4 ms·
Of the things you learned under pressure of exams and grades, how many of them do you actually remember? That is, did you learn for long enough to pass the tes
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Of the things you learned under pressure of exams and grades, how many of them do you actually remember? That is, did you learn for long enough to pass the test, or did you learn?
- stagger87 5y agoIs it controversial/surprising to say that one would learn more from studying than not studying?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIs it controversial to say that cramming (remember, we're talking about studying under the deadline of a coming test) is not a great way to learn for long-term retention? Is it better than not studying at all? Probably... but not much.
- sqrt17 5y agoFalse dichotomy. What you call "not studying" would vary between effectively dropping out (for the people who are only at uni to get drunk and end up with a degree at the end), gaining a more thorough holistic understand of the material, or diving really deep on some of the aspects that are most interesting at the cost of others. The drink-and-get-a-certificate people will indeed profit from being encouraged to study, but the controversial opinion here would be that university should only or mainly care about those.
- WalterBright 5y agoI'm well aware of the modern movement to discredit tests, arguing that doing well on tests have nothing to do with knowing the material. I'm not a subscriber to that. If you are, I expect you'll be disappointed with the results. It's also why there are athletic competitions. It brings out the best in athletes as they strive to win. Are their achievements fake?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoYou seem to be ascribing to me a position that I do not hold. I don't have a problem with test as a measure. I don't exactly have a problem with tests as a motivational device, either. I have a problem with cramming as a learning technique. I don't think it works very well for actual long-term learning.
- cmh89 5y agoNo one is saying tests 'have nothing to do with knowing the material'. The point is that a test environment isn't ideal for gauging how well someone knows materials. Our system of testing incentivizes teaching to the test and a focus on pointless memorization. Our schools aren't supposed to be competitions, at least not primarily. Comparing them to athletics events is silly. If we wanted to find out "who is the best at taking test", then a test is the most appropriate tool. If we want to find out "Can Timmy do geometry", a classical closed-book, timed test isn't the best measurement. It comes down to, what is the point of testing students? What is gained by restricting access to clarifying materials or enforcing arbitrary time limits?
- WalterBright 5y ago> The point is that a test environment isn't ideal for gauging how well someone knows materials. Nobody said it was "ideal". Sheesh. But nobody has found a better way. > Our system of testing incentivizes teaching to the test and a focus on pointless memorization. News flash: some tests are poorly conceived. > It comes down to, what is the point of testing students? Allow me to reframe that. Would you get on an airplane piloted by a fellow who was never tested on his flying knowledge and skill?
- cmh89 5y ago>Nobody said it was "ideal". Sheesh. But nobody has found a better way. I mean, there are plenty of people who have found a better way. They get pushback from folks who think testing is the end-all-be-all of knowledge assessment. >News flash: some tests are poorly conceived. It's more like they are flawed from the get-go >Allow me to reframe that. Would you get on an airplane piloted by a fellow who was never tested on his flying knowledge and skill? I don't think it really benefits anyone to come up with irrelevant strawmen. Just like athletes, with pilots we care about their performance under specific conditions. Of course pilots should be tested in the conditions they should be working in. Obviously testing for specific things is necessary. The problem with the analogy is that the testing we use in K-16 doesn't mimic any real world conditions. A QB needs to be able to perform on the field and thats what we gauge them by. There is no reason an 8th grader needs to be able to solve X amount of problems in 50 minutes or whatever. It's adding elements to the assessment that are irrelevant for gauging knowledge.