3 ms·
I'm not sure if the Library of Congress website can survive an influx of hacker-news traffic on their video streaming. So I'll leave a brief summary here. This
by dragontamer 5y ago
I'm not sure if the Library of Congress website can survive an influx of hacker-news traffic on their video streaming. So I'll leave a brief summary here.
This 1952 cartoon is a very good explanation of the theory behind the New York Stock Exchange. The first few minutes are a bit of humor to set up Mr. John Q Public who is trying to save up his nest-egg for retirement (roughly the first 3 minutes). This naturally leads him to look into stocks, which the video then explains what stocks are.
The remaining 8 minutes of the 11-minute cartoon then goes into the theory of stocks: how stocks raise money for a business (a hypothetical oil-barrel company). First, a private equity raise with a bank ($3-million), and then later, the company IPOs on the NYSE directly for even more money ($20-million). The numbers are small by modern standards (showing off the last 70 years of inflation), but the concept remains the same: investment banks get earlier rounds of investment... and eventually an IPO on the stock exchanges brings in even more money.
There's also a good segment about what exactly goes on a ticker-tape, who looks at ticker tapes (the various partners of NYSE across the country), who places orders, and what happens on the NYSE floor (how buyers / sellers meet up). Modern computers do the same job and faster: broadcasting the last price sold on the exchange, and automatically matching up buy / sell orders with each other. As such, the ticker-tape analogy with humans is actually a very good mental model for what these computers are doing.
Though many things have changed in the last 70 years, it seems as if the stock market still plays the same role and function today as it did back then.
- phnofive 5y agoWhat's missing, in my opinion, is share dilution - do initial investors get a say, since they too hope for growth to compensate for the lost proportional ownership?
- Kranar 5y agoDepends on the corporation's bylaws, but generally the board of directors issues new shares. Investors get a say in so far as they agree to the bylaws and elect the board.
- phnofive 5y agoAppreciate the response! I was referring to the cartoon, though - it's clear why the president/board would want this (capital to expand), but less so why the existing shareholders would (presumably, in context, increased future value or dividends).
- quacked 5y agoPortions of it are available on YT: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnJCOof2HJk&t=449s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnJCOof2HJk&t=449s
- zinekeller 5y ago> I'm not sure if the Library of Congress website can survive an influx of hacker-news traffic on their video streaming. Seems that they use Cloudflare for their video distribution, it'll be fine.
- vannevar 5y ago>Though many things have changed in the last 70 years, it seems as if the stock market still plays the same role and function today as it did back then. Does it, though? The cartoon (which was probably a little naive even back when it was made) presents a world where corporations have a duty to provide good jobs and to serve the national interest in times of crisis. It describes the stock market as the mechanism for these corporations to raise money for growth and to share their profits with public shareholders. It talks about how carefully the NYSE vets the companies going public, and how a company must have substantial real assets and profits to be considered. But I would argue that today, the tail is wagging the dog. Capital uses the market as a way to aggregate more capital, and if it happens to provide some money for growth and some of the wealth gets spread around, that's just a happy side effect. Those considerations are secondary to the game. Companies go public now with virtually no assets other than name recognition, and no profit in sight. There are public companies with billion-dollar valuations and less than 200 employees. There is no implicit or explicit expectation of social value, a company is judged solely on its return on capital, a judgment that will always be weighted towards those with the most capital to begin with. The idea that it contributes to the national standard of living, or can provide some value in a national emergency, doesn't enter into the discussion at all. The cartoon is goofy, but at least it has a notion of civic obligation that no longer exists.
- dragontamer 5y agoThe point of this cartoon is for the USA to puff out its chest about the benefits of capitalism in the age of the Cold War. Capitalism vs Communism is the underlying theme of this cartoon (though unspoken, we cannot ignore the timeperiod this cartoon was made in). ------ That being said, the cartoon is correct about the fundamentals of how the stock market works, and its theoretical benefits. I'm sure companies existed back then that were terrible, but we gloss over those facts in propaganda to make the audience feel better about their society.
- systemvoltage 5y agoNot inclined to you but... I was afraid that the comments in this thread is going to be political. Yup, low and behold HN never disappoints. At this point, so many things are being politicized (Rust drama today as well), that is better to stay off of HN than not for mental health.
- dr-detroit 5y agoYup. Scam in plain sight.
- RC_ITR 5y ago>showing off the last 70 years of inflation Be careful with this point. Inflation is the value relationship between money and non-money. Part of the reason companies raise more now is because they are bigger and more profitable, not just because dollars are worth less relative to goods. For example, Ford went public in 1956 on a market cap of $3bn (one of the largest in the world at that time) on net income of c. $200mn, for a c. 15x P/E ratio. Today, Ford is worth c. $80bn and its net income is c. $4bn, for a P/E of c. 20x. The only inflation there is the move from 15x to 20x. EDIT: and to make this point more clearly, new cars have only inflated 3x since 1956, even thought Ford is 25x larger. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/fredgraph.png?g=JbBS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/fredgraph.png?g=JbBS
- folli 5y agoSo the ticker-tapes (which I only know from old time movies) really reported on every single transaction that occurred within the stock exchange? I assume that's quite a lot of data that was processed, even 70 years ago?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> every single transaction that occurred within the stock exchange? Yes > I assume that's quite a lot of data that was processed, even 70 years ago? “The New York Stock Exchange in 1954 had the most prosperous year since 1933 with its volume of business totaling 573,374,622 shares. This compared with 354,851,325 shares traded in 1953.” https://www.nytimes.com/1955/01/01/archives/54-stock-market-busiest-since-33-573374622-shares-dealt-in-on-new.html https://www.nytimes.com/1955/01/01/archives/54-stock-market-... So in 1953, not even 1 million shares per day traded on average.
- dragontamer 5y agoThe cartoon talks about odd-lots and round-lots for a reason. Odd-lots would not occur on the exchange. The "local" broker will handle odd lots, group them up into round lots, and only once a large enough round-lot was collected would the broker call up NYSE and actually do the exchange. ------ For example, if Alice was selling 32 shares of FOO, and Bob was buying 10 shares of FOO, the local broker would give Bob 10 shares (from Alice), and then take the remaining 22-shares for themselves. It was somewhat risky because if the share price changes dramatically, the broker could lose money... but this risk was compensated by brokerage fees. Eventually, Eve sells another 180 shares, meaning the brokerage now has 202 shares on hand. At this point the brokerage would telephone in to NYSE that they're selling 2 round lots of FOO. Once the broker confirms the sell order, they hand the money to Eve, and are left with a 2-share odd lot for themselves. --------- A brokerage could hold some stock in larger quantities if they were very popular in a town. Maybe Detroit has a lot of Ford / General Motors traders for example, so the local brokerage in Detroit would hold more Ford / GM to help speed up transactions. When transacting with odd lots, they simply use the last price on the ticker-tape.
- froh 5y agoThanks for the summary, which actually made me have a look. Regarding the Library of Congress website, it seems to me that leverages a well greased global CDN and will serve the video just fine.