4 ms·
It appears, based on the interesting submitted article, that it would be more informative to report about 100 meter dash winners where they trained, and who the
by tokenadult 15y ago
It appears, based on the interesting submitted article, that it would be more informative to report about 100 meter dash winners where they trained, and who their coaches were. Much the same could be said about marathon winners, who tend to train in a different part of the world.
After edit: the kind first reply to my comment here mentions a possible study design for looking at what might influence athletic success among athletes from one place or another. A "genetically sensitive" design for such a study would have to consider quite a few other issues, not least actual individual genes, which have been surprisingly neglected in genetic research over the years. (Rather than actually looking at genes of each individual in a study, which continues to be a generally expensive and occasionally error-prone enterprise, most previous genetic studies of human behavioral characteristics have been based on proxy assemblages of genes, by studying closely related family members, or in the best cases monozygotic twins.)
Readers who haven't seen this pair of links before, which I share fairly often here on HN because they are by world famous human behavioral geneticists, may be surprised by what they learn from reading about what twin studies can and cannot say about genetic influences on human behavior.
http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20Online%20CV/Turkheimer%20(2008).pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20O...
http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20Online%20CV/Johnson%20(2009).pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Articles%20for%20O...
Meanwhile other readers have commented, and tying in what I've written (and linked to) above to what several comments here say, a common fallacy comes from assuming that "race" (as socially defined in one place or another) has anything much at all to do with what genes one would find in a particular individual. Serious geneticists are actually some of the leading scientists in suggesting that in medicine, law, and education we should pay less attention to "race" than formerly, to avoid inherent cognitive biases in explaining individual differences.
- geuis 15y agoYou're right, but that's only part of the extended question. If most 100m runners are from a tiny part of the world, it would be interesting to do biological studies to see if the people living there have different genetics that let them become better runners. Your control in this type of study would be to put non-locals under the same lifestyle and training as how the winners live and see how they perform.
- eleusive 15y agoThis series of articles[1] goes into some depth in explaining why certain countries (and ethnicities) dominate various sports - this includes an in-depth discussion of why Kenyans are so good at distance running. The author focuses on genetics, location, support, training, incentives, culture, etc. of various combinations of these sports and the countries that seem to dominate them. It's not yet complete and is quite lengthy, but it's one of the most fascinating things I've read in some time. While the title seems to make the article focuses solely on Olympic Weightlifting, but the main focus is much more general, and is about uncovering recurring patterns between countries who dominate various sports. [1] http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/why-the-us-sucks-at-olympic-lifting-part-1.html http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/why-the-us-sucks-a...
- jacques_chester 15y agoOlympic Weightlifting is an interesting case. Some of the qualities that predict weightlifting success -- high fast-twitch fibre ratio, for example -- predict success in plenty of other sports. Whether a country excels at Weightlifting seems in large part to be a function of whether there is a more popular sport in that country. So in the Carribean potential lifters become sprinters, in the USA they become NFL players, in Australia rugby and AFL players and so on.
- truthout 15y agoTo claim that every 100m champion in the last 18 years has won because of coaching is the profoundly stupid and intellectually dishonest. To claim there is no genetic selection for speed is profoundly stupid and intellectually dishonest. Evolutionary biology is a reflection of your environment. To believe that different environments don't produce different selective pressures is profoundly stupid and intellectually dishonest. To believe this, we must dismiss all evolutionary theory that has been put forth in the last 200 years. The sad fact is that evolutionary biology, with genome analysis, it arriving at facts that humans have been avoiding in recent history. These facts indicate that a large percent of your ability is due to heredity. This does not mean that all of your ability is due to heredity, but it does mean a significant portion is. And it's inescapable. As science advances, this fact will become more evident. But, one has to understand that the best work the hardest, since, at the top, genes are comparable in terms of ability. But it also means that I will never be the fastest person on earth, regardless of how hard i try.