3 ms·
People love to say this, and while I agree with the general gist, there are a couple problems with this statement: 1. For large swaths of the population, hardw
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
People love to say this, and while I agree with the general gist, there are a couple problems with this statement:
1. For large swaths of the population, hardware key-based 2FA or TOTP-based 2FA are too difficult to use, and they can also be more difficult to remediate if the user loses the hardware key or TOTP secret.
2. SMS 2FA is much better than nothing for most people. The bigger problem is when SMS can be used as just a single factor in account recovery scenarios.
3. There is a push to make telecoms more responsible for sim-swapping fraud: https://krebsonsecurity.com/2021/10/fcc-proposal-targets-sim-swapping-port-out-fraud https://krebsonsecurity.com/2021/10/fcc-proposal-targets-sim...
- mbesto 5y ago> 1. For large swaths of the population, hardware key-based 2FA or TOTP-based 2FA are too difficult to use, and they can also be more difficult to remediate if the user loses the hardware key or TOTP secret. This doesn't mean software providers should not offer the ability to use TOTP instead of SMS. This irritates me to no end when applications force me to establish MFA using SMS before I can also establish TOTP.
- walrus01 5y agoAnd sometimes no way to remove the sms ability to reset an account credentials for login even after totp is set up.
- sieabahlpark 5y agoIt's generally an anti-spam measure
- woah 5y agoThese same people who can’t handle pasting a 6 letter code from an app are also driving multi-ton vehicles on the freeway, one muscle twitch away from massive casualties. Scary. You don’t think that maybe they can learn?
- codetrotter 5y agoI use Google Authenticator TOTP/HOTP. But when I first started using it, and was switching to a new phone, I learned the hard way that the keys had not been included in my backups. Sorting that out was a royal pain in the butt. Since then I have started ensuring that I have the keys backed up properly. But it’s one of those things that you might not realize until it happens. And it’s why even though I like to use it, I’d still be unlikely to recommend even to my family that they use proper 2FA instead of SMS based ones. Lest they end up permanently locked out of their accounts.
- petepete 5y agoI switched to BitWarden for my ToTP needs and wouldn't go back. Having everything to hand, both on my phone and in my browser, saves so much time. I keep BitWarden safe with a YubiKey.