7 ms·
What Makes Us Tick? (1952) [video]
- wly_cdgr 5y agoThe part where he is trying to think of all the good things he has done with his life and the first and nearly only things that come to mind are insurance and ogling women who are not his wife on vacation is so brutally dreary and depressing
- oliv__ 5y agoI know they are always a bit naïve and overly optimistic but I love these war-era cartoons, commercials and "propaganda" art: the overwhelming belief in America, capitalism and a better future is so contagious, it's like a breath of fresh air in a new spring
- dragontamer 5y agoI'm not sure if the Library of Congress website can survive an influx of hacker-news traffic on their video streaming. So I'll leave a brief summary here. This 1952 cartoon is a very good explanation of the theory behind the New York Stock Exchange. The first few minutes are a bit of humor to set up Mr. John Q Public who is trying to save up his nest-egg for retirement (roughly the first 3 minutes). This naturally leads him to look into stocks, which the video then explains what stocks are. The remaining 8 minutes of the 11-minute cartoon then goes into the theory of stocks: how stocks raise money for a business (a hypothetical oil-barrel company). First, a private equity raise with a bank ($3-million), and then later, the company IPOs on the NYSE directly for even more money ($20-million). The numbers are small by modern standards (showing off the last 70 years of inflation), but the concept remains the same: investment banks get earlier rounds of investment... and eventually an IPO on the stock exchanges brings in even more money. There's also a good segment about what exactly goes on a ticker-tape, who looks at ticker tapes (the various partners of NYSE across the country), who places orders, and what happens on the NYSE floor (how buyers / sellers meet up). Modern computers do the same job and faster: broadcasting the last price sold on the exchange, and automatically matching up buy / sell orders with each other. As such, the ticker-tape analogy with humans is actually a very good mental model for what these computers are doing. Though many things have changed in the last 70 years, it seems as if the stock market still plays the same role and function today as it did back then.
- phnofive 5y agoWhat's missing, in my opinion, is share dilution - do initial investors get a say, since they too hope for growth to compensate for the lost proportional ownership?
- Kranar 5y agoDepends on the corporation's bylaws, but generally the board of directors issues new shares. Investors get a say in so far as they agree to the bylaws and elect the board.
- phnofive 5y agoAppreciate the response! I was referring to the cartoon, though - it's clear why the president/board would want this (capital to expand), but less so why the existing shareholders would (presumably, in context, increased future value or dividends).
- quacked 5y agoPortions of it are available on YT: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnJCOof2HJk&t=449s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnJCOof2HJk&t=449s
- zinekeller 5y ago> I'm not sure if the Library of Congress website can survive an influx of hacker-news traffic on their video streaming. Seems that they use Cloudflare for their video distribution, it'll be fine.
- vannevar 5y ago>Though many things have changed in the last 70 years, it seems as if the stock market still plays the same role and function today as it did back then. Does it, though? The cartoon (which was probably a little naive even back when it was made) presents a world where corporations have a duty to provide good jobs and to serve the national interest in times of crisis. It describes the stock market as the mechanism for these corporations to raise money for growth and to share their profits with public shareholders. It talks about how carefully the NYSE vets the companies going public, and how a company must have substantial real assets and profits to be considered. But I would argue that today, the tail is wagging the dog. Capital uses the market as a way to aggregate more capital, and if it happens to provide some money for growth and some of the wealth gets spread around, that's just a happy side effect. Those considerations are secondary to the game. Companies go public now with virtually no assets other than name recognition, and no profit in sight. There are public companies with billion-dollar valuations and less than 200 employees. There is no implicit or explicit expectation of social value, a company is judged solely on its return on capital, a judgment that will always be weighted towards those with the most capital to begin with. The idea that it contributes to the national standard of living, or can provide some value in a national emergency, doesn't enter into the discussion at all. The cartoon is goofy, but at least it has a notion of civic obligation that no longer exists.
- quacked 5y agoI hate the stock market almost as much as I respect it as an incredible tool. The further out you can guarantee future rewards in exchange for labor and materials, the more prosperous your society will be, and we've seen that in spades. The Dutch invented the concept of common-stock and became the masters of the sea in no time flat; I wouldn't be surprised if the progress (if that's what you believe it is) of the Europeans in philosophy and government was engaged in a feedback loop with the ability of the "common man" to tie his own fortunes into the engines of commerce, rather than into his own social status. At the same time, it feels infuriating that in order to afford medicine, clothes, food, shelter, and defense once you're past your working prime you must attach your fortunes to companies that have very little to do with the actual services you require in retirement. Personally, I think that the American middle class has been totally taken hostage by Wall Street via the 401(k) and the IRA; anything that threatens "market performance" (e.g. a series of metrics made up and owned by the market owners) threatens their ability to provide for themselves. In this way, any serious large-scale action that might mend a social ill is off the table if its implementation damages large-scale market performance.
- kgin 5y ago2/3 of Americans don’t have and will never have a 401k or IRA.
- AlanSE 5y ago> At the same time, it feels infuriating that in order to afford medicine, clothes, food, shelter, and defense once you're past your working prime you must attach your fortunes to companies that have very little to do with the actual services you require in retirement. This feels like the worst possible argument against public corporations. There's a whole sector of the stock market for health care, and you can easily buy funds that only invest in that. What other services to retirees need? You will be able to find listed companies providing all of those services. There are some technical imperfections in a basket of equities. If your intention is to exactly hedge living costs, then you would also seek to own bonds from those companies, much of the economy is not public, and so on. There are valid points to be found, I don't think these are what you're concerned about. In the big picture, owning the means of production is the only game that makes sense. What's the alternative? The best store of value is a collection of things that people are paying for, because that's central to the economic definition of value. Otherwise, everything is gold or bitcoin.
- JohnWhigham 5y agoKind of related: what was it in Hollywood that did away the old time-y presentations like this in animations? The grand orchestral music, the personable-but-still-authoritative male narrator, amazingly well-paced script. Was it Hanna-Barbera and how they commoditized animation?
- dragontamer 5y agoThe opposite. These presentations were 100% within the propaganda period of the USA. These sorts of cartoons were top-down funded by the US Government for WW2 and eventually, the cold war (well, this cartoon is 1952, well within the Cold War period). But all of these cartoonists were good at their job _because_ of WW2 propaganda cartoons. US Government practically bankrolled Disney (and other cartooning groups) to ensure we had unity throughout the War. What changed is politics. We're no longer in a World War nor a Cold War... and propaganda techniques such as this cartoon are now frowned upon. --------- This is "good propaganda" though. I think our country needs more of it these days. But it'd be a difficult political battle to get people used to propaganda again, especially because there's no communist threat anymore for us to point to. If we were to ask the US Government to spend $50 million bucks making a similar production cartoon today on a variety of US-subjects (imagine an up-to-date version of this cartoon on the modern Stock Market), can you imagine how many people would be pissed off? -------- In any case, as US Government propaganda money dried up from the post-war period (1960s), the quality of cartoons dropped down. People still agreed upon the commissioning of educational cartoons for children (ex: School House Rock), but not upon educational cartoons for adults. > Was it Hanna-Barbera and how they commoditized animation? Hanna Barbera needed to commoditize animation to save money. With less money flowing into the industry from the post-war period (much less propaganda being made), the quality of cartoons suffered.
- TheGigaChad 5y agoYes, because 50M is a huge sum. You have youtube content creators making similar cartoons for peanuts.
- jaypeg25 5y agoThe US govt is certainly still involved in propaganda. For example, NASA helped with The Martian.[1] DoD released a game, America's Army, about 20 years ago with a total budget of $32 million over 8 years or so.[2] Also, Pentagon pays about $10-15 million annually just for the various pro-military messaging we see at sports events (salute to veterans, etc).[3] These are just some examples, but there are plenty more. [1]. https://www.popsci.com/why-nasa-helped-ridley-scott-create-martian-film-and-what-means-future-sci-fi-space-movies/ https://www.popsci.com/why-nasa-helped-ridley-scott-create-m... [2]. https://www.wired.com/2009/12/americas-army-budget https://www.wired.com/2009/12/americas-army-budget [3]. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2015/11/04/report-at-least-50-teams-were-paid-by-department-of-defense-for-patriotic-displays/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2015/11/04...
- whimsicalism 5y agoWatching this really drives home how much being a woman in this era must have sucked.
- tantalor 5y agoIs eating bonbons on the chaise really so bad?
- gknoy 5y agoIt looks like you're getting downvoted, but I think it's clear that the woman's perceived role at the time was NOT just eating bonbons. I think the fact that the cartoon portrays this in comedy and exaggerated form (just as the man's car is comically Too Small, and his "built to last" house's door falls off) underscores that the woman's role was perceived to be _infinite housework_ (rather than, say, coming home from _her_ job). Consider that her "help" includes the man washing a floor. In contrast, the wife (now relaxing) has handled dishes, meal planning + prep, laundry, ironing -- and the appliances there are portrayed as making that all that work take less time. As someone with all those tools now, I can confirm that I have a hard time even keeping up with what housework I notice needs doing, let alone all the work that my wife does (and arguably should have to do less of). It feels like that implied portrayal of "wife sits at home goofing off all day because machines do all the real work" couldn't be the norm.
- kelseyfrog 5y ago> that implied portrayal of "wife sits at home goofing off all day because machines do all the real work" couldn't be the norm. The history of women's work is a history of unpaid labor. The reality maintenance machinery supporting this is powerful. From devaluing industries which see a change in gender participation, to not classifying certain tasks as labor, the mechanisms of maintenance range from insidious to ridiculous. Understanding what happens if that reality is not maintained is important to understanding why it is maintained.
- moskie 5y agoThe issue being that it isn't an accurate representation of the lived experiences of women at the time. It is my instead the perceived experiences of women from the perspective of misogynists.
- a-dub 5y agoi've been pondering this notion of fractional shares that has become popular amongst retail brokers recently. i read some news about a stock split and it got me wondering how relevant that is now that shares are essentially divisible down to the penny. the fact that splits exist at all says that it's a knob that is intentionally turned at some point... but what did it do? does it reduce volatility by requiring a larger outlay to participate? (a sort of requirement to put more skin in the game). if so, does its elimination increase systemic risk? does it mean that every stock becomes a penny stock- subject to unpredictable price moves as a result of cheap speculation?
- vineyardmike 5y ago> does it reduce volatility by requiring a larger outlay to participate? Yes. Absolutely. It also makes it less appealing to retail investors. Eg. Berkshire Hathaway A stock is 431,536.38 at time of writing. Amazon is 3,608.66, Apple is 163.27. Apple is supposedly the most popular consumer-held stock. It also makes it harder to use derivative products. eg. Options require buying/selling 100x shares, so Berkshire Hathaway would literally require millions of dollars for one option contract. That surely impacts trade volume. > Does [fractional shares] mean that every stock becomes a penny stock- subject to unpredictable price moves as a result of cheap speculation? Yes and no. Not all companies are available as fractions. Also, the Robinhood investor who is day trading from his phone at work is probably using fractional and driving price movements (eg. GME), but the day trading full time investor class is not using fractional shares nearly as much. A lot of more professional-focused platforms either don't allow fractions (or don't for pro users), or don't make full features available. Eg. IBKR is a common platform for Algo trading and their api doesn't allow fractional shares (but their manual GUI with app allows it). This is likely due to technical and liquidity reasons as much as pragmatic ones. When a fractional share is available, that basically means the broker owns the shares, and gives you partial ownership. They need to basically own n+1 across their platform for all users (round up). If you're doing large trading volumes, that's impractical to keep up with on their end - especially if you quickly buy a lot and sell back. > does it mean that every stock becomes a penny stock Just to repeat, usually brokers only support the most popular stocks as fractional, which already have high volume. This means it may not have a huge impact on the system - but that's just speculation, i don't know if it has had an impact on the stocks like you suggest.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoFun fact: In 1952 when this movie was made only about 4.2% of the US population owned any stocks. After the Depression it took a generation or more before many people were willing to invest in stocks and not view the stock market as some sort of gambling casino. Of course as we transitioned away from pensions in the 80s towards self directed retirement plans like 401k's that began to change as more people were suddenly finding themselves owning stocks and mutual funds.
- xivzgrev 5y agoObligatory “if you invested $100k in 1952 in s&p 500, you’d have $152m today”. Or $14m in real terms https://www.in2013dollars.com/us/stocks/s-p-500/1952 https://www.in2013dollars.com/us/stocks/s-p-500/1952