlink is not real competition for the cable providers. Starlink will be a massive upgrade for users in remote locations that currently have the choice between DSL and slow satellite services. Starlink is giant competition for HughesNet and ViaSat.
- naruvimama 5y agoA bit of an outdated idea. Uber is illegal in many progressive EU countries. While it is free to operate in India. Developed countries play the free market game as long as they are the mercantilist in the room.
- desi_ninja 5y agoOr NSA reading other country's ppl data.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThis is nothing special to India or "evil" countries that like to censor/surveil their interwebs. Also, Indian politicians care far more about grift than they do surveillance (though they do also like surveillance.) We're talking about a country where one party tried to buy an election by distributing free color televisions: https://www.google.com/search?q=india+free+color+tvs+election https://www.google.com/search?q=india+free+color+tvs+electio... Many countries (the US included) regulate/license even receive-only satellite devices. It's not for surveillance or censorship reasons, it's for interference prevention reasons. If they didn't regulate ground stations, space would be a wild wild west of people beaming whatever frequencies, at whatever signal strengths, they wanted. Bit of history/trivia: many cell phones used to not support GLONASS satellite fixes within US territories because first telecom companies "forgot" to file the necessary paperwork with the FCC to get GPS chips in phones licensed for GLONASS reception. Then when they did, the FCC sat on the paperwork for no particularly good reason. Used to be you could enjoy a GPS/GLONASS/Galileo satellite position fix on a cross-atlantic flight and watch as your fix dropped to just GPS the second you crossed into US territory.
- orangepurple 5y agoJust wait until you learn about the Central Board of Film Certification