4 ms·
I don't know why people feel the need to whatabout this. The Uyghur genocide is a much more complex scenario due to the power of China ( and there have been boy
by sofixa 5y ago
I don't know why people feel the need to whatabout this. The Uyghur genocide is a much more complex scenario due to the power of China ( and there have been boycotts, including by countries, of stuff related to slave labour there). The same way that nobody can actually do anything when a great power such as the US or Russia commit atrocities, home or abroad. Where were the boycotts or sanctions over Guantanamo and the whole illegal kidnapping and torture programs, or heck, the illegal Iraq war? Heck, Russia has invaded another country and the response is weak, at best.
Face it, when a great power does bad things, very few can oppose them, internally or externally. Consequences will be limited. They know it, and that's why they keep doing it and getting away with it.
The UN can't do anything because it can only work if everyone is there, at the table, and of course the big bad guys and their allies won't want to sanction themselves. The UN is the best possible realistic version.
All that aside, the ongoing genocide in Tigray is a real problem that needs to be stopped. Whatabouting won't help the people there.
- timdaub 5y agoThis massive power abuse of nation states is also why I stopped identifying and a citizen of my country. It's not representative of what I stand or voted for. It's not the way I interpret my institution. If I had a say, we wouldn't do none of those things. But it seems as a mere individual I Am powerless in doing anything against these issues.
- redis_mlc 5y agoYou've been lied to by the MSM. Read my comment below.
- redis_mlc 5y ago> much more complex scenario due to the power of China There's a simple solution: the US can expel China from US capital markets. China does 91% of foreign trade using the US dollar. Done. > Guantanamo and the whole illegal kidnapping and torture programs, or heck, the illegal Iraq war Get your facts straight. Most of the detainees' countries didn't want the prisoners back. Four of the ones released are heads of the Taliban now. Iraq (world's 4th largest army, with chemical weapons) invaded Kuwait, and KSA was next. They paid the US to defend them. Since WW2, the US has reacted to world events. The US doesn't enter another country without a reason, comrade.
- mjburgess 5y agoCan we distinguish between the prerogative of a state to wage an offensive war against another state (eg., US vs Iraq) *from* a state engaged genocide of its own people? When a state attacks, on-mass, its own citizens it's essentially failed. Absent a functioning state, any outsider can do what they want here: invade, preferably. The "whataboutism" here isn't solved with yet more whataboutism. Every state today and in all of history has waged war, and holds itself to low standards on non-citizens. There is nothing exceptional in the US having Guantanamo; it is a world-wide exception not to have one! (And I agree, incidentally, that there shouldnt be one). A genocide isn't part-and-parcel of the nature of states; it is the opposite. An exceptional event which represents a profound failure of the state. It was the genocidal conditions of slavery which caused the US federal state to fail: civil war.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> When a state attacks, on-mass, its own citizens it's essentially failed. Absent a functioning state, any outsider can do what they want here: invade, preferably. A failed state isn't one that does thngs you don't like. China doesn't like that there are many, many countries where you can say bad things about China. It's one that can't control very large parts of its territory or get things done. Being evil and failing are separate concepts. The Qing killed the Dzhungars. They eradicated an entire ethnic group. That was a strong state, not a failed one. And of course outsiders can invade if they're willing to put up with the consequences. International law is and always has been a farce, from Grotius making up the law of the sea to protect Dutch weakness in Northern European waters when they were abusing all round them in the East Indies, to the victor's "justice" of the Nuremberg trials to the differing treatments of genocide depending on great power sponsorship. At its most farcical you have puppet regimes of the "international community" like the Somali or Afghan puppets. You can invade if you're willing to pay for it.
- asimpletune 5y agoWhat was wrong with Nuremberg?
- 5y ago
- rospaya 5y agoNot that I don't agree, but: > Iraq war Largest protests in history and (less noticable) a decline in US power, leadership, respect. In 50 years the Iraq war fuckup whill the thaught as the moment the American empire began to fall. > Russia Large scale sanctions in Europe, but IMHO weaker than they should be. Considering German interests and our collective addiction on Russian gas it's the best we can get I'm afraid.
- baybal2 5y ago> Face it, when a great power does bad things, very few can oppose them, internally or externally. Consequences will be limited. They know it, and that's why they keep doing it and getting away with it. We don't face it, and the discourse like this is part of the problem. Don't say this, don't "face" it. Proving the opposite of what you say.