4 ms·
> But here in the real world... Your starting point was that any ISP who doesn't implement your preferred technical standard should be fined. With a disregard
by roenxi 5y ago
> But here in the real world...
Your starting point was that any ISP who doesn't implement your preferred technical standard should be fined. With a disregard for whether IPv6 makes sense for them or their customers. You might detect a little pushback here on the idea that your ideas are real world. Laissez faire is a very practical approach.
> By the time it becomes, it'll be too late and nobody will have it yet, so there won't be anywhere to switch anyways.
A crisis so terrible I can't even imagine it. Nobody outside some fairly obscure tech circles would even notice.
Imagine if they'd taken this approach rolling out IPv4 and weren't fast enough to change the legislation. The rollout of IPv6 would look really hard if IPv4 was a legislated requirement. The EU just isn't a competent technical standards body, and it has no business trying to be one because a couple of tech types like IPv6.
> That only happens in ideal markets where switching providers is trivial...
I switched providers to get IPv6 support. It was pretty trivial.
- franga2000 5y ago> Your starting point was that any ISP who doesn't implement your preferred technical standard should be fined. "my preferred standard" == the only alternative to the current collapsing standard that has been agreed upon by industry leaders for some 20 years now. > With a disregard for whether IPv6 makes sense for them or their customers. IPv6 can't "not make sense", it can only "not be necessary yet". > A crisis so terrible I can't even imagine it. Nobody outside some fairly obscure tech circles would even notice. What, service costs going through the roof because the ISP now has to buy IPv4 addresses? Getting IP blocked from sites because the address you share with half the town got reported for spam? Not being able to access IPv6-only sites from smaller providers who can't afford to lease IPv4 addresses? And only then the ISPs start investing in it, which will take a few years to finish, all the while your service is shit? Pretty obscure, yeah. > I switched providers to get IPv6 support. It was pretty trivial. I've been trying to for several years and have not been able to for a multitude of reasons.
- yyyk 5y ago>What, service costs going through the roof because the ISP now has to buy IPv4 addresses? If it was profitable, the ISP would do it and pocket the now unnecessary service costs. >Getting IP blocked from sites because the address you share with half the town got reported for spam? 99.9% people don't want to run their own SMTP server. It's an ultra-niche use case ISP don't care about. >Not being able to access IPv6-only sites from smaller providers who can't afford to lease IPv4 addresses? There aren't any. Look, it's just an internet addressing protocol, not something that justifies legislation.
- notriddle 5y ago> 99.9% people don't want to run their own SMTP server. It's an ultra-niche use case ISP don't care about. It's not SMTP. It's StopForumSpam and CloudFlare that you need to worry about.
- Dagger2 5y ago> If it was profitable, the ISP would do it and pocket the now unnecessary service costs. This is another "if you ask an economist" situation. In the real world, people will happily spend more effort justifying not doing v6 and working around problems caused by being v4-only than would be needed to just do v6. > 99.9% people don't want to run their own SMTP server. It's an ultra-niche use case ISP don't care about. This misses the point. It only takes one person behind CGNAT to get the CGNAT source IPs on a spam list, at which point it affects everyone. Plus spam exists on the web too, it's not an SMTP-only thing. > There aren't any. Which is exactly why it's so important to be deploying v6: so there can be v6-only sites. Or rather, more than there are at the moment, because they do exist. > Look, it's just an internet addressing protocol, not something that justifies legislation. I've seen an argument that it's already covered by existing legislation: the refusal of large/old providers to support v6, which forces the use of v4 which small/new providers can't get enough of, is beginning to look rather a lot like an abuse of market position. That would make it an anti-trust issue, which definitely falls within the remit of government.
- yyyk 5y ago>This is another "if you ask an economist" situation. In the real world, people will happily spend more effort justifying not doing v6 and working around problems caused by being v4-only than would be needed to just do v6. Yea, I don't like silly economism too, and I know half the jokes too. However, right now IPv4 addresses aren't so expensive. Sure, way more expensive than the 0 bucks they should cost, but not that expensive in the grand scheme of things. Here's a very rough calculation: The cost of IPv4 will start to bite when getting the needed addresses costs more than a single engineer salary where one lives. If a one time address buy costs less, it's not something business would care much for, and anti-trust won't touch it. I'm not smart enough to be able to forecast pricing, right now it's not there yet. Eventually the price will force every public network to IPv6, while many private networks will remain IPv4 forever.
- selfhoster11 5y agoGood luck switching providers to get IPv6 support. Unless you have true gigabit fiber, the only providers that don't have shit speeds without exorbitant expense (aka - Virgin Media) refuse to support IPv6.
- nobody9999 5y ago>I switched providers to get IPv6 support. It was pretty trivial. Your use case is not everyone's. I was forced to change ISPs recently and didn't have a choice as to which one (which is another, unrelated, issue). I did some research and the ISP in question does provide IPv6 support for some customers. However, the sales drones I spoke with claimed to not even know what IPv6 was, let alone whether or not it was available in my area. I'd say that has more to do with the exorbitant fees they charge for static IPv4 addresses than anything else. As such, it's not always "pretty trivial" to get IPv6 on your ISP link. I sure wish it was. Edit: Clarified my prose.