4 ms·
It's a fine and thoughtful article, but I'm not sure that I see the logical fallacy. Assuming that this success is driven by genes rather than environment, the
by nkurz 15y ago
It's a fine and thoughtful article, but I'm not sure that I see the logical fallacy.
Assuming that this success is driven by genes rather than environment, there is a rather obvious inference to make - black people are naturally better sprinters than white people.
But here's the thing. This inference is not merely false - it is logically flawed.
If we assume that sprinting performance is genetic (and realizing that there are lots of other factors), and we assume that the best 100m sprinters are consistently black (realizing that "black" may or may not be a clearly defined genetic category), is it really a fallacy to say that black people are better sprinters?
Logically, so long as the prevalence of winners is greater than the percentage of the population defined as black, I would think it has to follow. The winning sprinters are also strong, lean, and young. Would it be a fallacy to say that "strong, lean and young runners make better sprinters"?
The obvious fallacy is to conclude that all blacks are better sprinters. But it feels like the article goes far beyond this, and wants to redefine "better" as incompatible with "more likely to excel". And pointing out that Americans and Jamaicans tend to excel seems to run counter to the part where he asks us to assume that the success is driven by genes.
Hmm. His book "Bounce" sounds interesting, though. I've requested it from the library. And oddly, I found 4 year old version of essentially the same article (minus the reference to resumes, adding reference to "yellow" domination at table tennis, and advertising a different book) here: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest_contributors/article2189194.ece http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest_co...
- pkulak 15y agoThe problem is in the sample size. You can't draw any conclusions from testing a few dozen or hundred self-selected people out of 7 billion. The author does essentially say just that, just in many more words.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago...is it really a fallacy to say that black people are better sprinters? Yes. Data on the Olympics gives very little information on whether the average black person is a better sprinter than the average white person. It is not, however, a fallacy to say that it is highly likely that the next top sprinter will be black. (If anyone disagrees with this claim, I'm willing to offer good odds on the race of the next Olympic sprinter medalists.) Honestly, I'm finding the author's exposition to be rather confused. He seems to conflate two logically distinct propositions ("the best $x come from group $Y" and "a random $y in $Y has a higher probability of outperforming a random $z in $Z") for reasons I can't fathom.
- sambe 15y ago...and in fact I believe that Freakonomics suggests that black athletic ability is more about variance than average.
- nkurz 15y agoI agree with you on "very little information", but I wouldn't want to make the jump to "fallacy". It would be a fallacy to presume that the between-group difference is anything approaching the within-group difference, but I'd guess that the effect is there. Instinctively, I wouldn't be surprised if genetics played at least a 1% role. Would you? What if instead of "black", you pointed to a particular gene? The alternative would be to presume that the variance of sprinting ability with the black population is greater than that of the white. I'd want to see some reason that this is true before presuming it. This also gets us back to the furor regarding Lawrence Summers dismissal from Harvard, which does imply that there some things that are simply "wrong to note".
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt would not surprise me at all if genetics plays a large role. The only point I'm making is about inferring information about the mean/median of a distribution by observing only it's far tails. In fact, I'd speculate that across the US population, black sprinting ability is probably lower than that of whites. Black women are disproportionately overweight/obese and are likely to lower the average for blacks. Looking solely at olympic level data points would never reveal this. (As far as I'm aware, this latter effect is minimally related to genetics.)
- nkurz 15y agoThe only point I'm making is about inferring information about the mean/median of a distribution by observing only it's far tails. That's the same point I'm making, but I come to the opposite conclusion. I think that in the absence of contradictory information one should prefer simple inferences to complex ones (Occam rephrased). Thus I'd look first to the mean, then to the variance, and only then consider that only one of the groups has a multi-modal distribution. I do think our "overcompensation" for race affects our conclusions here (mine included). If one were to find that the winners shared some other trait other than skin color, I don't think there would be nearly the same desire to find alternative explanations. But this doesn't mean that these alternatives are not useful to consider, and quite possibly correct.
- mynegation 15y ago> The obvious fallacy is to conclude that all blacks are better sprinters. It is a question of semantics here. The general and a vague inferred claim is that "Black people tend to be better sprinters than other races". If that means that "There exist black people that run better than any people of all other races", then this statement is verifiably true: just look at the Olympic charts. Now, if statement is that "If you pick up a random black person and put them in a race against a person of other race (no pun intended), black person is more likely to win" - it would be a logical fallacy to make that statement based just on the fact that Olympic winners in running are all black.