2 ms·
One problem with google is its ridiculous, and absurd word substitution. This started more than a decade ago, with things such as 'Bob" being aliased to "Rober
by b112 5y ago
One problem with google is its ridiculous, and absurd word substitution.
This started more than a decade ago, with things such as 'Bob" being aliased to "Robert". Back then, before the annoying Google Plus came onto the scene, the + could be used to insist that a word is never aliased, always present in search results.
This was deprecated due to conflicts with Google Plus searches for name+ or whatever, and half-assed replaced with 'use quotes they're the same', which of course they are NOT the same. Google just gives slightly higher precedence to quoted text, and will chose to ignore its existence and alias if required.
Thus, 'verbatim' search was created, under a hard to find menu item, doesn't work with things such as date matching, isn't available until after you search, and is only a partial replacement for the now missing + (which only did one word).
These days, google auto-aliases everything. Debian is aliased to ubuntu, and others. dhclient is aliased to dhcp (due to dhcpd/dhcpcd), and on and on, so searching for the precise thing is only even remotely possible with verbatim.
Of course, verbatim itself often breaks now, randomly still aliases things, and is just a PITA to use.
The reason behind all of this, is voice search, plain and simple.
How can you search for 'here' 'hear' via voice, without aliasing? Even searching for 'tanya' via voice, means people might want 'tania' 'tanyah' or whatever other close sounding word is the case.
So, google continues to destroy search results for those wanting precision, because google thinks the code should be the same.
One of the richest companies on the planet, can't manage a few extra coder cycles, pulled away from whatever advertising scheme they're working on, to slap in a few if statements for 'text' or 'voice' differentiation.
I used to love google. Used to.
- steerablesafe 5y agoQuoting still seems to work? As I remember + was always for emphasis/importance and quoting was for verbatim, but maybe I remember wrong. I get highlights for Robert here: https://www.google.com/search?q=bob+downey https://www.google.com/search?q=bob+downey No highlights for Robert here: https://www.google.com/search?q=%22bob%22+downey https://www.google.com/search?q=%22bob%22+downey Otherwise the found pages are similar here, but that's maybe because the search is very specific.
- alok-g 5y ago+1. I just wrote a similar thing here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29351147 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29351147 I hope this is not a sign that someone here will disrupt today's web search using, for a change, older technology. :-)