3 ms·
Its hard to beat Amazon at its own game. But people are wising up to the fact that reviews are largely illegimate and largely gamed these days. So how are we to
by dragontamer 5y ago
Its hard to beat Amazon at its own game. But people are wising up to the fact that reviews are largely illegimate and largely gamed these days. So how are we to get trustworthy reviews?
Wirecutter is under the model that a larger newspaper would be a good source of reviews. Consumer Reports is also basically a newspaper / 3rd party review site. While noble in concept, I'm not 100% sure how economical this model is (Consumer Reports is a non-profit for example).
Wirecutter's ultimate revenue comes from affiliate links, meaning they're ultimately subservient to Amazon.
-----
But I shop at jetpens.com for my stationary. Why? Because their blog has happened to win their trust with me.
I can accept the economic situation: jetpens.com needs to distinguish itself from other online stores (Amazon, Walmart, etc. etc.). Blogging about their products and offering in-depth reviews of paper and pen products is pretty much the "Wirecutter" model.
That's probably the path forward in the future. Create a shop (online or in-person). Capture an audience using modern information (blogging, social networks, etc. etc.). And finally, its the __shop's reputation__ that is put at stake whenever reviews are put out. None of this "Amazon 3rd party review, we're not responsible for the words on our site" bull**, you know, a shop that stands behind the words and reviews that are next to the products on their website.
- MivLives 5y agoThere's a trend in modern SEO to essentially manufacturer things like jetpen's blogs. Amazon is actually already doing this by giving "Editorial recommendations". Other sites have ideas pages. I'd wonder if Amazon is paying Wirecutter for those to appear on the site. Google gives higher priority to information that could be helpful, so now you'll see things like that or larger explanations of what the category is as text on the page. Wirecutter could literally just be thought of an SEO expense. The aggressive thing Amazon does for SEO is that affiliate program. It's robust and it makes it harder for smaller stores to compete unless they're super specialized. I work for a very large online retailer that doesn't have one, and despite being a more niche retailer we're still being killed by Amazon in the categories we specialize in.