3 ms·
As others have said, you're using definitions that are very much not the normal ones. If you're talking to other people, you don't get to make up your own defi
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
As others have said, you're using definitions that are very much not the normal ones. If you're talking to other people, you don't get to make up your own definitions.
But, more: I'm a "worker". I work for other people. I also make a borderline-top-10% income. I make more than many small business owners. So I'm not middle class, because I have a job? Class is about how I get the money, not how much money I get?
And in your last paragraph, you talk about "the upper income class". Is there one class hierarchy that is based on income, and another that is based on source of income? If so, why should I have solidarity with my income-source group rather than with my income-level group? And if not, then what are you trying to say in your last paragraph?
- dllthomas 5y ago> you don't get to make up your own definitions It's a historical use still common in some contexts. I agree that being clear on the definitions being used is important, including marking explicitly where definitions may be different from what the reader is familiar. But it's not a definition dragonwriter has simply invented. The Wikipedia page on middle class has more info.