4 ms·
> This doesn't look like anything that may compete > with Macbook Air in my book > design is reminiscent of old laptops from the year > 2001 1. The age
by pyre 15y ago
> This doesn't look like anything that may compete
> with Macbook Air in my book
> design is reminiscent of old laptops from the year
> 2001
1. The age of the design shouldn't necessarily say anything about how good it is. Would you claim that we should just get rid of art museums because everything in them is just 'too old?'
2. The ThinkPad was praised for it's industrial design back in it's day.
3. There are many people that prefer the ThinkPad design over the MBA unibody.
4. If the X220 surpasses the MBA in all aspected except looks, then does it really not compete in your book? Is the design of the laptop so important that you would be willing to pay more for less functionality just for your laptop to look nicer?
5. I don't quite understand how you can reply to someone saying that they went with a X220 due to features that it had that the MBA didn't (and which were important to the poster), with a "it's not even competitive because the design is not pleasing to my eyes." It comes off like this:
poster1: I bought a NASCAR because I need to go fast for
work.
poster2: How could you even claim that a NASCAR is a replacement
for a sedan?! The external looks are horrible!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- georgieporgie 15y agoThe original question posed was, "any good Macbook Air alternatives?" To me, that implies lightweight, compact, and, yes, elegant. The Thinkpad doesn't appear to be any of those.
- pyre 15y agoElegant is subjective. It's better to talk about things like specs, issues, OS support, etc, and let people decide on the aesthetics themselves. Arguing over which design is more pleasing on the eye (or elegant) adds nothing to the discussion. The original post suggesting the X220 listed a bunch of specs that it had (and that the poster needed) that the MacBook Air didn't. A response of, "Disregard that the design sucks cocks," adds nothing to the discussion even if that it your personal opinion. If someone thinks that the external looks of the laptop are important, they are not going to just blindly make the purchase based a comment on HN without personally checking it out. The more important discussions are things like: * X is billed as (or looks to be in the surface) a replacement for Y, but once you get it out of the showroom you'll notice issues A, B and C. * X looks really cheap on the surface, but in my experience it's extremely durable. * X looks really good, but doesn't run Operating System Y. * X looks like it runs Operating System Y, until you need to use feature/hardware component Z.
- georgieporgie 15y agoElegant is subjective. I think you would be hard pressed to find someone who honestly believes a Thinkpad to be more elegant than a Macbook Air. A response of, "Disregard that the design sucks cocks," Excuse me?
- blinkingled 15y agoHow much elegant is good enough or to what degree that is a concern is subjective. GP did not specify that elegance was the sole criteria which means he/she is probably ok with a fairly elegant machine within same ballpark of the Air - which the x220 is. The x220 certainly ain't ugly - it is thin, lightweight and durable. Many prefer the Thinkpad design. So even if for you personally elegance may be the first/only priority without override - many people are not that obsessive when it comes to choosing a work laptop. So the X220 is certainly a choice when you are thinking Macbook Air. The screen size falls nicely between the too small 11" and a bit too big 13.3", the CPUs are same gen, SSD is configurable etc.
- georgieporgie 15y agoSo even if for you personally elegance may be the first/only priority without override Okay, I'm genuinely curious here. What's with all the strange, reactionary posts in this thread, and mis-categorization of people? When did I say anything about elegance being my first priority? I was quite clear in my statement, yet you've skewed it in a bizarre manner. many people are not that obsessive when it comes to choosing a work laptop Obsessive? How about appreciative? In fact, how about any word which isn't loaded? Again, there is some strange, defensive stuff going on here.
- puredemo 15y agoIndeed. I've been reading a lot of responses thinking the same thing.
- blinkingled 15y agoWell nothing to be defensive about. I was responding to the question /why even bring up Think pad when it looks less elegant/. Only a somewhat obsessed person will completely ignore a laptop because it is not as good looking as the Air. Nothing wrong or loaded about that - just that it isn't what everyone will generally do. And so the response wasn't completely irrelevant, that's all.