10 ms·
B.1.1.529
- makeworld 5y agoA deleted Tweet from her has broken the thread. The full version can be viewed easily at https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1463885539619311616.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1463885539619311616.html
- chaoskanzlerin 5y agothe speed within which B.1.1.529 became dominant is really concerning
- _Microft 5y agoIf it is confirmed to spread like this chart makes it look like, this is very bad. https://nitter.net/jburnmurdoch/status/1463956686075580421 https://nitter.net/jburnmurdoch/status/1463956686075580421
- zx76 5y agoYes, I've also been really surprised by this. The fact that South African wastewater coronavirus detection is spiking dramatically [1] makes me wonder if this variant could be a genuine step up from the current status quo. [1] https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-11-25-the-covid-19-fourth-wave-is-looming-in-december-wastewater-surveillance-gives-us-all-the-signposts/ https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-11-25-the-covid...
- jsnell 5y agoIt's easy for a variant to become dominant just by random chance if the prevalence is low. That's the case here. Alpha and Delta were quite different, they took over when the case counts were high, so it was basically impossible for founder effects to be the reason. So in this case we need to rely much more on the circumstantial evidence (which admittedly seems pretty solid on a first skim).
- bertil 5y agoThis is still a handful of cases (10 total, the only comparison curb I've seen is on three cases in Botswana; there could be one on six other cases in South Africa). We’ll know more soon, and hopefully, local health authorities will contain anything worrisome, but this is not yet like Delta with thousands of cases emerging overnight in some countries.
- threeseed 5y agoNot really comparable to Delta. Given that so much of the world is vaccinated.
- bertil 5y agoIf you mean that Delta original advance wasn’t hindered by the vaccines, but Nu will be… it’s not clear that the vaccines will be very effective if it spreads. The spike protein looks quite different.
- _Microft 5y agoOn Nitter, no Twitter account required: https://nitter.net/chrischirp/status/1463885593461628928 https://nitter.net/chrischirp/status/1463885593461628928 (link to end of thread, so you can scroll up over the broken part of the thread) On Threadreader: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1463885539619311616.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1463885539619311616.html (full thread)
- black_puppydog 5y agoNitter ftw. I've noticed I barely every open threadreader now.
- boringg 5y agoOh man nitter is so much better - twitter is just full of ad/promoted content. Never knew about nitter.
- grawlinson 5y agoI'd love a browser extension that automatically redirects all twitter URLs to the nitter equivalent.
- rich_sasha 5y agoSo, basically, another Covid variant, but much badder than Delta? I’m a bit fed up with coronaviruses tbh.
- Yuioup 5y agoWe all are.
- geraldcombs 5y agoThe coronaviruses don't appear to be fed up with us, unfortunately.
- throwamon 5y agoHonestly I'm more fed up with people who can't seem to be able to sit quietly in their homes for two weeks.
- orra 5y ago“Two weeks” is quite the litotes. COVID-19 has been around /two years/.
- throwamon 5y agoExactly! Imagine how many diseases we would have eradicated if we all just stayed at home for that long! Not just diseases, by the way - as Pascal would have said, "All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone."
- jansan 5y agoI recently found this video that shows and comments the worldwide evolement of variants over time. It is astonishing just how dominant Delta has become. To me this was more entertaining than a marble race. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ig_FjVVHS00 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ig_FjVVHS00
- guilhas 5y agoWhat does this means? Now we need booster 4? Or don't need booster 3? Or nothing matters anymore?...
- gmuslera 5y agoBoosters of the same vaccine will make the effect of a vaccine to last longer, if its protection diminishes with time. Other variants are present too, so regardless if this particular variant spreads to your zone or not, it probably won't harm. The problem if is this variant is different enough to the original variant for the vaccine to be effective against it or no.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 5y agoFrom the Prof.: “We do know that B.1.529 has many more mutations than other variants and has mutations seen in other variants that are associated with BOTH higher transmissibility AND immune escape.”
- bawolff 5y agoIts a developing situation. What exactly it means isn't clear yet. Booster 3 is almost certainly still helpful but how helpful against this strain requires more science. Booster 4 (at least in the near term) would continue to probably do nothing further because its not a simple matter of more boosters at the same time equal more protection. That's just not how it works. People seem to want to treat covid as if its a school assignment; as if there is a teacher giving you harder and harder homework in an arbitrary fashion who knows what is going to happen and you can ask them. Its not - this is the real world. Answers come when people test out theories and discover what's what. Its a process, and it takes time. What the article is saying basically is that there is a lot of uncertainty but what we do know so far is concerning.
- bertil 5y agoSo far, not much: it appears that there are very few cases confirmed (10 so far). If all those people isolate and don’t contaminate anyone, that could be the end of it. But one of them just flew on an intercontinental flight, so… yeah, things might not be contained. If even one of them transmit to someone else, who transmit is themselves… this could spread like the Delta variant. There has not been any clinical test on the effectiveness of vaccines, of course; however, with so many mutations, in particular the mutations on the parts that code the spike protein, the vaccines that have proven effective so far (which focus on that spike) are likely to be far less effective. It’s likely we would develop new vaccines, but that presents more risk, so would need more tests, etc. Lockdowns are likely in the meantime.
- usedtoprog 5y ago[flagged]
- usedtoprog 5y agoTime to get on with enjoying your life because this never ends.
- Y_Y 5y agoPlease fix the title and mention that this refers to a new COVID variant
- _Microft 5y agoNames looking similar to the one of this variant have been mentioned on the news already, so it might not be completely surprising for some people that this is about SARS-Cov2. The nomenclature is called PANGO by the way. It is named after the software tool "Phylogenetic Assignment of Named Global Outbreak Lineages" (PANGOLIN) which is used to classify lineages of SARS-Cov2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phylogenetic_Assignment_of_Named_Global_Outbreak_Lineages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phylogenetic_Assignment_of_Nam... https://cov-lineages.org/ https://cov-lineages.org/
- quesera 5y agoOn first read, I thought someone had revived the B programming language (predecessor to C), and started their pre-2.0 versioning at 1.1. FWIW.
- thenewnormal 5y agoI particularly liked how the mutations were described as "horrific". How are they? Do they have terrible claws and sharp pointy teeth?
- _Microft 5y agoAs many as a horrific car crash has.
- thenewnormal 5y agoA car crash has lots of nasty pointy bits.
- haunter 5y agoSo probably new shots every 4-5 months and the end game will be a yearly shot like with the seasonal influenza? Got my 3rd shot a month ago but I can see we will get a new one in the spring. Rinse and repeat
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 5y agoSomething along those lines is what the very early medical projections were, yes, as I recall.
- bingohbangoh 5y agohell of a yearly shot
- threeseed 5y agoNot really. As far as vaccines go they look to be very safe and effective.
- bawolff 5y agoThere's really no evidence to come to that conclusion at this time.
- DeusExMachina 5y agoIsrael is already at the fourth shot. Not evidence, but definitely grants the suspicion.
- belltaco 5y agoSource?
- angelzen 5y agoNov 24, 2021 "Health minister suggests fourth vaccine dose amid rising fears of fifth COVID wave" https://www.timesofisrael.com/health-minister-suggests-fourth-vaccine-dose-amid-rising-fears-of-fifth-covid-wave/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/health-minister-suggests-fourt...
- bajdn 5y agoTake your retarded fascist fear mongering branch covidian propaganda the fuck out of here. Fucking fascists.
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoWe need to just get on with it. We can't just keep locking down and banning travel. For the majority of us the virus poses no danger.
- aaomidi 5y agoSource of this claim with the new variant?
- cedws 5y agoThis number of mutations isn't enough to completely change the mechanics of the virus. It's still the same thing in different clothing which might be enough to pass through the vaccine firewall, but the lethality won't be much different. I don't have to be a biologist to apply basic logic.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This number of mutations isn't enough to completely change the mechanics of the virus. One mutation can be enough, if its the right mutation. > I don't have to be a biologist to apply basic logic. Basic logic only helps if you start with accurate premises, which having an understanding of the relevant biology helps a lot with. Otherwise, you end up with GIGO.
- eudoxus 5y agowell at least you're not making sweeping generalizations with no references/citations/sources on a field of research you admittedly aren't a part of...
- meepmorp 5y ago> I don't have to be a biologist to apply basic logic. Biology doesn't really work like that. The number of rules is vastly smaller than the number of exceptions to them.
- kashunstva 5y ago> This number of mutations isn't enough to completely change the mechanics of the virus. Maybe. Maybe not. The majority of the mutations in the B.1.1.529 genome are expressed as changes in the spike proteins but others are not and remain to be better understood. It is too early to tell what effects those remaining mutations will have on the lethality of this variant. If those mutations result in more efficient intracellular replication or other changes in intracellular viral life-cycle efficiency, then the morbidity and mortality may be greater, independent of immunologic escape.
- bajdn 5y agoAll covidians should be shot dead. Fuck these terrorist pieces of shit.
- bajdn 5y agoYour God fauci tortures puppies and throws acid on monkey brains. Oh, he also directly funded the creation of covid cause he's a bioterrorist piece of shit. You all are such nice people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dvt 5y agoI'm fully bracing for downvotes, but I really think that having professional immunologists/scientists/etc. interacting directly with Twitter masses off of fresh-off-the-presses data (weak data, at that) is a mistake. For a few reasons: (a) it creates an environment where everyone wants to "break the news" first, even if it's full of hot takes, incorrect, or incendiary. This isn't a big deal when breaking who the Kardashians are dating, but it's very dangerous when talking about public health policy. And (b), there's zero accountability. If this entire thread ends up being wrong -- as so many of these Twitter hot takes have been proven to be wrong from last year -- no one cares. It's memory holed, and the good professor is just happy for the 15-minute limelight today, without worrying about what happens tomorrow. I know this is not a particularly popular opinion, but I think we have things like peer review, the three sigma rule of thumb, and so on, for good reason. It's disappointing to see scientists spew out an entire thread and then cap it off with "just my opinion, so who knows" -- just as dishonest as crypto pumpers and their "not financial advice" disclaimers. Give me a break. I'm happy you got your Twitter engagement though, that's what it's all about.
- KKKKkkkk1 5y agoEverything you just wrote applies equally well to traditional mass media.
- bertil 5y ago> there's zero accountability. If this entire thread ends up being wrong -- as so many of these Twitter hot takes have been proven to be wrong from last year -- no one cares. It is true in many cases, but I feel like anyone who has contributed _as an expert in epidemiology_ has a good track record on correcting their statements. Did I miss anything worrisome?
- dvt 5y ago> feel like anyone who has contributed _as an expert in epidemiology_ has a good track record on correcting their statements I think this feeling would be misguided: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7447267/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7447267/ -- retractions have been basically non-existent. On the scientist or the journalist side.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoWhere there is a partially vaccinated population, yet still widespread infection, then there will be strong selection pressure for vaccine immune escape (and indeed prior infection immune escape). It may not be this variant, but if such an escape variant emerged, it would quickly spread - assuming the mutations don't interfere too much with viability and transmission. Vaccines, with other measures as necessary, should be used to suppress a highly contagious virus to nearly zero (trigger warning!!) to prevent this from happening.
- charcircuit 5y agoWhy can't they come up with a better name like security vulnerabilities have nowadays?
- mercy_dude 5y agoI travelled in UK and it seems you do have to do an antigen tests when you get in as a traveller. Is antigen test able to detect this variant?
- _Wintermute 5y agoIt can detect it as a positive result, it can't distinguish between variants.
- thenewnormal 5y agoWhat feature of the virus does the anitgen test detect? If this one has so many mutations, it's not a ridiculous question.
- Aachen 5y agoI don't know the answer, but related: I read the manual that came with the new self tests and it mentioned what else it reacted to, like some micrograms of influenza type such and such. There was a whole host of things it responded to. They seem to just detect extremely broadly. Previous self tests didn't include this, I found it quite interesting.
- jl6 5y agoIs there any reason to believe that higher infectivity should correlate with lower lethality? i.e. the virus which keeps its host alive the longest has greatest opportunity to replicate and spread?
- giarc 5y agoYes, there's kind of a triad of attributes that affects a virus and it's ability to cause a pandemic. Virulence (how sick people become), transmissibility (how easy does it spread), lethality (can it kill at high rate). -higher virulence causes people to stay at home more, and less spread in community -higher transmissibility means more spread person to person -high lethality means people die faster and not spread as fast SARS and MERS before SARS-COV2(COVID) all had high lethality and therefore those that were infected didn't get a chance to transmit to others that well, and likely helped slow the spread. COVID seems to have a good balance between the three. The above is a big simplification, but the general idea sticks.
- zarzavat 5y agoYour model is missing one big variable and that is latency, the time difference between when people are most contagious and when they are symptomatic. SARS-1 had low latency, and so people tended to become contagious and symptomatic at around the same time, reducing transmission. Whereas SARS-2 has a high latency which helps it to spread while people are unaware they even have it. This also insulates SARS-2 from selective pressure to reduce its virulence.
- quotemstr 5y agoKeep in mind that imperfect vaccination shifts this triad in the direction of higher sustainable lethality: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marek's_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marek's_disease In both the natural and leaky-vaccine scenarios, the virus evolves towards an ecological equilibrium, but in the leaky-vaccine scenario, that equilibrium is shifted in the direction of greater lethality. See the linked article: as a direct consequence of mass vaccination of chickens, Marek's diseased evolved from a minor illness into a highly-virulent, highly-transmissible disease that causes 100% lethal cancer in chickens unless the chicks are vaccinated before they hatch from their eggs.
- djantje 5y agoThe pull request https://github.com/cov-lineages/pango-designation/issues/343 https://github.com/cov-lineages/pango-designation/issues/343
- toyg 5y agoSucks to be the South African government: too poor to vaccinate efficiently, shares data with rest of the world in "excellent" meetings, gets immediately quarantined via airline bans. And then we wonder why countries tend to be secretive... Note I'm not saying we shouldn't trigger transfer bans (we should), but there should be a compensation mechanism that goes with them - like money or free vaccines. Otherwise poor countries have no incentive to cooperate.
- makomk 5y agoSouth Africa's big problem with vaccination right now seems to be that they're running out of willing people to vaccinate - they just postponed a bunch of vaccine deliveries because their current stockpile is big enough already, and apparently a lot of people there are reluctant to get the vaccine.
- EvanKnowles 5y agoThis is entirely it - we have plenty of vaccines, there's no queue at vaccination centres, people just aren't getting vaccinated.
- fsflover 5y agoAnother discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29345194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29345194.
- jfoster 5y agoSomething that's frustrating about this type of situation which is probably going to arise many more times over the next few years; time is of the essence in this type of situation, and whilst detailed research into the nature of the mutations in this variant takes time, but basic data that doesn't take much time to gather is still not being shared. When hearing about a bunch of cases discovered to have this new variant, it would help to assess the situation if we knew data related to each case: vaccination status, age, viral load, severity, etc. All those details must have been collected already, and would indicate exactly how much of a concern the new variant is or isn't.
- lifeplusplus 5y agoIs it more lethal and transmissible? I couldn't find any info on that? If yes to both, than RIP.
- Aachen 5y agoMight be a blessing in disguise. People will become afraid well before it reaches their country. Maybe we actually have the willpower to stop it if it's actually quite lethal, and then it's indeed RIP (COVID). Since we apparently can't manage to announce a few months ahead a global 2 week lockdown, just stock up and afterwards nobody is infectious anymore. For the few essential people that need to be out (doctors, caretakers, police), switch on the last day and they now isolate for two weeks. Probably best to also add self-tests to the mix towards the end of the two weeks. Instead, so far, we'd rather have intermittent half-assed lockdowns for years on end and millions of deaths. Idk, a proper lethal variant (with the infectiousness before symptoms like it is now, else it wouldn't spread) might motivate us to solve the problem rather than to keep failing to try.
- thinkingemote 5y agoIt's functionally impossible to have a global lockdown. Absolutely impossible for every country in the world at the same time. Just think outside your continent for 3 minutes. Developing worlds, populations with millions living in poverty. Billions of people without the money to buy things two weeks in advance. Millions of food producers without the facility to produce and store 2 weeks worth of things for people. Now consider enforcement, healthcare, transportation, logistics, communication, borders, active wars and civil wars going on right now, etc. Let alone the normal international political cooperation needed. It's actually totally impossible for it to happen simultaneously at a global level. I'd say it's probably also impossible for the majority of countries in the world (i.e. not rich) to have an effective lockdown at all at any time.
- eneveu 5y agoEven with a global lockdown, there will always be a reservoir of virus somewhere. Some immunocompromised people can carry the virus for weeks. Also, what about households where one person catches COVID the day before lockdown, incubates for a few days (asymptomatically), then transmits it to another person in the household, who also incubates for a few days... At the end of the two week lockdowns, some people will still be contagious.
- randomopining 5y agoDefinitely just need a combination of fast alterable vaccines, good public health (vit d, lower weight), and reasonable masking around vulnerable people.