3 ms·
Cherry-picked anecdotes and data to support a priori conclusions.
by scott_s 18y ago
Cherry-picked anecdotes and data to support a priori conclusions.
- jmtulloss 18y agoI agree, but it's still a counter point that isn't often discussed. Maybe you'll start to see more things supporting the argument now that it's in your mind.
- scott_s 18y agoI don't think the author's position is new or radical; I've heard it frequently. Your second sentence describes confirmation bias.
- jmtulloss 18y agoYeah, I know. Confirmation bias isn't a bad thing if you're aware of your own thought processes. You can see arguments for both sides if you're paying attention. All I'm saying is that just because you've made a conclusion a priori doesn't mean it's a bad idea to write about it. That's how argument and discussion works. It's only a bad thing when you've proven yourself wrong and you refuse to admit it.
- iloveyouocean 18y agoNo anecdotes or data to support a priori dismissal.
- pg 18y agoThat could equally well describe any essay. An essay is not a report on a controlled experiment. You have to work to decide which parts you agree with.
- scott_s 18y agoIt could describe most bad essays, yes. Good essays either stay out of falsifiability territory, or they invite formal exploration of the subject. In this essay, she makes claims that are supported only with anecdotes, when data could be used. This is important since I can easily think of counter-anecdotes that nullify her arguments. The biggest example is her claim that males are predominantly presented as emasculated in popular culture. I'm sure one can consume a subset of all popular culture where that is true, and I'm also sure one can do the opposite. But if someone were to actually come up with a metric and test this idea, then that would be worthwhile.
- pg 18y agoGood essays either stay out of falsifiability territory, or they invite formal exploration of the subject. It would be a mistake to write an essay using anecdotal evidence to argue about a precisely defined question in math or the hard sciences. But outside math and the hard sciences, falsifiability gets fuzzy. A statistical (surely you don't really mean formal?) analysis of this topic would be in the domain of "social science," and though such studies usually measure something precisely, it's never clear what. Often a thoughtful essay will come closer to the truth, despite containing no tables of numbers.
- scott_s 18y agoI'd prefer an attempt at a statistical analysis (yes, that's what I was getting at) which is upfront about assumptions and methodologies. Essays are worthwhile, but are only honest if the author is upfront about their assumptions. This author presents her assumptions as fact. That's when I tune out. In particular, this essay is predicated on the assumption that our culture is more emasculated than in the past - if this is not the case, then the entire thing falls apart. I think there are reasonable ways to test this assumption, but the author, as a reporter, is probably not equipped to do so.