2 ms·
"Paper wealth" is an odd term that's not used in the study. It seems particulary odd to call real estate investments "paper wealth." After all, land and buildin
by skybrian 5y ago
"Paper wealth" is an odd term that's not used in the study. It seems particulary odd to call real estate investments "paper wealth." After all, land and buildings are pretty darn real, hence the name.
These investments may be overvalued and if prices change, owners will find they're not as wealthy as they thought, but they'll own the same thing.
Also, what does it mean to say that wealth is "tied up" in real estate? Prices going up doesn't change anything real. The effect might be more resources going into construction and renovation, though.
Debt and financial derivatives backed by inflated asset prices might be the problem, as in 2008. Those income streams might be less solid than they look.
- analyte123 5y agoIf you have to spend 5x your net worth on a house, that’s capital that is not spent on building businesses, whether through direct investment (buying tools or paying workers at your own business) or indirect (through stocks or other securities).
- skybrian 5y agoYour debt is someone else's income. They could spend it on any of these things, assuming you keep paying. (All you get is a house, though.)
- 01100011 5y agoDevil's advocate: Doesn't that mean the person who sold you the house now has the money to invest? It seems to me that wealth isn't being lost. It's being transferred to those wealthy, smart, or lucky enough to have invested in real estate.
- jackcosgrove 5y agoI think in most cases it's being transferred to someone older than you. Real estate is a seniority system.
- skybrian 5y agoWell yes, in a sense it has to be that way, because people aren’t born owning anything but eventually younger people will end up with everything when older people die. However, sometimes the transfer is via inheritance and sometimes it’s by selling property. I wonder to what extent retirement could be considered to be funded by real estate sales? It’s certainly something people do: sell the house and move somewhere cheaper.