5 ms·
I agree. These fake meats only get around the mistreatment of animals. As far as I can tell, they're worse for the environment and worse in terms of health im
by klyrs 5y ago
I agree. These fake meats only get around the mistreatment of animals. As far as I can tell, they're worse for the environment and worse in terms of health impact than eating meat. Not too long ago, a local fake sausage maker got into trouble for dumping their industrial waste into a stream. It's possible to farm animals ethically. This is not the way.
- __float 5y agoDo you have any links to back up the claim that they're worse for the environment? I've heard that they're better, and my immediate reaction would be to believe that. It takes a lot of plant material to raise a cow, so cutting out that step (and using the plants more directly) would seem that plant-based "meat" needs less water, land, emissions, etc.
- p0wn 5y agoLook up monoculture and what it's doing to the land. Destroying it. Why are we subsidizing soy crops anyways? Soy is terrible for your health. It contains loads of phytoestrogen and allergens. We are reliant on exporting the crop because it's not a part of the typical american diet. It's just bad news altogether.
- philips 5y agoI agree about monocultures being an issue in industrial farming. However, I am skeptical of all of the claims about soy particularly if you eat it as only part of your diet. That said Beyond Meat doesn't contain soy. Impossible does though. https://www.beyondmeat.com/products/beyond-beef https://www.beyondmeat.com/products/beyond-beef
- Spooky23 5y agoProcessed legumes and coconut oil has its own issues.
- __float 5y agoThat doesn't really seem completely related to the topic at hand. Besides, if we _were_ producing more things like Impossible foods that _did_ use soy, then we wouldn't need to export it as much? I'm not proposing all production in the US switch to soy crops, and your argument seems pretty disingenuous to me
- wumpus 5y ago> Besides, if we _were_ producing more things like Impossible foods that _did_ use soy, Impossible Foods is a drop in the bucket compared to tofu, but, there are too many calories of soy grown in the US to feed them all to humans. That's also true for corn.
- AlexandrB 5y agoWhat's wrong with phytoestrogen? Despite the name it's not the same thing as estrogen found in humans and it doesn't always trigger the same response in your body. The research[1][2] seems overall mildly positive on the effects of soy and phytoestrogen on health. At worst it's a wash. [1] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/soy/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/soy/ [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9888630/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9888630/
- Toutouxc 5y ago> It's possible to farm animals ethically. I believe that most artificial meat consumers would argue that it's impossible to kill and eat animals ethically. After all that's why they choose to eat the more expensive artificial meat instead of the real deal or no meat at all.
- wumpus 5y agoIf you talk to actual vegetarians and vegans, you'll find that there are more reasons than just ethics. It's a very diverse group of people.
- sjwalter 5y agoHow many animals does a 30 acre soy field kill? Have you ever seen how many foals are chewed up in a combine? IMO much more ethical to directly kill an animal vs. indirectly destroy its habitat or kill it accidentally (and then fail to use the carcass).
- UglyToad 5y agoOh in that case we better stop... uh.. eating animals since that drives demand for 77% of Soy consumption [0]. I know we must engage in good faith but the soy scaremongering sure does seem coordinated. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/soy https://ourworldindata.org/soy
- phonypc 5y agoI don't think it follows that because the largest fraction of soy consumption is as animal feed, that animal agriculture drives soy consumption. Soy animal feed is mostly a byproduct of soy oil and biofuel production. If not for that production, we'd just move to the next cheapest feed.
- tfehring 5y agoThe amount of feed crop acreage needed to produce a beef burger is much greater than the crop acreage needed to produce an Impossible burger, so the Impossible burger reduces the number of those habitats that are being destroyed. (I'm using "feed crop" loosely to include hay - even 100% grass-fed cattle can't just be pastured year-round in most areas, and cutting hay is just as bad as harvesting feed crops for any smaller animals that've made their homes in the fields.)
- arduinomancer 5y agoSorry but this is completely false. Look at the research. > the Beyond Burger generates 90% less greenhouse gas emissions, requires 46% less energy, has >99% less impact on water scarcity and 93% less impact on land use than a ¼ pound of U.S. beef. https://css.umich.edu/publication/beyond-meats-beyond-burger-life-cycle-assessment-detailed-comparison-between-plant-based https://css.umich.edu/publication/beyond-meats-beyond-burger...
- sjwalter 5y agoThis is one of the problems with the mainstream obsession about climate change. The environmental destruction wrought by gigantic, inhumanely scaled monocrop farming is direct, immediate, obvious, and worthy of huge mobilization to resolve. Instead, we hear, as you say here, that if the carbon emissions are low, it's Great For The Environment!
- arduinomancer 5y ago> inhumanely scaled monocrop farming And what do you think the animals are fed with? If you're going to have 8 billion people eating meat do you really think there's going to be less environmental impact growing the food for the animals + the impact of the animals themselves compared to just growing vegetables? I feel like meat scales even worse due to efficiency losses
- sjwalter 5y agoDepends on the animals. My cows are fed exclusively grass, right to finishing. My pigs and chickens are fed mixes of locally-sourced corn, oats, barley, peas, and lentils from organic growers. And they supplement with grasses and broadleafs because we raise 'em on pasture. Well-raised, environmentally reasonably-fed animals cost lots of money. Meat is basically the healthiest thing people can eat. If you just take the pasture-raised cows alone, the grass grows itself and large herbivores are a natural part of the environment here--the environment and its polyculture would be harmed by their removal.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago> It's possible to farm animals ethically. I am not convinced that this is true because it necessitates raising an animal for the sole purpose of slaughtering it. Though I realize that many will have a different measure of "ethical", I would say that these products are most certainly the way for me.