3 ms·
What about saying that such conditions exists right now in contemporary world. We have great amount of thinkers and scientists and technologists and populists a
by watwut 5y ago
What about saying that such conditions exists right now in contemporary world. We have great amount of thinkers and scientists and technologists and populists and cult leaders.
All of them producing and moving world forward. It is crowded competition, actually.
- mistermann 5y agoI wonder if it would be possible for these people and others to produce in a more collaborative manner, perhaps with a shared roadmap, strategy, etc. To me, it seems at least plausible, what's your take?
- watwut 5y agoSocrates was not particularly collaborative. Lived through dictatorship+revolution led by his students and got killed after. The resentments were real. Quite a few people were tortured and killed in that story of betrayal, revolution, contrarevolution, amnesty and broken amnesty. Like seriously, it was way more violent and bloody then your average western society now. And we don't even go to regular wars against other cities and don't keep slaves. Neither of those two are collaboration. And now you can actually become citizen without being born from citizen father.
- mistermann 5y agoThis difference would be advantageous to us though wouldn't it?
- notahacker 5y agoYep, the cynic in me thinks that actually creating the conditions where a dozen people's speculation on stuff dominates discourse for a couple of millenia like the Greek philosophers is less about the quality of speculation, and more about ensuring that not much else of note is written down...
- mistermann 5y agoLots of stuff gets written down nowadays, but so much of it is crap, and most of everything kind of vanishes into the ether of old forum posts as time marches on.
- watwut 5y agoA lot more crap or even super high quality thinking vanished in that era. Socrates was even refusing to write at all. All we know is what Plato wrote for his own reasons.