4 ms·
This will be an unpopular opinion but I feel someone taking a photo with me as the subject without my permission is almost on par with assault It feels like a
by bluefirebrand 5y ago
This will be an unpopular opinion but I feel someone taking a photo with me as the subject without my permission is almost on par with assault
It feels like a huge invasion of my personal space, regardless of whether or not the photographer is in my face or not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lovelyviking 5y ago>taking a photo with me as the subject without my permission is almost on par with assault Why would you wish to give 'permission' to art expression of someone else? Isn't that an assault to the freedom of other person? >It feels like a huge invasion of my personal space It feels this way until there is understanding that public space means that you are part of that public and public can be photographed by anyone interested to preserve the moment. Some people feel uncomfortable and find it hard to respect basic freedom of other person for art expression. It is a small price to pay though considering the alternative of living in society where disrespect to the freedom of art expression is a norm. Such society is doomed to be oppressive and living in oppression could be much more uncomfortable. Look at this attitude: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29332188 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29332188
- bluefirebrand 5y ago> It feels this way until there is understanding that public space means that you are part of that public and public can be photographed by anyone interested to preserve the moment I understand this and also disagree with it. It may be the way things are but that doesn't mean I have to like it. > Some people feel uncomfortable and find it hard to respect basic freedom of other person for art expression You are asking me to care more about people's artistic freedom than my own peace of mind. That is never going to happen. > Such society is doomed to be oppressive and living in oppression could be much more uncomfortable I don't see how asking for a good faith effort to ask permission to take or publish photos of an individual is trampling the ability of artists to express themselves. When people photograph you, they can then do anything they want with that photo. They can delete it, or store it indefinitely, or post it online, turn it into a meme, whatever. Forgive me if I don't think someone else should have that kind of control over something that could affect me deeply.
- lovelyviking 5y ago>Forgive me if I don't think someone else should have that kind of control over something that could affect me deeply. No, I am not going to forgive you for that. Not you nor any one else with such views. It sounds like you are ready to deny to other people their basic freedoms just because it "could affect you deeply". This way any oppression really work. To avoid repeating myself I'll direct you to my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29335887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29335887 >I understand this and also disagree with it. It may be the way things are but that doesn't mean I have to like it. Of course it doesn't mean you have to like it. You may not like it as long as you do not convert it to aggressive actions that I have observed many times in the streets. >You are asking me to care more about people's artistic freedom than my own peace of mind. That is never going to happen. I am not asking you anything it is your responsibility to care about things that could lead to loosing freedom in society. I am claiming it is a right of an artist to have freedom of thoughts and art expression and if you really mean what you say it seems like you are ready step over it. From my perspective you are crossing the line there with severe consequences. >I don't see how asking for a good faith effort to ask permission to take or publish photos of an individual is trampling the ability of artists to express themselves. Street photography doesn't work this way at all which means zero ability for artist to express themselves in that way. If you ask permission then you already lost the moment you wanted to picture. If you have to ask permissions you are not free to do what you really wanted because the subject who is sometimes unable to grasp what was in your mind due to the lack of education or any other reason would have the ability to block your work just because to his uneducated or corrupted or super enlightened mind it is not what photographer should picture. Why to bother then if someone else in full censorship over your work? It is zero freedom for art expression. And it influences the mood of photographer thus not allowing him to feel free and make pictures of what is really going on according to his perception. So instead of work of art you'll get glamour stupid pictures. Artificial demo instead of quality observation by the artist. Thanks to the attitude you've perfectly described it makes it in some countries absolutely impossible to do proper street photography and even harder to publish due to a lot of hassle. This leads to the situation where I simply do not publish my street photography and this is exactly: "how asking for a good faith effort to ask permission to take or publish photos of an individual is trampling the ability of artists to express themselves." >When people photograph you, they can then do anything they want with that photo. They can delete it, or store it indefinitely, or post it online, turn it into a meme, whatever. It is not exactly like that, there are nuances in each case of usage and they vary in different countries. But in general freedom of other person means that it is choice of that person and yes it can affect you deeply. Does it mean you should prohibit everything that affects you deeply? again there are other things that affect you much more deeply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29335887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29335887 Would you also be in favor of prohibiting a free speech? After all some of it could be unpleasant and affect you deeply? Just keep in mind that once you do that the society looses ability to discuss hard issues thus unable to face real issues thus separating itself from reality and together with inability for the artist to deliver different perspective on things would exactly be moving toward doomed oppressed society that is unable to deal with real world. If you wish to see live example you can look toward Russia and Belarus. Would you prefer to live there?
- remus 5y agoWould you feel the same way if someone did a painting of the same scene from memory? What if they were particularly adept at creating photorealistic paintings? How about if someone wrote a very vivid description of the same scene? Would you feel the same way? I'm genuinely interested and not trying to make any particular point.
- shapefrog 5y agoWould you feel the same way if someone looked at them and commited the image to their memory?
- bluefirebrand 5y agoThe story thing has actually happened to me, believe it or not. Actually it's probably happened to a ton of people. It happens all the time. Usually in verbal form, along with "remember that one time...?" But in my case someone actually wrote a NaNoWriMo story with me as one of the central characters. It was science fiction and no one could ever mistake it for being a true story. I still did not super like being included in such a way.
- dsego 5y agoI can feel the same about people looking at me without my permission. Is there a difference between the two?
- bluefirebrand 5y agoYes, and it should be obvious. Someone looking at you doesn't produce an artifact that they can profit off of, for one.