3 ms·
Investing in the wrong fusion approach will almost certainly just burn money instead of hydrogen. ITER is a shining example of how to do this maximally wrong.
by jiggawatts 5y ago
Investing in the wrong fusion approach will almost certainly just burn money instead of hydrogen.
ITER is a shining example of how to do this maximally wrong. It is a path only to ongoing expenditure, not useful energy.
There are some smaller startups doing interesting things such as using superconducting coils with much higher field strengths. They might be able to leapfrog ITER. If any of them can demonstrate net positive energy, then and only then the human race should throw tens of billions at that.
- wahern 5y ago> ITER is a shining example of how to do this maximally wrong. ITER is an example of what happens when you dither and drag things out for decades. If member states had made a major commitment to not only fund ITER, but to have it built within 5-10 years and actually done so, it would have been money well spent. If you wait long enough all designs for anything will become outdated. An operational ITER would have provided, and still can provide, crucial experience and data. But the cost-benefit ratio is now much poorer for the delays. This is the lesson of SpaceX--not a lesson about financial frugality or simplicity of engineering. SpaceX has spent far more money than will be spent on ITER, and its designs are not known for their elegance. The world is awash in both cash and talent. The lesson is about process and pace and iteration--all that cash and talent is wasted if you don't apply it. Optimize for time. Emphasize process over product, as the former makes for the latter, not the other way around. When you have confidence something is worthwhile, as with ITER at the outset, don't hold back.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI just don't think ITER is really that expensive compared to other stuff like defense, oil subsidies, returning to the moon and so on.
- tsimionescu 5y agoYou can't really compare ITER and SpaceX. SpaceX has worked on a breakthrough in engineering, one that had seen research in decades past as well (the DC-X rocket achieved vertical landing from a few kilometers in the 1990s before the project was shut down; they would have almost certainly reached orbit if they were allowed to continue a few more years). On the other hand, ITER is breaking entirely new ground on the engineering side, and it even requires fundamental research. It is not even known if what ITER is setting out to do is fundamentally possible given realistic engineering constraints instead of idealized models.
- inglor_cz 5y agoTo be fair to SpaceX, all (two) full flow staged combustion cycle engines prior to Raptor were test articles that literally never left the ground. The Raptor family is a major, major innovation.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoExactly. ITER is more like rocketry was in the 50s. You know it should be doable but there are a ton of details to figure out first. SpaceX could build on decades of experience built by others.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoDon't forget that ITER is a big research project that tries to answer a lot of questions and put things together into a working prototype. That's not as shiny as doing interesting things in selected areas but somebody has to start building a whole machine. I think by design it will be outdated by the time it's done but that's a good thing. Somebody has to go first and pave the way for the next generation. Considering the potential payoff of fusion I believe this money is spent way better than than on things like returning to the moon or a lot of defense projects.
- pfdietz 5y agoITER is what happens when you focus on a shorter term goal and not a longer term goal. ITER's goal is fine, except that there's no way to extend what ITER is doing to a power plant that could be economically competitive (not even competitive with fission, never mind renewables). A fusion reactor that could be competitive must take a different approach, like one involving advanced fuels. This would make ITER's goal much harder (and would likely rule out tokamaks entirely), but the long term goal easier.
- runnerup 5y agoInvesting in the wrong ~~fusion approach~~ "tech startup" will almost certainly just burn money. The point GP is making isn't that fusion is a guaranteed win -- GP gave examples of other failures. It's probably their belief that there's more money in fusion than Magic Leap.
- rndphs 5y ago> then and only then the human race should throw tens of billions at that. Yeah we should hold out before spending tens of billions on fusion research... Meanwhile, 1.5 trillion gets spent on a failed fighter jet program... The amount of money spent on other projects is so, so much greater than that spent on fusion.
- piva00 5y ago> There are some smaller startups doing interesting things such as using superconducting coils with much higher field strengths. They might be able to leapfrog ITER. If any of them can demonstrate net positive energy, then and only then the human race should throw tens of billions at that. Show me examples of startups and private ventures that did completely fundamental research required for their engineering efforts on a product. At least one that wasn't mostly based on technology and research created by the public sector. I really don't understand how neoliberalism got so powerful as an ideology to force people to think that smaller startups are really better at fundamental, unprofitable research than tax-subsidised government research programs. There is no place in the neoliberal "free market" ideology for private companies (even less smaller startups) to pour money into expensive research for 10-20 years with the unknown if it's even feasible and possible, much less profitable.