3 ms·
> I know memorization is seen negatively from a pedagogical standpoint, and schoolchildren find it alienating and discouraging, but I think when you have enough
by Jtsummers 5y ago
> I know memorization is seen negatively from a pedagogical standpoint, and schoolchildren find it alienating and discouraging, but I think when you have enough experience to understand the value of it, so that the work to achieve it isn't such a negative experience in itself, judicious application of it has a lot of power to make your work easier and your learning experiences richer.
https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2013/09/when-memorization-gets-in-the-way-of-learning/279425/ https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2013/09/when-m... - Article I read years ago on this, I think it helps to frame the debate of memorization vs anti-memorization. In particular this sentence:
> I define memorization as learning an isolated fact through deliberate effort. [emphasis in original]
I'll emphasize isolated fact. A lot of people who say memorization and rote learning are bad or ineffective are probably framing it in the same sense as this author. They (mostly, there are exceptions) aren't arguing against committing information to memory, but of committing information to memory with no (or minimal) understanding attached to it.
If you just learn isolated facts, you become a meat sack Chinese room (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room). You can't connect the dots and perform the real interesting work of synthesis (combining information and ideas) or derivation (from what you know, determine new results). The author talks about students "knowing" that the sine of pi/2 is 1. What do they actually know, though? What can they do with that fact on its own without any understanding of what "sine" itself means and the contexts in which it is used?
- dkarl 5y agoYep, defining memorization as learning "isolated" facts presupposes that the teacher is too lazy to draw connections in the classroom and explain the relevance of what the students are learning. It defines memorization as something that only an incompetent teacher would utilize, like defining engagement with primary sources as having students read material in dense technical or archaic language they don't understand, without assistance, or defining classroom discussion as asking the students to talk about the material and then going to the teacher's lounge to have a cup of coffee. No teacher would defend the use of techniques framed that way.