3 ms·
> If you are a Linux distribution maintainer, please understand what all of these solutions are trying to accomplish. All your hard work in building your softwa
by panick21_ 5y ago
> If you are a Linux distribution maintainer, please understand what all of these solutions are trying to accomplish. All your hard work in building your software repository, maintaining your libraries, testing countless system configurations, designing a consistent user experience… they are trying to throw all of that away. Every single one of these runtime packaging mechanisms is trying to subvert the operating system, replacing as much as they can with their own. Why would you support this?
This sound like a luddite that is against machines. How about embrace the revolution and then you can save a huge amount of work and focus on other things. There are enough things distor people could focus on instead.
I don't buy any of the technical arguments here and it sounds mostly like moralizing argument rather then anything else.
- ltbarcly3 5y agoThe whole point is that this is technically worse and only being used to try to bootstrap a walled garden where they (RedHat, Canonical for flatpack or snap) get paid a fee due to a monopoly on app distribution to their users. This is not 'the revolution' we should support. I encourage you to study the technical arguments until you understand them well enough that they become convincing.
- panick21_ 5y ago> monopoly on app distribution to their users And the argument that it is a walled garden is simply nonsense. Its not monopoly any more then any default repository is. > I encourage you to study the technical arguments until you understand them well enough that they become convincing. I have been using flatpak since it came out and many other people in this thread have already pointed out the failure of the technical arguments, no need to do that again.
- ltbarcly3 5y agoI guess Canonical, who makes 100% of their revenue on support contracts for open source software, doesn't release the snap server code in open source because... what's the reason you are going to come up with? What possible reason is there apart from making it difficult for anyone else to set up any repository at all? It's the same reason they bet big on Ubuntu on Phones. App stores are worth a ton of money, you contribute effectively nothing and collect 25% of other company's revenue purely because you can lock out any competing app store.
- panick21_ 5y agoI don't care about Snap, only Flatpak.
- ltbarcly3 5y agoGood for you, here is some candy?
- panick21_ 5y agoYour arguments simply don't hold any water when we are talking about Flatpak. So I guess you can have candy but no water.
- ltbarcly3 5y agoJust announcing that you think something you disagree with is wrong isn't an argument at all. I know you think my arguments are wrong since you are disagreeing. The only reason you have given for thinking they are wrong is that you don't think they are convincing. This may be because you have a secret reason you don't want to share, but I believe it is more likely you are more interested in being disagreeable than in understanding.
- southerntofu 5y ago> This sound like a luddite that is against machines. The luddites were not anti-tech from a moral perspective, but understood mechanization of work to profit the bosses and go against the interests of workers (artisans) and therefore practiced sabotage. Despite this initial mischaracterization, i believe the metaphor holds and the author is against this application of this technology precisely because they believe it produces a net negative impact across the ecosystem.
- panick21_ 5y agoSure, I agree with your interpretation of luddites historically. However I still think moral is the right word. The consequences are consider amoral. So its is very much a moral perspective. And I think the argument that it is bad for the ecosystem is fundamentally wrong.