3 ms·
> ask someone of the FSF group what "open source" means and they'll say the obvious meaning is you can look at the source code which is what makes "open source"
by teddyh 5y ago
> ask someone of the FSF group what "open source" means and they'll say the obvious meaning is you can look at the source code which is what makes "open source" different than FLOSS
Completely wrong. FSF considers the “open source” term to have the meaning as ascribed to it by the OSI. The FSF does not want to use the term itself, precisely because it can lead to misunderstandings.
The definition of “open source” is universally agreed upon to have the OSI-defined meaning, except for some people:
1. Intelligence community people, who have long understood the term “open source” to mean a source of intelligence which is not itself secret.
2. People who, without having ever looked it up, assume it means that the source code is available for reading. These people are simply ignorant, and should be using the term “source available” instead, since it means exactly that.
3. People who want to be able to use the “open source” term for their software to gain goodwill, but don’t want to actually give all of the freedoms it should guarantee. These people are dishonest shills who try to confuse the debate in order to get away with fraudulent labeling.
- zamadatix 5y agofsf.org links to this gnu.org article to define what they mean by "free software" https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html From this page: > The official definition of “open source software” (which is published by the Open Source Initiative and is too long to include here) was derived indirectly from our criteria for free software. It is not the same; it is a little looser in some respects. Nonetheless, their definition agrees with our definition in most cases. > > However, the obvious meaning for the expression “open source software”—and the one most people seem to think it means—is “You can look at the source code.” That criterion is much weaker than the free software definition, much weaker also than the official definition of open source. It includes many programs that are neither free nor open source.
- teddyh 5y ago> fsf.org links to this gnu.org article to define what they mean by "free software" https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html We were discussing the term “open source”, not “free software”. > From this page: No, the text you cite is not present on that page. It is present on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software; <https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....>. > Nonetheless, their definition agrees with our definition in most cases. In context, they obviously mean “[The OSI’s] definition [of ‘open source’] agrees with [the FSF’s] definition [of “free software’] in most cases”. The FSF does not have an alternative definition of “open source”; they explicitly use the OSI definition. > the obvious meaning for the expression “open source software”—and the one most people seem to think it means—is “You can look at the source code.” Contrary to what you seem to be implying, they are arguing against that definition of the term “open source”. This is evident by their phrasing: “That criterion […] includes many programs that are neither free nor open source.”