4 ms·
LOL yeah the US does the exact same thing. I would pay to read a newspaper that (somewhat satirically) reported on the US the way we report on our adversaries.
by whimsicalism 5y ago
LOL yeah the US does the exact same thing.
I would pay to read a newspaper that (somewhat satirically) reported on the US the way we report on our adversaries. Complete with referring to police as "security forces", including wild speculations about the backstabbing behind-the-scenes of their top politics, etc.
- jszymborski 5y agoThe issue I take with this point is that: 1) There's plenty of criticism of the West from within its many nations borders 2) There's far more from outside its borders 3) Criticism of crushingly oppressive dictatorships is strictly forbidden from within With that context, Western criticism of oppressive dictatorships serves a vital purpose, and so does fair criticism of the West.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe Washington Post does this occasionally. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/05/29/how-western-media-would-cover-minneapolis-if-it-happened-another-country/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/05/29/how-weste... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/global-opinions/wp/2017/08/16/what-if-western-media-covered-americas-white-tribalism-the-same-way-it-covers-other-nations/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/global-opinions/wp/2017/... "'Culturally, Americans are a curious lot,' said Andrew Darcy Morthington, an United Kingdom-based commentator who once embarked on a two-year mission trip to teach rural American children and therefore qualifies as an expert on U.S. affairs."
- elzbardico 5y agoThe wapo did it till last January
- hutzlibu 5y agoWell, just try some russian or chinese newspapers. I do it at times. There surely is wild propaganda mixed in, but also some very clear analysis of a certain cituation. More so, if for example russia is reporting on US-China crisis. Or vice versa.
- shlurpy 5y agoYou have to take into account bias even then. Negative bias and propaganda can be just as strong. But yeah, I personally read German news or AL Jazeera or whatever.
- zepto 5y ago> Complete with referring to police as "security forces", The western press goes in to far more detail about how oppressive, brutal and unaccountable American police are than any other country. There is pretty much an unending stream of criticism of the police. > including wild speculations about the backstabbing behind-the-scenes of their top politics, etc. If you have never seen such speculation about American politicians, I assume you have never looked at a newspaper.
- monocasa 5y agoEh, it's not quite the same. There was some foreign paper that described the George Floyd protests as 'tensions continue to rise over the death of an ethnic minority in a agrarian province at the hands of state security forces' that made me chortle when I read it.
- zepto 5y agoIt’s not quite the same - it’s far more critical.
- monocasa 5y agoI disagree.
- zepto 5y ago‘tensions continue to rise over the death of an ethnic minority in a agrarian province at the hands of state security forces’ Is absolutely nothing compared to the mountains of analysis of how racist and brutal the US police are, likening them to slave patrols, citing statistics about how often unarmed black people are killed, criticizing the Supreme Court for qualified immunity, explaining the overpolicing of trivial crimes in poor neighborhood and underpolicing of serious crimes that harm this same neighborhoods, the school to prison pipeline etc. etc. You’d be forgiven for thinking we live in an open society with a free press where people are unafraid to criticize the government and police.
- vkou 5y ago> I would pay to read a newspaper that (somewhat satirically) reported on the US the way we report on our adversaries If you really want this, just start reading foreign news.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI read quite a bit of news, but unfortunately only speak english. It is not quite the same - newspapers put out in english by foreign adversaries are usually targeting foreign audiences, so they are not written in quite the same fashion as how American outlets describe regimes in other countries. The closest I've found is SCMP English in Beijing, which (at least for print) is apparently different (and more slanted) than the English version found in the US.
- pessimizer 5y ago"Regime" and "oligarchs" are my big annoyances. If you used words and phrases like these for domestic stories consistently, they'd lose all of their propaganda value. Hell, "propaganda" is the archetypal example. All communications with the primary purpose of advocacy were referred to as propaganda until the propaganda industry came up with the term "Public Relations." It's a bit like the Anglo-Saxon/Latin split in English, where the Anglo-Saxon word means the cheap, commonplace version of whatever the Norman word is. English for the last century or so has had a sort of "communist register" that you're required to use about things that are officially disapproved of.