4 ms·
Well, there's not much evidence for it. And, honestly, there's arguably an aspect of wishful thinking to it. "This was the result of a leak" is much less scary
by rsynnott 5y ago
Well, there's not much evidence for it. And, honestly, there's arguably an aspect of wishful thinking to it. "This was the result of a leak" is much less scary than "this just showed up", because in the leak scenario, the next one probably _could_ be stopped through better procedures, whereas the entirely natural scenario... well, there are some precautions that can be taken, but good luck preventing exiting new viruses from showing up from time to time.
- torstenvl 5y agoClosest known relatives of virus behind COVID-19 found in Laos https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02596-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02596-2 The NIAID claimed that it didn't fund research into BANAL-52 and similar. "the closest known relatives of SARS-CoV-2 . . . were not studied under the EcoHealth Alliance grant" https://www.niaid.nih.gov/diseases-conditions/coronavirus-bat-research https://www.niaid.nih.gov/diseases-conditions/coronavirus-ba... However, that was recently revealed to be extremely unlikely, since bat coronavirus samples were in fact collected from Laos, where BANAL-52 was located. Even more suspiciously, the Laos genetic samples disappeared from the WIV database in late 2019. https://wap.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/wuhan-scientists-were-studying-laos-bat-viral-samples-before-covid-report-121112201019_1.html https://wap.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/wu...
- postalrat 5y agoSo what's the harm in accepting it was a lab leak? You might end up with better procedures?
- kspacewalk2 5y agoBetter for whom? Certainly not for the labs. It's far better for the labs to draw their own conclusions from the leak, privately, at their own pace. Also, there's a significant financial disincentive: funding for gain of function research will be severely impacted by recognizing the lab leak as the most plausible explanation.
- inciampati 5y agoRight now I'd conclude that you can accidentally release things from labs with virtually no consequences. Just make sure that a similar virus exists naturally somewhere on the same continent, don't share any internal records, don't let your staff talk to the press, and you have plausible deniability.
- Fomite 5y agoThat depends on what you decide to do about it. 1) I've seen people call for a ban on research at all on BSL-3+ pathogens. 2) If you "accept that it was a lab leak" you are implicitly accepting that it was not a natural event - which is going to cause you to focus more on long-tailed, low-probability events like lab leaks, and less on zoonotic transmission events. Which if you're wrong would be a serious problem.
- MilnerRoute 5y ago> ...good luck preventing exiting new viruses from showing up from time to time. But even with a "natural origin," there are things that could be done. I've heard it said that the real Chinese cover-up in that scenario is the widespread trading of wild animals (with one wild animal vendor even travelling from Wuhan to other markets which China had insisted only sold frozen food and kitchenware). https://news.yahoo.com/virologist-suggests-coronavirus-origin-theorists-204106053.html https://news.yahoo.com/virologist-suggests-coronavirus-origi... You still have the same problem in the end: a "lack of transparency" (if not downright dishonesty) from the Chinese government. And also, an obvious avenue for reforming the dangers that helped spread the 2020 pandemic -- which is not being explored because of difficulties in even establishing the facts of the initial outbreak. I honestly don't know why this idea -- this possibility, this scenario -- isn't getting equal consideration.
- dehrmann 5y ago> there's not much evidence for it The fact that the first(?) major outbreak was in a city with a major virus research lab that researches coronaviruses is pretty strong circumstantial evidence. China's "nothing to see here" handling of it was also suspicious.