4 ms·
Houses are not zero-sum, as it's possible to build more. Even for land, the value is all about how developed it is, which is not zero-sum: one can always devel
by HPsquared 5y ago
Houses are not zero-sum, as it's possible to build more.
Even for land, the value is all about how developed it is, which is not zero-sum: one can always develop more land.
In England for example, known as a densely-packed country, only about 2% of land is actually built on, and of that 2% only a tiny fraction is actually dense.
- francisofascii 5y agoThe value is very much about the location of the land. The neighborhood, school district, proximity to parks or transit. The actual structure matters less and less these days. It is "possible" to build more, but rarely politically viable.
- HPsquared 5y agoSchools, parks and transit are not static and new ones can be built. Those all fall under "development".
- herlitzj 5y agoYou say this as if it's fast or easy. All of these can easily take 10s of years build from conception to completion due to a myriad of reasons. Land acquisition, federal state and local funding, environmental review, court cases, zoning changes, public review proceses, etc. It's not like someone decrees that a school should be built and 6 months later it's up and running. And the school is the easy one on that list :)
- tlholaday 5y ago> Houses are not zero-sum, as it's possible to build more. Every newly-built house lowers the value of every already-built house. It is straightforward to specify initial conditions where the result is negative-sum.
- ushtaritk421 5y agoIt lowers the "value" as a monopolistic asset class but not the "housing/day units" value. The second value is what society should care about increasing, and it should go out of it's way to destroy the first kind of "value".
- kragen 5y ago> Every newly-built house lowers the value of every already-built house. Do you mean every already-built house nearby or every already-built house in the world? If you mean nearby then your theory would predict that places like San Francisco, Manhattan, and Paris would be among the cheapest places in the world to buy housing. This is very much the opposite of the truth, so if that's what you mean, then either your theory is completely wrong or the effect it describes is swamped by other effects that are much more important determinants of housing value. If you mean in the world then I suppose it's possible that you're correct in a market-value sense, since the effect on the price of my house due to someone in Shanghai building a nice new condo would be to drop the price by, say, US$0.00003. But if we're talking about use-value rather than exchange-value (which is the sense in which it really matters whether things are zero-sum, positive-sum, or negative-sum) it's hard to see how that could be true. Perhaps you think the use-value of my house is primarily that it enables me to laugh at the suffering of the homeless beggars of Dhaka? I assure you I spend zero time on that activity. So I think it's clear that your theory is just completely bogus.
- ProfessorLayton 5y agoIt's not bogus. It really is as simple as supply and demand. Yes, SF and NYC etc. are super expensive despite their density, however, what you're missing is that 1: Supply hasn't kept up with demand, and 2: SF/NYC would be even more expensive if they weren't as dense as they are now, and continuing to build (however slowly).
- dan_mctree 5y agoHave you considered that density may drive demand?
- larsiusprime 5y ago> the value is all about how developed it is If by "developed", you mean "built upon", that's empirically not the case: Here's an empty lot in the heart of San Francisco for $2 million dollars: https://www.fortressofdoors.com/content/images/2021/08/image-21.png https://www.fortressofdoors.com/content/images/2021/08/image... Here's a building next door to it on a similar sized lot for $2.3 million dollars: https://www.fortressofdoors.com/content/images/2021/08/image-22.png https://www.fortressofdoors.com/content/images/2021/08/image... Location, Location, Location. The vast majority of the value of urban real estate is land (locational) value.
- HPsquared 5y agoThe land value is increased by the nearby development known as "San Francisco". The same land in the same location, with no development nearby, would be worthless.
- BirdieNZ 5y agoThis is why it is sometimes referred to as "location value" rather than land value. The dirt is approximately worthless, but the location is worth a lot due to the surroundings (usually, because of human development of the surroundings). Advocates of a land value tax therefore often call it a location value tax, or a site value tax, because it is the location and the society around the location that has value, not the dirt itself.
- larsiusprime 5y agoYes, that was my point. That is exactly how land appreciation works. The owner of the land gains value from the work of his neighbors, whether he contributes or not.
- tlss 5y agoIt's possible to build more houses... up to a limit. Cities need to be supported by enough resources -- that includes enough water, proximity to arable land, hospitable climate, and ease of access. The 2% figure you quoted can be a bit misleading because we can never develop 100% of the land into houses. But as Japan/China/Korea has shown, it is probably still very possible for England to become much denser than it currently is. It would require all the residents to change their lifestyles to match though.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago>proximity to arable land Any land is arable if we want to. See Phoenix.
- bumby 5y agoThat potentially just shifts to another zero sum game for water rights. The West is dealing with that currently.
- bagels 5y agoOcean is full of water. It just costs money (maybe a lot) to desalinate it.
- bumby 5y ago(And to move it). That just pushes it to another zero sum game of money.
- bagels 5y agoWhy does it matter if it's zero sum? Sometimes things we need aren't free.
- bumby 5y agoThe GGP post was claiming housing was zero-sum. Posts responding to it seem to be trying to contradict it. My point is that in a world of finite resources, it's going to be zero-sum at some point whether that's land, water, money, labor, or something else. It's not good or bad, but you do have to pick your poison to a certain extent.
- cik2e 5y agoI agree with your comment in theory but I'd say that only applies over a long-enough horizon. At any given point in time when someone enters the market, there's a fixed supply. Sure, someone could commission the construction of their own home, but good luck with that in an urban area.
- theluketaylor 5y agoHousing doesn't need to be this way, but in much of the developed world we've artificially turned it into a zero-sum game with development restrictions, zoning rules, height limits, historic districts, green belts, and tons of other rules. None of those things is inherently bad on its own, and some are even a net good for society like a well managed green belt. Zoning in north america has an awful racist history and needs to be first on the chopping block. In combination all these restrictions have made adding density and housing units in areas with economic opportunity nearly impossible. Those who already own property (myself included) are participating in a system that is increasingly pulling up the ladder on those who wish to join. The housing market is one of the least free. Rules requiring bedrooms have 2 points of egress and that building have minimum fire resistance are fantastic and need to stay. Rules that do things like prevent 2, 3 and 4-plexes, mandate a whole city can't go above 4 stories, and require 1:1 parking for every adult need to get tossed out right away.
- wahern 5y ago> Rules that do things like prevent 2, 3 and 4-plexes, mandate a whole city can't go above 4 stories, and require 1:1 parking for every adult need to get tossed out right away. In places like California, simply strictly applying the existing rules would be a huge step forward. Instead, even projects that are 100% compliant with all building and zoning rules and already granted building department approval are subject to an endless and often patently illegal "community review" process. See, e.g., https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/State-gives-S-F-30-days-to-explain-why-it-16642975.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/State-gives-S-F-30-da... and https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/Supervisor-Mar-pushes-compromise-for-contested-16647322.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/Supervisor-Mar-pushes... Under Supreme Court precedent such ex post facto community "vetoes" are unconstitutional. The community votes by passing laws a priori, not through ad hoc, targeted manipulation of the regulatory review process. But for complex procedural and policy reasons the Supreme Court has unfortunately been too reticent to police violations of this principle. My disposition is toward federalism and local control, but in many cases the system is violating fundamental principles in our society about the creation and application of law. Principles even more basic and fundamental than property, free speech, or personal liberty rights.
- jimbob45 5y agoTo what end? How many houses do we need before we’re just making houses to enrich people rather than create shelter? States like Oregon and Washington that greatly limit supply are widely praised for their natural beauty and conservation precisely because they don’t chop down forestry to build cheap homes to sell to the CCP. Fools have created an acronym - NIMBY - to denigrate those who don’t want to waste land just for personal financial gain. However, there remain very real benefits to conserving forests and very real consequences to turning every square mile of land into an AirBNB. The landlord won’t live in that area and the renter won’t stay in the area long enough to care about the area but the long-term residents will pay the price regardless.
- iamstupidsimple 5y ago> Fools have created an acronym - NIMBY - to denigrate those who don’t want to waste land just for personal financial gain. Coming at this from a UK perspective, housing is a nightmare here too. But our green belt is at an all time low and London is an unbelievable sprawl. No, I'd rather rent forever than ruin the countryside.
- JamesBarney 5y agoIf you can afford to live in one of those places it's great. If your homeless you'd probably be ok with a little less green space if it meant you had a home to live in. Also very little of the NIMBY vs YIMBY debate is whether or not to turn forests into condos, it's almost also SFH vs denser construction.
- snidane 5y agoLand != land. Gresham law applies. City center land > suburban land > rural land > land on Mars > land in faraway galaxy. There is always scarcity of land even though there is an infinite capacity of it across the Universe.