4 ms·
No. I use a recipe from an old Good Housekeeping Cookbook. + Put the bird in a roasting pan + Put foil over the roasting pan. + Cook at 450F + For the
by brudgers 5y ago
No. I use a recipe from an old Good Housekeeping Cookbook.
+ Put the bird in a roasting pan
+ Put foil over the roasting pan.
+ Cook at 450F
+ For the last 30 minutes, remove the foil
The standard instructions produce dry turkey because they are solely focused on food safety to reduce liability. Think about it this way, if you are using the "recipe" on the packaging, then you don't have experience cooking a turkey another way.
- jimhefferon 5y agoFor how long? Or to what temp?
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoThey say 450, but they don't say the duration, so a lame joke would be that the turkey is never dry because they never eat it, you just put another turkey on top of the remains of whatever you've been cooking since last year.
- gmfawcett 5y agoThat reminds me of the "garbage can turkey" we cooked at a Scouts camp one year. "Watch the temperature of the coals," we said to our turkey minder, "keep it low and slow."... But while we were hiking, the minder kept worrying it wouldn't cook in time, and so he piled on the charcoal. A few hours later, our 50+ pound bird had been transformed into a tiny black football. Fortunately there was a pizzeria a mile away, or it might have been Squirrel Soup on the menu that night. :)
- brudgers 5y agoThere's a table. It's in another comment. Looks like about 20min per lbs.
- akerl_ 5y agoYou had me until 450F. Is this a humblebrag that you’re great at timing the precise moment to rip the turkey out of the oven? Because that’s easily 100F over what I’d consider sane for somebody to cook a whole bird, given that you’re aiming for interior temps under 200F.
- brudgers 5y agoNo the cookbook has a table (retyped for another comment). Bibliography: The Good Housekeeping Cookbook, copyright 1963, Hearst Corporation, LOC 16-15315, page 282.
- akerl_ 5y agoI’m kindof shocked by what you’re pitching here. The instructions for most turkeys would have you cook at either 325F or 350F for somewhere in the neighborhood of 10-15 minutes per pound. Despite what you put in a parallel comment, “low temps” aren’t what dry meats out. Jerky is dry because it’s cooked radically longer than you’d cook the equivalent meat for a dinner plate. It’s pretty obvious rationally that cooking a turkey at a higher heat for longer is going to overcook it. That’s especially humorous given your note about how the turkey packaging is optimized for food safety: if they’re confident that 325 at 15minute/lb is enough to be safe, why the heck are you aiming for hotter/longer?
- brudgers 5y agoThe instructions on the packaging tend to produce a dry result. Dry turkey is safe turkey in the same way that a dry well done hamburger is recommended for food safety. I think I understand the basic science of the approach. There are, practically speaking, three mechanisms for heat transfer. Radiation, conduction, and convection. Scientifically, to a first approximation, all heat transfer in the universe is via radiation. It is the only form of heat transfer that can occur across a vacuum. However, metal foils (or in this case a metalloid foil of aluminum) provide effective radiant barriers. Metal foil based radiant barriers are what made Eagle so shiny. The foil over the bird makes heat transfer inside the oven less efficient by eliminating most of the radiant heat transfer. However, where the foil touches the skin, it can serve as a conductor and crisp the skin relatively quickly. But that doesn't go bone deep. It is analogous to searing a steak, it helps keep the moisture in. So that means convection does all the heavy lifting. In the beginning it is only via hot air. But as the bird heats, some of the moisture turns to steam. The steam cools as it rises when it hits meat at lower temperatures. The foil somewhat contains the steam...so a lot of the moisture does not evaporate and the effective cooking temperature is much lower than 450F. In particular the convection cycle uses the thermal mass of the pan at the bottom. Juices flow down into it, evaporate and rise until cooled by uncooked meat above. Some of the uncooked meat liquifies and flows down along with the condensed steam. --- But anyway, while I haven't cooked a hundred turkeys this way, I have cooked several dozen due to a period where I was eating low carb and cooking a small turkey about once a week for meat. It's worked for me a few dozen times less the few times before I used the foil method. Last Thursday's bird is among the successes. I don't have an ideological dog in the method. The recipe produces great results with minimal additional effort (using foil, turning the oven dial a little further, and removing the foil). I use the method because it is idiot proof. Alas as HN shows, it is not genius proof. Then again nothing is.
- tclancy 5y agoI think you left out the part where the recipe says to start at 450 for 15 minutes or so (probably to kill any bacteria in case you weren’t all too careful in handling) and then turn down to 325/ 350.
- brudgers 5y agoNo. Instead there's foil involved. Cooking is an empirical endeavor. Lower temperatures tend to dry meats out, e.g. jerked meats (all things kept constant (a sous vide gives different results)).
- raldi 5y agoHow do you know when you've reached "the last 30 minutes"?