6 ms·
> This is a big 'problem' in the west too, where venture funded 'startups' can often out compete small scale traditional rivals in price temporarily by providin
by roenxi 5y ago
> This is a big 'problem' in the west too, where venture funded 'startups' can often out compete small scale traditional rivals in price temporarily by providing goods to the market at much less than cost, burning investor money until the rival way of doing things is broken, then jack the prices back up and reap the profits as a local monopoly.
I come from a position of extreme scepticism that this strategy can work. In theory I can imagine it, but in practice I haven't seen a follow up like "...as was sen in the case of [practical example".
The companies that try this without network effects seem to get crushed - I like to point at Uber. Their loss-making competition seems to be translating into ongoing losses rather than monopoly.
Companies with network effects - and I'm thinking FANG companies - generally moved in and took out well established players by being substantially better with innovative new business models. In most cases they were profitable most of the way through their journey.
- Retric 5y agoAmazon is a solid example of burning everyone else out of the market with VC funding. Don’t be fooled by their nominal profits, for retail their making money hand over fist and simply use tax avoidance strategies to turn profits into capital.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThey burned everyone out of the market with venture capital funding they got between Jul 1994 and May 1997, at which point they went public? The $8M from Kleiner Perkins in 1995 seems like a small amount to have been possible to burn everyone out of the market: https://www.fundable.com/learn/startup-stories/amazon https://www.fundable.com/learn/startup-stories/amazon Are Target and Walmart and Home Depot and all other retail stores also hiding profits and choosing to report only 2% to 4% profit margins to avoid paying taxes for the past few decades? Could it not be that the retail business has optimized down to low single digit profit margins? Seems like a baseless conspiracy theory.
- shubb 5y agoWhen a company issues shares to the market, investors who buy those shares are investing in the company, and the company can take that investor money and spend it on equipment, wages, or I guess subsidising goods to undercut the competition. Many companies buy back shares, returning money to investors and increasing the price of their current shares. There are arguments about whether this is a good thing, but the fact remains that Walmart and Microsoft (comparable companies) have bought half and 1/3rd of their shares - returning large amounts of money to investors. This is in contrast to Amazon. Amazon have constantly issued new shares. This isn't a company that took some initial VC money and turned it into profits. As a company that has not been making a profit and has constantly been issuing new shares, Amazon has factually been running on investor cash for 20 years. I'm not saying the investors don't get a good deal. Investors know they are paying for Amazon to build market share by undercutting. I'm just saying what happened. Here is the graph: Amazon borrowing from the market to subsidise its loss making business in order to build marketshare: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AMZN/amazon/shares-outstanding https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AMZN/amazon/shares... Walmart not borrowing from the market and making a profit, which it returns to investors as a share buy back rather than a dividend: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/wmt/walmart/shares-outstanding https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/wmt/walmart/shares... Also do note that the number of shares issued by amazon per year has remained fairly constant but the value of those shares has increased, so the amount Amazon 'borrows' has increased each year. You raise the question, long term, will it work? It is too early to say right? Amazon dominate cloud and are making a profit now in that area, but other companies have been able to cut in on 'their' market. What will happen to elsewhere if amazon stop subsidising and a new investor subsidised company comes for their cheese? Amazon shares are very high on the the expectation that market share has been permanently bought. How deep is the moat?
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> This isn't a company that took some initial VC money and turned it into profits. If you do not think the $8M VC funding AMZN took in 1995 turned into profit, you are using a different definition of profit than most people. > As a company that has not been making a profit and has constantly been issuing new shares, Amazon has factually been running on investor cash for 20 years. Your macro trends link shows profit margins of 4% prior to 2010, and 4% after 2018. Walmart shows 3% or less on many years. I do not even know what we are talking about anymore, but the numbers show that Amazon is investing into its business. I do not see proof they are undercutting competitors (Walmart/Target/etc). In fact, Amazon’s retail prices have been consistently higher than their competitors, precisely because retail is a low margin game with little upside. The big money is in digital goods, which can scale easily with extremely high profit margins, such as AWS and Amazon Prime Video/Music. I would bet Amazon’s retail play is now just a way to get the retail public to sign up for the recurring monthly revenue from video services, and to take the 15% profits off the top from reseller’s sales for being a platform. Amazon ideally does not want to be an actual retailer, that is a 3% profit margin business, as Walmart’s data shows. They want to be a platform, that is a 15%+ profit margin business. And it is reflected on their website by them not allowing you to restrict searches for items shipped and sold by Amazon, and not competing on price (in my experience). Why would they want that inventory risk and stuff that comes with selling physical goods.
- karatinversion 5y agoThis is such a strange comment to me. Amazon is not even the largest retailer in the US (that’s Walmart). It’s the largest e-commerce retailer, but at 40% share there are plenty of other businesses here. Amazon IPOd in 1997, three years after being founded, when it still only sold books - I’m not aware of any VCs that are in the habit of buying shares in public companies. And finally, it’s really weird to call investment by a business, something that the tax code and public policy explicitly encourages, a “tax avoidance strategy to turn profits into capital”.
- Retric 5y agoOwning all online retail was hardly their initial business. What’s their share of online book sales over time? They of course continued to sell stock to fund further investments in other business, but they also funneled “operating expenses” into long term capital. AWS is a one such example, which hides actual profit margins via investments in software. The IRS has a clear line in the sand when buying land, but R&D gets tricky.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoAside from the fact that you're arguing that "company wipes out competition, raises prices" is some sort of fantasy and not standard business practice: How is Uber not a practical example? VC-backed startup, out-competed traditional rivals using VC cash to undercut them, jacked prices and dropped quality once they had established dominance. Uber and Lyft decimated the taxi industry. Taxi drivers lost but so did the public; we ended up with wildly variable rates, extremely discriminatory service (virtually zero handicapped accommodations), uninspected vehicles, background checks that were a joke, no licensing, no government agency responsible for keeping an eye on them, and no accurate metering (any cyclist with a bike computer will tell you that GPS and wheel-measured distance almost never line up.) In my city, you could call up the police department's livery unit and they would investigate reports of illegal driving, unsafe vehicles, lost property, etc. Companies like FAANG don't move in to a new tech space and succeed because of "substantially better / innovative new business models." They usually have an inferior ripoff but it dominates because they can leverage their existing infrastructure, brand recognition, PR relationships, and giant piles of cash to pump into it until it succeeds. This Indian entrepreneur is bleeding cash undercutting these local salesmen, and if it takes long enough, someone like Amazon will come in and do the same thing to him. But if he pulls it off, he's going to drop the one-day delivery and 15% price discount like a bad habit, guaranteed.
- rsj_hn 5y agoThat is some weird alt-history. In San Francisco, before Uber, this was the situation of the taxi industry: - It was routinely a 2-3 hour wait to get a cab on Friday or Saturday night - Rampant discrimination by cabbies who would always ask you where you are going and would refuse to take you if they didn't like the answer. They would frequently refuse to pick up black passengers (pretending they didn't see you on the street). Very few cabs had disability support. - Cabs were old, in poor condition, sometimes dirty. Sometimes they were also new and nice, but there was no quality control. - Significant problems with cabbies yelling at passengers, not bathing, smoking in their cabs, and generally being surly. - Cabbies were under-insured and also poor background checks. - Side payments to the dispatcher and other bribes were common to get the high paying airport jobs - cab rides cost about 40% more than now - The city made hundreds of thousands per medallion as they auctioned off the right to be a cab and artificially restricted supply. - There was no opportunity for part time cabbies -- you needed to pick a shift and then drive that shift. You could not set your own hours. This created a situation where there weren't enough cars on weekends because the number of medallions were fixed. - Cab companies earned insane profit margins - 50% margins was not unusual for Yellow. Basically all of the above issues were substantially improved by Uber and Lyft. You can get a ride anytime with 10 minutes of waiting or less, and you (usually) pay less. Lyft is a bit in between Uber and regular taxis in that it is usually more expensive but does not have the same surge spikes, trading off wait time for prices. The system of rating cabbies gets rid of those who smoke in the cab or don't shower, or don't keep the car clean. Just a massive increase in driver professionalism and politeness. Uber and Lyft were one of the few ways that blacks and minorities could regularly get rides as the platform did not allow discrimination. The platform also checked the routes to limit the number of riders being ripped off. Uber also has dedicated disability rides that you can select from. And for the drivers, you can now work any hours that you want, you do not need to pay a gate and so risk is reduced. Just an overwhelmingly positive improvement that significantly increased quality of life for san francisco riders and opened up new income earning opportunities to those who were locked out of the medallion system.