2 ms·
There are two forces at work here, is my understanding. One has changed as the center of the economy in the US has changed and one will not without some kind of
by shadowgovt 5y ago
There are two forces at work here, is my understanding. One has changed as the center of the economy in the US has changed and one will not without some kind of massive incentives.
The first is heavy industry. Mixed-use made no sense when America was an industrial backbone because nobody thinks it's wise to put everyone's houses right next to the steel furnaces (1). But as US labor shifts from manufacturing to service sector, I anticipate we'll see more mixed-use. We already see quite a bit of it in city commercial districts.
The second is suburbia. It doesn't matter how many apartment-bistros we rezone if "the good life" in America still looks like owning (or renting, nowadays) a 2-bedroom 2-story outside town with a lawn and a fence only to get on the freeway twice a day, 5-6 days a week to swear at traffic to get to and from work. But incentives will have to be massively restructured to alter that behavior because America is blessed with land (and its citizens blessed / cursed with a fascinatingly unlimited tolerance for travel time... I once had a coworker who did a 90-minute one-way drive from the next state over 5 days a week. Better jobs than her hometown, but she didn't want to leave home). It's generally still cheaper to buy (or rent from someone who bought) a home on nuked-and-paved farmland than deal with a landlord in a more concentrated urban center, where higher population density lets them charge more (and you never even have a prayer of owning that tenement building... 1950s suburbia is increasingly unattainable for most Americans, but it's a lie we still believe).
(1) I'm distorting history a bit... In what is now the Rust Belt, homes within walking distance of the factories were common in the industrial-center cities. But so was lung cancer, and personal transportation hadn't yet exploded into ubiquity like it has now.