17 ms·
The author draws the wrong conclusions from the CV experiment. He claims that it shows a bias against black candidates; in reality, what it shows is a bias aga
by cperciva 15y ago
The author draws the wrong conclusions from the CV experiment. He claims that it shows a bias against black candidates; in reality, what it shows is a bias against "black" names.
Names are really powerful. The same is true of email addresses; how many people here can honestly say that they would treat an email from purpledinosaur28@aol.com the same way as they treat an email from john.smith@gmail.com?
- BCM43 15y agoPlease explain your point further, because it seems to me you are equating "black" names with cheesy email addresses.
- cperciva 15y agoNames say something about the people who pick them. Yes, race; but also education, socioeconomic level, and community. The black population of the US is heavily weighted towards poor education and poverty, so when people think of "typical black names" they're often thinking of typical poor uneducated black names.
- ldd- 15y agoKey difference . . . names are chosen by a person's parents, while email addresses are chosen by a person for themselves. Focusing on the name, which the person can't control, instead of on the person's accomplishments (resume), which the person can absolutely control, would seem to be an indicator of bias. I don't think your point holds up.
- cperciva 15y agoYou don't think that your parents' income or education level has an effect on your later success? And sure, it would be better to ignore names and focus on a resume -- but people rely on subconscious cues all the time. If your only goal is to find good candidates as quickly as possible, a subconscious cue which is usually correct works to your advantage -- whether it's "people with degrees from Harvard are stuck-up snobs", "people who write their resumes in LaTex are good coders", or "people with weird names like 'jewyl' are useless".
- jbri 15y agoMaking important decisions based on stereotypes rather than facts tends to be frowned upon these days. And (at least in the US) it opens yourself up to huge discrimination suits if you base your discrimination on protected classes like gender or race.
- cperciva 15y agoI'm not saying that people should do this. Only that they do, and (barring legal consequences) it's advantageous to do so.
- kenjackson 15y agoThis just seems odd given that you have a page of information which is probably a lot more informative. But that's kind of the definition of racism -- even in the face of evidence that would contradict your stereotype you'll cling to your stereotype.
- cperciva 15y agoSure, you have a page of information which is more informative. And you have Google, which is probably even more informative. And you could start phoning college professors and get even more information. There's a point where the cost of gathering information exceeds its value. Unfortunately, that point sometimes comes halfway through reading a resume.
- n09n 15y agoWhen you're comparing the candidate against someone else with the exact same resume that differs only by name, the rest of that information is not useful, because it doesn't help you distinguish between the choices.
- kenjackson 15y agoBut isn't that the point of the statement. It would be like saying that if you saw the candidate in person and they did the job equally well, but one had dark skin and the other light skin, so we used their skin color to distinguish -- but then trying to argue that skin color isn't really a proxy for race, since some black people could be lighter than a white person. To me it just sounds like racism covered up.
- ldd- 15y agoIn response to cperciva's comment . . . Statistically? Sure . . . on an individual basis? Should be irrelevant . . . that's why we base employment decisions upon the resume of the individual and not based upon the resume of the parents.
- jcampbell1 15y agoThis is not completely true. Of the 10 or so people I have hired, 3 had resume names different from their legal names. One had a Pakistani name, another was chinese, and one had a ghetto name. It is well known that you can put whatever name on your resume you want. It is not until after you are hired that you have to submit documentation.
- bootload 15y ago"... Names say something about the people who pick them. ..." There is a freakonomics discussion about the power of name choice in "Super Freakonomics", CH6, "Perfect Parenting, Part II; or: Would a Roshanda by Any Other Name Smell as Sweet?" which hints at this ~ http://freakonomicsbook.com/freakonomics/chapter-excerpts/chapter-6/ http://freakonomicsbook.com/freakonomics/chapter-excerpts/ch... and http://www.slate.com/id/2116449/ http://www.slate.com/id/2116449/ though the message I got was the signaling the name gave to others & the recipient of the name mattered more.
- hackinthebochs 15y agoI think you're trying too hard to explain how a bias against black names isn't a bias against the racial group. The article said they used archetypal black names such as "Latoya" or "Tyrone". Taking this at face value, there is no indication of lower socioeconomic level unless you're taking being black itself as the indication. We're not talking about made up ghetto names that we all love to disparage these days. Being biased against standard <racial group> names is in fact a bias against <racial group>.
- rayiner 15y agoYou don't see a lot of black guys named "Tyrone" walking around Harvard. Latoya and Tyrone are common black names, and they're also strongly associated with lower socioeconomic level because lots of blacks are in a lower socioeconomic level. The sorts of professional, educated black families that send their kids to good schools and from there to good jobs don't name them these lower-class names.
- kenjackson 15y agoTyrone is just not a common name at all anymore. You're not likely to meet someone named Tyrone at a Crip hangout.
- hackinthebochs 15y agoSo you're saying that any black name is automatically associated with lower class. I would contend that this proof that bias against names is bias against the race. Edit: just to explain a bit more: my point is that Tyrone and Latoya are not indicative of lower class, any more than simply being black is. Thus a bias against those names is a bias against black in general.
- chc 15y agoIf I recall correctly, names that are considered distinctively black but not actually African do tend to be associated with lower-class blacks. It's unfortunate but AFAIK that's the way the world is, largely because blacks historically have felt pressure to seem more "white" as they've moved up in society. So it's hard to disambiguate the two factors. I'd bet you'd see a similar bias against lower-class white names like Bubba or Leroy or most of the names here: http://babynamesworld.parentsconnect.com/forum/topic88623.html http://babynamesworld.parentsconnect.com/forum/topic88623.ht... If it is purely economic, you probably also wouldn't see as much bias against black-sounding names that don't have negative connotations such as Michael Jackson (it might get a smirk, but if it is indeed about economic bias, the name of a prestigious black man should be a good demonstration).
- ajays 15y ago"Names say something about the people who pick them. Yes, race; but also education, socioeconomic level, and community...." You are forgetting one not-so-minor fact that the resumes were _identical_ to the white ones'. Are you saying that the recipients just looked at the names and didn't even bother to read the resumes??
- cperciva 15y agoI'm saying that having seen the names people didn't read the resumes as closely, yes.
- Someone 15y agoIt could also mean that they read them differently. Say they took two years more than normal for high school. On the one hand, that can trigger thoughts about laziness or lack of intelligence. On the other, it can trigger thoughts about perseverence (many others would have given up), or about how the recruiter 'lost' two years in high school, too, because his father died in a house fire. Fighting one's prejudices is really hard.
- gcb 15y agoi think i got the parent comment's point. it's not about race in this case, but assuming --even if with the back of the mind, how the candidate would fit into the cultural aspect of the organization. Imagine a guy in a organization that has a heavy crunch time every friday until late if needed. in the several interviews when he mention that, he noticed that the group of people that turn down the position because of this is of some cultural group. The next time he is hiring, even if only on the back of his mind, he will go past the candidates that have names indicating that said cultural group, because his brain will fast forward to all the time wasted interviewing and then being turned down. it's not like the guy has anything against that group. In the article, the point made is far worse than this example. From a moral point of view. as it hints to a macro-social preconception on race.
- alister 15y agoThere's something about the CV experiment that makes no sense to me: The researchers also found that although high-quality "white" candidates were preferred to low-quality "white" candidates, the relative quality of "black" CVs made no difference whatsoever. It was as if employers saw three categories - high-quality white, low-quality white and black candidates. We know that the "black" candidates got some responses, and we know that the "black" CVs did have differences in quality. So on what basis were the employers choosing the black candidates on the occasions that they did choose a black candidate? Randomly? It's a big anomaly in the experiment I think, and should be explained somehow.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- doctoboggan 15y agoI am sure each employer thought they were choosing the best person for the job, not weighing the benefits of a black person vs a white person. The point is that when all these decisions are summed up a bias emerges. The author of this argument is arguing that our tendency to incorrectly clump people into groups is the reason for this bias.
- alister 15y agoI think you misunderstood my point. I'm not talking about blacks vs whites. I asking why this experiment doesn't show any difference between high-quality and low-quality black candidates. Using the names suggested by the article, suppose Tyrone is a high-quality black candidate and Latoya is a low-quality black candidate. The experiment shows that employers--when they do choose a "black" candidate--will choose Tyrone and Latoya equally often. The employer supposedly has no preference for the better CV among the black applicants. Does that make any sense to you? It makes me suspicious of the whole experiment.
- doctoboggan 15y agoYes, they were saying the employers classified all black applicants as the same and didn't notice the difference in their actual quality. Because they had a black name that is the first and only label they get.
- rickmb 15y agoExactly. A black candidate won't trigger any subconscious prejudices in me (half my family is black). Certain African-American names like "Tyrone" or "Latoya" however will trigger negative associations with social and cultural stereotypes. The same actually goes for certain "white" names.
- dave84 15y ago'Tyrone' is Irish, not African-American.
- hackinthebochs 15y agoThe problem is, when there are no black names that won't trigger that bias, that is in fact a bias against the race. Whether that bias stems from socioeconomic level or from prejudice is beside the point.