3 ms·
When you look at the recent history, it becomes evident that all big powers were enjoying a through view of the societies they were governing, and modern commun
by bayindirh 5y ago
When you look at the recent history, it becomes evident that all big powers were enjoying a through view of the societies they were governing, and modern communication changed this.
They don't want new powers, they want their old powers back. When I understood that, I enlightened.
- IgorPartola 5y agoWhat are you talking about? Do you really think that the king of England had a better view into his subjects inner thoughts in the 18th century than literally anyone can currently do by pulling up anyone’s social media presence? You don’t need to read private text messages to know what people are up to. They tweet, post on Reddit, Instagram, and TikTok about it all the time.
- bee_rider 5y agoI think by 'recent history' they mean more like 1970-2010 or so. I'm not sure I agree but at least that isn't outright ridiculous like the 18'th century would be.
- bayindirh 5y agoI was talking about [1960, ...}, but older "kingdoms" also had a passing knowledge about their population's state. This knowledge was much leaner when compared to today, but there were less population to begin with, so that knowledge was enough. Crowded countries like China had its social norms evolved accordingly and differently due to this population density.
- IgorPartola 5y agoHow many people tweeted about storming Area 51 in the 1950s? Or put up long political monologues on Tik Tok? I think your argument is 180 degrees backwards from how things actually are.
- bayindirh 5y agoJust because people didn't have Twitter or TikTok in 50s and 60s doesn't mean that people didn't think about these things. It was only disseminated to a tighter group, so they're closer, less prominent and smaller. Increase in the speed of communication and in overall population allowed greater dissemination in shorter time, that's it. Before, more manual methods worked well enough to get a sniff of these activities, but it doesn't work now. So, governments want their cake back. CIA did mass surveillance on state level with Crypto AG. Russians bugged whole fleet of diplomatic IBM typewriters. Intelligence agencies listened people via central heating pipes, insiders were planted inside suspected groups... The ways were numerous, and still are. The people, society and technology is evolving. So the game. I don't support the initiative, but that's the state of the play right now. This might be backwards when looked from there, but this is how it looks from here.
- IgorPartola 5y agoRight. So in the past it took massive amounts of money and manpower to watch relatively small groups of people. Now those same groups organize on easily accessible and sometimes straight up public websites so it takes less money and manpower to monitor virtually everyone. What power is the government trying to get back? Seems like achieving their goal got easier, not harder.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe bulk of the manpower for the Stasi was the good little people of East Germany ratting on each other.
- bayindirh 5y ago> Seems like achieving their goal got easier, not harder. Nope. E2E communications have buried a lot of stuff proverbially underground. The leaks are reduced. Hence, governments lost the ability to monitor as they liked. There's much more and invisible communication going on when compared to the past, and it's much more detailed and direct. Also its volume has increased exponentially. So monitoring that stuff got way harder, and they want the easy way back.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, this makes good sense.
- 8ytecoder 5y agoThere has never been a time, except for short periods, where the ruling class has had full access to what everyone has been saying or thinking. There has always been constraints on how much they can know about the populace. Distance, cost, manpower have all been age old constraints. A new technology usually makes it easy to monitor but then something else comes in the way to block it. I think Stasi are probably the only real-successful blanket monitoring.
- jacquesm 5y agoEven the Stasi didn't manage to get everything, but they made a very impressive effort and a Stasi like entity with today's technology may well achieve the panopticon that they were shooting for able to suppress dissent before it hatched into something actionable. Their main tool? Snitches. The tools we have made are quite dangerous for this and that's one more reason why we as the techies responsible for the creation of such tools should ensure that this can never ever happen. It's also one the reasons why Phil Zimmermann is one of my personal heroes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_Zimmermann https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_Zimmermann
- 77pt77 5y ago> They don't want new powers, they want their old powers back I don't agree. They want both. They want more!
- e0a74c 5y ago> They don't want new powers, they want their old powers back Maybe you're too young to remember a time when no one carried a GPS in their pocket, most payments were done in cash and only banks had CCTV cameras. I'd love to see states and companies take back the "powers" they had back then :)
- novok 5y agoTrue, but your phone calls, letters and packages were very easy to silently tap and interdict and were all controlled by central monopolies. Nobody encrypted anything, so raids on offices gave a lot juicy information in plain paper.
- bayindirh 5y agoNo, I'm not that young, but I've read enough history knowing that countries had a passing knowledge about the state of the population under their control. You don't need Stasi or NSA level of access to know the state of your citizens. Intelligence is an old craft. Insiders are old as well. However, speed of life and increase in population coupled with new communication methods invalidate these old methods. To protect their status quo, governments want their so-called vision back, and then some...