3 ms·
Apparently some people feel that any violation of free speech is unacceptable My favorite counterexample is, do you believe that disclosing state secrets to yo
by sliverstorm 15y ago
Apparently some people feel that any violation of free speech is unacceptable
My favorite counterexample is, do you believe that disclosing state secrets to your country's enemy to bring about the destruction of your country should be protected by free speech?
As a side note, I get the feeling anymore that people trumpeting absolute free speech aren't exactly staunch defenders of Liberty and Justice; they just see a convenient excuse for why it's O.K. to make other people miserable.
- tomjen3 15y ago>My favorite counterexample is, do you believe that disclosing state secrets to your country's enemy to bring about the destruction of your country should be protected by free speech? Assuming that you had not signed an NDA or otherwise took steps to grant yourself additional access to information then yes, you have a right to tell whom ever you fucking want. That is why certain things are kept secret.
- shabble 15y agoThere's also the concern of "Born Secret"[1] in US law, at least, which restricts even independent discovery of the 'secret' in question. Mostly famous for the high profile case of United States v. The Progressive [magazine] regarding publication of independently sourced facts and conjecture about the design of hydrogen bombs. Under something like that, you'd be required to keep something secret despite not having NDAs, access, etc. [1] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Born_secret https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Born_secret