3 ms·
The address translation, either with segments or with pages, is the essential function of a MMU and by far its most complex feature. Adding flags for additiona
by adrian_b 5y ago
The address translation, either with segments or with pages, is the essential function of a MMU and by far its most complex feature.
Adding flags for additional features piggy-backed over the address translation, e.g. memory protection, is the easy part of a MMU.
80286 added memory protection, which is essential for a multi-user operating system, like UNIX. That is why it was the first Intel CPU to which UNIX was ported, but any computer with address space extension must have a MMU.
8088/8086 was indeed unusual in having a MMU without memory protection, because it was intended only for personal computers, while the previous computers expensive enough to need address space extension were all intended for multi-user applications, so all included memory protection in the MMUs.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago"Address translation" at the level done by the 8088 is not the most complex part of a MMU. It's a shift and an add. So, no. That's not what any of the rest of us mean by "MMU".
- monocasa 5y agoAnd in hardware, the shift is free, so it's literally just a 12+16 adder.
- johndoe0815 5y agoThere was a Xenix version for the 8086. Of course, without memory protection, a misbehaving process was able to wreak havoc. You can run the system in your browser using the pcjs emulator: https://www.pcjs.org/software/pcx86/sys/unix/sco/xenix/086/2.1.3/ https://www.pcjs.org/software/pcx86/sys/unix/sco/xenix/086/2...